{"author":null,"canonical_references":[],"database_sha256":"8cfbe7284c6936871d57c02dc6aa63ebbdfd4722422d539dd9f716e46e91112e","date_end":null,"date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"id":"sermonindex-ecf-13071","native_reference":{"book_number":470,"chapter_from":27,"chapter_to":27,"system":"MyBible module coordinates (mapping unverified)","verse_from":45,"verse_to":45},"public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"verse-keyed-module-record","review_required":["English edition and exact text","author/work attribution","dating","verse mapping and citation kind","reuse and attribution","split author quotations and deduplicate"],"review_status":"unreviewed","source_html":"<p><b>Apollinaris of Laodicea</b>: Now a certain Phlegon, a philosopher among the Greeks, recollects this darkness as an incredible occurrence in the fourteenth [night] of the moon, when an eclipse should not have appeared … for eclipses occur at the time when these two stars [the sun and the moon] draw near to one another. An eclipse of the sun happens at the conjunction of the sun and the moon as it runs into its way. This is not the time of the full moon, when the sun is diametrically opposed to the moon. But the eclipse occurred as creation mourned over what had happened, signifying that the drunken behavior of the Jews was linked to a darkened mind. The sunshine of the intellect had departed from them. For if they had been considering him—for that darkness found its source in the wrathful one and was evidence of what was about to overtake the murderers.<br/><i>— FRAGMENT 142.17</i></p><p><b>Jerome</b>: (Verse 45) But at the sixth hour, darkness came over the whole land until the ninth hour. Those who wrote against the Gospels suspect a solar eclipse, which usually occurs at certain fixed times, as the reason for the disciples of Christ being misunderstood about the resurrection of the Lord: since a solar eclipse only occurs when the moon is rising. However, there is no doubt that during the time of Passover, the moon was full. And so it would not seem that the shadow of the earth, or the opposite side of the moon, made brief and rusty darkness, is placed in a space of three hours, so that every opportunity of causing harm is removed. And I think this was done in order to fulfill the prophecy, saying: The sun shall go down at noon, and it shall be dark over the earth in broad daylight (Amos 8:9); and in another place: The sun went down while it was still day (Jeremiah 15:9). And it seems to me that the most radiant light of the world, that is, the greater luminary, withdrew its rays so as not to see the Lord hanging, or so that the wicked blasphemers might not enjoy their own light.<br/><i>— Commentary on Matthew</i></p><p><b>John Chrysostom</b>: This is the sign which before He had promised to give them when they asked it, saying, \"An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign, and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas;\" meaning His cross, and His death, His burial, and His resurrection. And again, declaring in another way the virtue of the cross, He said, \"When ye have lifted up the Son of Man, then shall ye know that I am He.\" And what He saith is to this purport: \"When ye have crucified me, and think ye have overcome me, then, above all, shall ye know my might.\"</p><p>For after the crucifixion, the city was destroyed, and the Jewish state came to an end, they fell away from their polity and their freedom, the gospel flourished, the word was spread abroad to the ends of the world; both sea and land, both the inhabited earth and the desert perpetually proclaim its power. These things then He meaneth, and those which took place at the very time of the crucifixion. For indeed it was much more marvellous that these things should be done, when He was nailed to the cross, than when He was walking on earth. And not in this respect only was the wonder, but because from heaven also was that done which they had sought, and it was over all the world, which had never before happened, but in Egypt only, when the passover was to be fulfilled. For indeed those events were a type of these.</p><p>And observe when it took place. At midday, that all that dwell on the earth may know it, when it was day all over the world; which was enough to convert them, not by the greatness of the miracle only, but also by its taking place in due season. For after all their insulting, and their lawless derision, this is done, when they had let go their anger, when they had ceased mocking, when they were satiated with their jeerings, and had spoken all that they were minded; then He shows the darkness, in order that at least so (having vented their anger) they may profit by the miracle. For this was more marvellous than to come down from the cross, that being on the cross He should work these things. For whether they thought He Himself had done it, they ought to have believed and to have feared; or whether not He, but the Father, yet thereby ought they to have been moved to compunction, for that darkness was a token of His anger at their crime. For that it was not an eclipse, but both wrath and indignation, is not hence alone manifest, but also by the time, for it continued three hours, but an eclipse takes place in one moment of time, and they know it, who have seen this; and indeed it hath taken place even in our generation.</p><p>And how, you may say, did not all marvel, and account Him to be God? Because the race of man was then held in a state of great carelessness and vice. And this miracle was but one, and when it had taken place, immediately passed away; and no one was concerned to inquire into the cause of it, and great was the prejudice and the habit of ungodliness. And they knew not what was the cause of that which took place, and they thought perhaps this happened so, in the way of an eclipse or some natural effect. And why dost thou marvel about them that are without, that knew nothing, neither inquired by reason of great indifference, when even those that were in Judaea itself, after so many miracles, yet continued using Him despitefully, although He plainly showed them that He Himself wrought this thing.