JAMES CRICHTON OF ELIOCK
We must, however, be just to the Duke, who, in the midst
of his self-imposed religious duties, found time, through
Zibramonti, to invite the Capitano di Giustizia to investigate
the deaths of Crichton and Lanzone, " to establish the most
minute circumstances, and to punish the culprits." The report
of the Capitano di Giustizia to Zibramonti, dated from Mantua,
6th July, 1582, tends to exonerate the Prince. "From every-
thing," says he, " it is acknowledged to have been an accidental
affray, the one party not knowing the other until after the
unhappy success of the wounds ; and that all the information is
well disposed in favour of his Highness [the Prince's] doings in
this affair; and that there reasonably follow his acquittal and
liberation for justice's sake." But even in this report there is a
significant qualification
:
"
always provided that his Highness be
so content both to repress every sinister opinion of the world, as
also to remove from his most serene person every stain that the
[evil] deeds of men are wont to bring to those who commit
them."
Nevertheless, in Mantua and in other parts of Italy it was
believed that the Prince had been guilty of murder ; indeed, an
instructive little dispatch, dated from Venice, 14th July, 1582, is
couched in the following significant words :
"The Prince of Mantua has retired to Ferrara to await the
conclusion of the trial which is now taking place concerning the
death of the Scotsman, to prove that his Highness did kill him
to defend himself."
Another " avviso " preserved in the State Archives at Modena
contradicts the opinion given by the Capitano di Giustizia, for
from it one learns that Vincenzo was condemned to banishment
from Mantua for a period of twelve months. Here is a transla-
tion of the note, which is dated from Venice, 4th August, 1582 :*
1 Document in Archivio di Stato in Modena {Cancelleria Ducale), for which, with others,
the writer acknowledges the courtesy of the Director of the Archives.
359