174
JEROME.
quietly and would not have exercised his office. And should the bishop have seen fit
to rend the church on that score, he would
then have owed him nothing save the re-
spect which is due to all who offer sacrifice.1 9. So much for his prolix defence of him- self or I should rather say his attack on me.
In this letter I have only answered him
briefly and cursorily that from what I have
said he may perceive what I do not say, and
may know that as I am a human being I am a rational animal and well able to understand
his shrewdness, and that I am not so obtuse
or brutish as to catch only the sound of his
words and not their meaning. I now ask of
you to pardon my chagrin and to allow that
if it is arrogant to answer back, it is yet
more arrogant to bring baseless charges.
Yet my answer has indicated what I might
have said rather than has actually said it.
Why do men look for peace at a distance ?
and why do they wish to have it enforced by
word of command ? Let them shew them-
selves peacemakers, and peace will follow
at once. Why do they use the name of your
holiness to terrorize us, when your letter —
strange contrast to their harsh and menacing
words — breathes only peace and meekness ?
For that the letter which Isidore the presby-
ter has brought for me from you does make
for peace and harmony I know by this, that
these insincere professors of a wish for peace have refused to deliver it to me. Let them
choose whichever alternative they please.
Either I am a good man or I am a bad one.
If I am a good one let them leave me in quiet :
if I am a bad one, why do they desire to be
in bad company ? Surely my opponent has
learnt by experience the value of humility.
He who now tears asunder things which, for-
merly separate, he of his own will put together,
proves that in severing now what he then
joined, he is acting at the instigation of an-
other.2 10. Recently he sought and obtained a de-
cree of exile against me, and I only wish that
he had been able to carry it out,3 so that, as the will is imputed to him for the deed, so I
too not in will only but in deed might wear the crown of exile. The church of Christ has
been founded by shedding its own blood not
that of others, by enduring outrage not by in-
flicting it. Persecutions have made it grow ;
martyrdoms have crowned it. Or if the Chris-
tians among whom I live are unique in their
love of severity and know only how to perse-
1 Here as frequently in Jerome the word ' sacerdos ' is used to denote a bishop.
2 Probably Isidore, who had taken a view hostile to Jerome, and who at this time fell under the displeasure of Theophilus.
3 The execution of the decree was stopped by the sudden death of the imperial minister Rufinus.
cute and not how to undergo persecution,
there are Jews here, there are heretics pro-
fessing various false doctrines, and in partic-
ular the foulest of all, I mean, Manichseism.
Why is it that they do not venture to say a
word against them ? Why am I the only per-
son they wish to drive into exile ? Am I who
communicate with the church the only person
of whom it can be said that he rends the
church ? I put it to you, is it not a fair
demand either that they should expel these
others as well as myself, or that, if they keep
them, they should keep me too ? All the
same they honour men by sending them into
exile, for by so doing they separate them from
the company of heretics. It is a monk,1 shame to say, who menaces monks and ob- tains decrees of exile against them ; and that
too a monk who boasts that he holds an apos- tolic chair. But the monastic tribe does not
succumb to terrorism : it prefers to expose its
neck to the impending sword rather than to
allow its hands to be tied. Is not every monk
an exile from his country ? Is he not an ex- ile from the whole, world ? Where is the need
for the public authority, the cost of a rescript,
the journeyings up and down the earth to ob- tain one ? Let him but touch me with his
little finger, and I will go into exile of myself.
" The earth is the Lord's and the fulness
thereof."2 Christ is not shut up in any one
spot. ii. Moreover when he writes that, though
I seem to be separated from communion with
him, I in reality hold communion with him
through you and through the church of
Rome : he need not go so far afield, for I am
connected with him in the same way also here
in Palestine. And lest even this should ap-
pear distant, in this village of Bethlehem I
hold communion with his presbyters as much
as I can. Thus it is clear that a private cha-
grin is not to be taken for the cause of the
church, and that one man's choler, or even that of several stirred up by him, ought not
to be styled the displeasure of the church.
Accordingly I now repeat what I said at the
beginning of my letter that I for my part am
desirous of Christ's peace, that I pray for har- mony, and that I request you to admonish
him not to exact peace but to purpose it.
Let him be satisfied with the pain which he
has caused by the insults that he has inflicted
upon me in the past. Let him efface old
wounds by a little new charity. Let him
shew himself what he was before, when of his
own choice he bestowed upon me his esteem.
Let his words no longer be tinged with a gall that flows from the heart of another. Let him
do what he wishes himself, and not what others
1 John of Jerusalem. 8 Ps. xxiv. i.