{"author":null,"canonical_references":[],"date_end":null,"date_start":null,"deduplication_fingerprint":"cca0ae4ad0f253af0674f1fa3a7c714477c797118843754f738afb956333c6d0","edition_title":"The City of God, Volume II","edition_translators":["Marcus Dods","George Wilson (Books XVII-XVIII)"],"edition_year":1871,"explicit_reference_candidates":[],"headings":["THE CITY OF GOD.","BOOK TWENTY-FIRST.","ARGUMENT."],"id":"pg45305-paragraph-655","license_url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/policy/license.html","note_targets":[],"public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"original-paragraph-unclassified","review_required":["work and recension attribution","original-work chronology","Bible reference numbering and citation kind","English edition rights and attribution"],"review_status":"needs_review","rights_evidence":"Provider catalog reports public domain in the USA. Original transcription title leaves state T. & T. Clark, Edinburgh, 1871; printed translator allocation retained. Gutenberg credits Internet Archive/Canadian Libraries without an exact scan identifier. Full provider license preserved with acquired original; republication and per-work metadata remain unreviewed.","source_anchor":null,"source_ebook":45305,"source_html":"<p>But, say they, there is no body which can suffer and cannot\r\nalso die. How do we know this? For who can say with\r\ncertainty that the devils do not suffer in their bodies, when<span class=\"pagenum\"><a id=\"Page_415\">[Pg 415]</a></span>\r\nthey own that they are grievously tormented? And if it is\r\nreplied that there is no earthly body—that is to say, no solid\r\nand perceptible body, or, in one word, no flesh—which can\r\nsuffer and cannot die, is not this to tell us only what men\r\nhave gathered from experience and their bodily senses? For\r\nthey indeed have no acquaintance with any flesh but that\r\nwhich is mortal; and this is their whole argument, that what\r\nthey have had no experience of they judge quite impossible.\r\nFor we cannot call it reasoning to make pain a presumption\r\nof death, while, in fact, it is rather a sign of life. For though\r\nit be a question whether that which suffers can continue to\r\nlive for ever, yet it is certain that everything which suffers\r\npain does live, and that pain can exist only in a living subject.\r\nIt is necessary, therefore, that he who is pained be living, not\r\nnecessary that pain kill him; for every pain does not kill even\r\nthose mortal bodies of ours which are destined to die. And\r\nthat any pain kills them is caused by the circumstance that the\r\nsoul is so connected with the body that it succumbs to great\r\npain and withdraws; for the structure of our members and\r\nvital parts is so infirm that it cannot bear up against that violence\r\nwhich causes great or extreme agony. But in the life to\r\ncome this connection of soul and body is of such a kind, that\r\nas it is dissolved by no lapse of time, so neither is it burst\r\nasunder by any pain. And so, although it be true that in\r\nthis world there is no flesh which can suffer pain and yet\r\ncannot die, yet in the world to come there shall be flesh such\r\nas now there is not, as there will also be death such as\r\nnow there is not. For death will not be abolished, but\r\nwill be eternal, since the soul will neither be able to enjoy\r\nGod and live, nor to die and escape the pains of the body.\r\nThe first death drives the soul from the body against her will:\r\nthe second death holds the soul in the body against her will.\r\nThe two have this in common, that the soul suffers against\r\nher will what her own body inflicts.</p>","source_sha256":"7e0ced9e70512f3cf050b53c9d548e36b70d468d875153869f95d8aff5bbb530","source_url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/45305/pg45305-images.html","text_sha256":"6ea8d873f46a6d839014939c04ec2ee595d79c570aa053e88bb709ee64131eb6","verified":false,"work_id":null}