<br/><i>— Homily on the Gospel of Matthew 88</i></p><p><b>Origen of Alexandria</b>: And from the sixth hour there was darkness over the whole earth until the ninth hour. From this text certain people malign the truth of the Gospel, saying: how can what is said be true according to the text, namely that there was darkness over the whole earth from the sixth hour until the ninth, since no history records that this happened? And they say that, just as usually happens in an eclipse of the sun, so an eclipse of the sun occurred at that time.</p><p>Now an eclipse of the sun has always occurred throughout the ages at its own time. But the eclipse of the sun which is wont to happen according to the customary course of the seasons as they run does not occur at any other time than at the conjunction of the sun and the moon, when the moon, running beneath, obstructs the rays of the sun by coming to meet it, and by its encounter blunts its light. But at the time when Christ suffered it is manifest that there was no conjunction of the moon with the sun, since it was the Passover season, which is customary to keep when the moon has the fullness of the sun and is present the whole night.</p><p>How then could there be an eclipse of the sun, when the moon was full and had the fullness of the sun?</p><p>But certain believers, wishing to introduce some defense against these arguments, hard pressed by the words of those who professed such things, spoke thus: if no new portent had happened at the time of Christ's passion but everything according to custom, it would be believed that that eclipse of the sun had happened according to custom; but now, since it is established that the other portents which happened then did not happen according to custom, but were new and wondrous (for indeed \"the veil of the temple was torn into two parts from top to bottom, and the earth quaked, and the rocks were split, and the tombs were opened and many bodies of the sleeping saints rose again\"), it is manifest that that eclipse of the sun too, consequently, in keeping with the other new portents, happened contrary to custom. Again, against these things the \"sons of this age\" who are \"wiser than the sons of light in their generation\" say such things as this: grant that that eclipse of the sun happened contrary to custom at a time not ancient, under the rule of the Romans, so that darkness fell over the whole earth until the ninth hour — how is it that no one of the Greeks, no one of the barbarians, recorded that so marvelous a thing had happened at that time, especially those who wrote and noted chronicles, whenever any such new thing ever happened, but only your authors have written this? And a certain Phlegon wrote in his Chronicles that it happened in the rule of Tiberius Caesar, but he did not indicate that this happened at the full moon.</p><p>See therefore whether this objection is not strong and able to move every wise man (who agrees neither with those who say these things nor with those who write those things, but hears everything with reason and judgment), and it is indeed not hard … and every one of the faithful (who indeed believes, yet does not believe with reason and with judgment), so that he may be so constant in faith that, even if they bring a thousand charges against the faith of the Gospel wishing to destroy our faith, he may in no part of them be shaken by the words of those who (pretending to believe the Gospel scriptures) through the occasion of one or another question, whether difficult or perhaps even insoluble, opposing the scriptures, hasten to take away the faith of Christ and of his Gospels from our soul, introducing certain moral matters and wishing to transfer the wonders accomplished by the power of God to certain secular customs. I have therefore judged it good, taking up the good purpose of those who desire to be constant in the faith, to find solutions to their accusations (as far as there is power in me from God) on behalf of the truth of the Gospel, so that the faithful may be fortified in faith not only by simple faith, but also by the reason of faith.</p><p>We say therefore that Matthew and Mark did not say that an eclipse of the sun then happened, and neither did Luke, according to very many copies which have it thus: \"and it was about the sixth hour, and darkness fell over the whole earth until the ninth hour, and the sun was darkened\". But in certain copies it does not have: \"darkness fell and the sun was darkened\"; but thus: \"darkness fell over the whole earth, the sun failing\". And perhaps someone ventured (as though wishing to say something more manifest) to put, in place of: \"and the sun was darkened\", \"the sun failing\", supposing that the darkness could not have happened otherwise than by \"the sun failing\".</p><p>But I rather think that those who lie in wait for the Church of Christ altered this word, so that it read \"darkness fell, the sun failing\", in order that the Gospels might plausibly be refuted according to the contrivances of those wishing to refute them. I judge therefore that, just as the other signs which happened in his passion happened in Jerusalem only, so also the darkness was made over the whole earth of Judea only until the ninth hour. And the things I say happened in Jerusalem only are these: that \"the veil of the temple was torn\", that \"the earth quaked\", that \"the rocks were split\", that \"the tombs were opened\". For neither outside Judea \"were the rocks split\", nor \"were tombs opened\" other than only those which were in Jerusalem or perhaps in the land of Judea, nor did any other \"earth quake\" then except the earth of Jerusalem — for it is nowhere recorded that every element of the earth quaked at that time, so that (for example) both those who were in Ethiopia and those in India and in Scythia should feel it (which, had it happened, would without doubt be found in some histories of those who wrote in chronicles any new events). Just as, therefore, when it is said \"the earth quaked\", this refers to the earth of Jerusalem or (if one wishes to extend it more widely) to the earth of Judea, so also the darkness that fell from the sixth hour until the ninth over the whole earth was made over the whole earth of Judea, or certainly over Jerusalem only. Thus, therefore, whoever understands it this way understands it without fault, so that he may not, wishing to display the greatness of the miracle, fall into the mockery of the wise of \"this age\", and work unbelief rather than faith in wise men.