whom you believe in as the Son of God. What incredible thing is it, then, if some one soul
be assumed by Him in an ineffable and unique manner for the salvation of many? Moreover,
our nature itself testifies that a man is incomplete unless a body be united with the soul.
This certainly would be more incredible, were it not of all things the most common; for we
should more easily believe in a union between spirit and spirit, or, to use your own termin-
ology, between the incorporeal and the incorporeal, even though the one were human, the
other divine, the one changeable and the other unchangeable, than in a union between the
corporeal and the incorporeal. But perhaps it is the unprecedented birth of a body from a
virgin that staggers you? But, so far from this being a difficulty, it ought rather to assist you
to receive our religion, that a miraculous person was born miraculously. Or, do you find a
difficulty in the fact that, after His body had been given up to death, and had been changed
into a higher kind of body by resurrection, and was now no longer mortal but incorruptible,
He carried it up into heavenly places? Perhaps you refuse to believe this, because you re-
member that Porphyry, in these very books from which I have cited so much, and which
treat of the return of the soul, so frequently teaches that a body of every kind is to be escaped
from, in order that the soul may dwell in blessedness with God. But here, in place of following
Porphyry, you ought rather to have corrected him, especially since you agree with him in
200
believing such incredible things about the soul of this visible world and huge material frame.
For, as scholars of Plato, you hold that the world is an animal, and a very happy animal,
which you wish to be also everlasting. How, then, is it never to be loosed from a body, and
yet never lose its happiness, if, in order to the happiness of the soul, the body must be left
behind? The sun, too, and the other stars, you not only acknowledge to be bodies, in which
you have the cordial assent of all seeing men, but also, in obedience to what you reckon a
profounder insight, you declare that they are very blessed animals, and eternal, together
with their bodies. Why is it, then, that when the Christian faith is pressed upon you, you
forget, or pretend to ignore, what you habitually discuss or teach? Why is it that you refuse
to be Christians, on the ground that you hold opinions which, in fact, you yourselves demol-
ish? Is it not because Christ came in lowliness, and ye are proud? The precise nature of the
resurrection bodies of the saints may sometimes occasion discussion among those who are
best read in the Christian Scriptures; yet there is not among us the smallest doubt that they
shall be everlasting, and of a nature exemplified in the instance of Christ’s risen body. But
whatever be their nature, since we maintain that they shall be absolutely incorruptible and
immortal, and shall offer no hindrance to the soul’s contemplation, by which it is fixed in
God, and as you say that among the celestials the bodies of the eternally blessed are eternal,
why do you maintain that, in order to blessedness, every body must be escaped from? Why
do you thus seek such a plausible reason for escaping from the Christian faith, if not because,
as I again say, Christ is humble and ye proud? Are ye ashamed to be corrected? This is the
vice of the proud. It is, forsooth, a degradation for learned men to pass from the school of
459
Of the Incarnation of Our Lord Jesus Christ, Which the Platonists in Their…