</p><p>But someone says against these things: if the darkness then over the whole earth of Judea and Jerusalem was not made from an eclipse of the sun but from another cause, show the cause. To such we answer this: first indeed, that the evangelists did not at all name the sun in this place, but only that darkness fell over the whole earth. If therefore darkness fell over the whole earth with the sun not named, without doubt it follows to understand that certain most dark clouds, and perhaps not one but many and very great ones, ran together over the earth of Judea and Jerusalem to cover the rays of the sun, and therefore deep darkness fell from the sixth hour until the ninth. But since we have come to such a place, we say, lest perhaps also the \"palpable darkness\" in Egypt was made in this manner for \"three days\", not from an eclipse of the sun, but either because dark clouds ran together into one, or because the air there then became thicker over the Egyptians only — for \"to all the sons of Israel\", as the scripture testifies, \"there was light in all the places in which they were dwelling\".</p><p>For it is also impossible in an eclipse of the sun, which happens from the coming together of the moon to the sun, for darkness to be made for \"three\" continuous \"days\"; and it would be believed that there was some other cause of the darkness in Egypt, if the sun had even been named, or as though darkened at that time. But now the scripture of Exodus says nothing else except that \"Moses stretched out his hand to heaven, and there was darkness and gloom and the rest over the whole land of Egypt for three days; and no one saw his brother, nor did anyone rise from his bed for three days\".</p><p>But as to my saying over the whole earth of Judea or Jerusalem, so that we may not understand every element of the earth, this is the proof, which is written in the third book of Kingdoms, where Obadiah the steward of Ahab said to Elijah: \"what have I sinned, that you have given your servant into the hands of Ahab, that he may put me to death? As your God lives, if there is a nation or kingdom where my lord has not sent to seek you, and I said: he is not here, and he burned the kingdom and its regions, because he did not find you\". For who would be so stony, reading these things, as to suppose that Ahab king of Israel sent into every nation of the world and into every kingdom of the whole earth seeking Elijah, and burned wherever it was said: Elijah is not here? But without doubt those things were said hyperbolically, showing that he sought him abundantly among the nations that were around Judea, according as he was able to seek. And we have said also in other places that, since two general creatures were made on the sixth day, first indeed the animals, and then man made \"according to the image of God\", it follows that that sixth day too should be understood as then having been divided into two kinds of creature, so that before the sixth hour the animals should be understood to have been created, but at the sixth hour the Lord said: \"let us make man to our image\" and made him then. … on which account it was fitting that, for the salvation of that same man, he who was dying should be hung up at that very sixth hour, and from the sixth hour for this reason the darkness should be made over the whole earth until the ninth. And just as, when Moses stretched out his hand \"to heaven\", \"darkness was made over the Egyptians\", who held the servants of God in servitude, an image of the future darkness which was to seize the Egyptians, similarly also when Christ at the sixth hour stretched out his hands on the cross to heaven over the people who had cried out: \"take this man from the earth\", and \"crucify, crucify him\", darkness was made, and they were deprived of all light.</p><p>And that darkness was an image of the future darkness which was to seize the Jewish nation, because they dared to lay their hands upon the true light.</p><p>Whence from that time all that nation has been filled with darkness, as the prophet says: \"let their eyes be darkened that they may not see\".</p><p>Likewise under Moses \"there was darkness and gloom over the whole land of Egypt for three days; and no one saw his brother, nor did anyone rise from his bed for three days; but to all the sons of Israel there was light in all the places in which they were dwelling\". But under Christ darkness fell over the whole earth of Judea for three hours, but there was light over all the rest of the earth. Which everywhere illumines the whole Church of God in Christ.</p><p>And if until the ninth hour there was darkness over the whole earth of Judea, it is manifest that light shone upon them again, because \"when the multitude of the Gentiles has entered in, then all Israel shall be saved\". But that the darkness was made over the whole earth of Judea for three hours, this shows that on account of their sins they were deprived of the light of three hours: of the light of God the Father and of the splendor of Christ and of the illumination of the Holy Spirit.<br/><i>— COMMENTARY ON Matthew 134</i></p><p><b>Origen of Alexandria ((as quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274))</b>: Some take occasion from this text to cavil against the truth of the Gospel. For indeed from the beginning eclipses of the sun have happened in their proper seasons; but such an eclipse as would be brought about by the ordinary course of the seasons could only be at such time as the sun and moon come together, when the moon passing beneath intercepts the sun's rays. But at the time of Christ's passion it is clear that this was not the case, because it was the paschal feast, which it was customary to celebrate when the moon was full. Some believers, desiring to produce some answer to this objection, have said, that this eclipse in accordance with the other prodigies was an exception to the established laws of nature.</p><p>Against this the children of this world urge, How is it that of the Greeks and Barbarians, who have made observations of these things, not one has recorded so remarkable a phenomenon as this? Phlegon indeed has recorded such an event as happening in the time of Tiberius Caesar, but he has not mentioned that it was at the full moon. I think therefore that, like the other miracles which took place at the Passion, the rending of the veil, and the earthquake, this also was confined to Jerusalem. Or, if any one chooses, it may be extended to the whole of Judæa; as in the book of Kings, Abdias said to Elias, As the Lord thy God liveth, there is no nation or kingdom whither my lord hath not sent to seek thee, (1 Kings 18:10.) meaning that he had been sought in the countries round about Judæa. Accordingly we might suppose many and dense clouds to have been brought together over Jerusalem and Judæa, enough to produce thick darkness from the sixth to the ninth hour. For we understand that there were two creatures created on the sixth day, the beasts before the sixth hour, man on the sixth; and therefore it was fitting that He who died for the salvation of man should be crucified at the sixth hour, and for this cause that darkness should be over the whole earth from the sixth to the ninth hour. And as by Moses stretching out his hands towards heaven darkness was brought upon the Egyptians who held the servants of God in bondage, so likewise when at the sixth hour Christ stretched out his hands on the cross to heaven, darkness came over all the people who had cried out, Crucify him, and they were deprived of all light as a sign of the darkness that should come, and that should envelop the whole people of the Jews. Further, under Moses there was darkness over the land of Egypt three days, but all the children of Israel had light; so under Christ there was darkness over all Judæa for three hours, because for their sins they were deprived of the light of God the Father, the splendour of Christ, and the illumination of the Holy Spirit. But over the rest of the earth there is light, which every where illumines the Church of God in Christ. And if to the ninth hour there was darkness over Judæa, it is manifest that light returned to them again after that; so, when the fulness of the Gentiles shall have entered in, then all Israel shall be saved. (Rom. 11:25.)<br/><i>— Catena Aurea by Aquinas</i></p><p><b>Pseudo-Chrysostom ((as quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274))</b>: Creation could not bear the outrage offered to the Creator; whence the sun withdrew his beams, that he might not look upon the crime of these impious men.<br/><i>— Catena Aurea by Aquinas</i></p><p><b>Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite ((as quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274))</b>: (ad Polycarp. Ep. 7.) When we were together at Heliopolis, we both observed such an interference of the moon with the sun quite unexpectedly, for it was not the season of their conjunction; and then from the ninth hour until evening, beyond the power of nature, continuing in a direct line between us and the sun. And this obscuration we saw begin from the east, and so pass to the extreme of the sun's orb, and again return back the same way, being thus the very reverse of an ordinary eclipse.<br/><i>— Catena Aurea by Aquinas</i></p><p><b>Tertullian</b>: But My People hath changed their glory: whence no profit shall accrue to them: the heaven turned pale thereat\" (and when did it turn pale? undoubtedly when Christ suffered), \"and shuddered,\" he says, \"most exceedingly; \" and \"the sun grew dark at mid-day: \" (and when did it \"shudder exceedingly\" except at the passion of Christ, when the earth also trembled to her centre, and the veil of the temple was rent, and the tombs were burst asunder? \"because these two evils hath My People done; Me,\" He says, \"they have quite forsaken, the fount of water of life, and they have digged for themselves worn-out tanks, which will not be able to contain water.<br/><i>— An Answer to the Jews</i></p><p><b>Tertullian</b>: And so the \"pressure\" must be maintained up to that hour in which the orb-involved from the sixth hour in a general darkness-performed for its dead Lord a sorrowful act of duty; so that we too may then return to enjoyment when the universe regained its sunshine. If this savours more of the spirit of Christian religion, while it celebrates more the glory of Christ, I am equally able, from the self-same order of events, to fix the condition of late protraction of the Station; (namely), that we are to fast till a late hour, awaiting the time of the Lord's sepulture, when Joseph took down and entombed the body which he had requested.<br/><i>— On Fasting</i></p>","source_html_sha256":"2f18c37249b50de768507664cee23ca24d1240af1a8e66afa6244cbb430768a9","source_module":"ECF","source_row_id":13071,"source_url":"https://www.sermonindex.net/commentary/ecf/","text_sha256":"69a4bb4971e7cb5629b5f737d0cbee8af4e2070086e4bcd0077ae565ed6c2ea7","translator":null,"work":null}