For until the resurrection men are justly said to be in death; as every one is said to be in
sleep till he awakes. However, though we can say of persons in sleep that they are sleeping,
we cannot speak in this way of the dead, and say they are dying. For, so far as regards the
death of the body, of which we are now speaking, one cannot say that those who are already
separated from their bodies continue dying. But this, you see, is just what I was saying,—that
no words can explain how either the dying are said to live, or how the dead are said, even
after death, to be in death. For how can they be after death if they be in death, especially
when we do not even call them dying, as we call those in sleep, sleeping; and those in languor,
languishing; and those in grief, grieving; and those in life, living? And yet the dead, until
they rise again, are said to be in death, but cannot be called dying.
And therefore I think it has not unsuitably nor inappropriately come to pass, though
not by the intention of man, yet perhaps with divine purpose, that this Latin word moritur
cannot be declined by the grammarians according to the rule followed by similar words.
For oritur gives the form ortus est for the perfect; and all similar verbs form this tense from
their perfect participles. But if we ask the perfect of moritur, we get the regular answer
mortuus est, with a double u. For thus mortuusis pronounced, like fatuus, arduus, conspicuus,
and similar words, which are not perfect participles but adjectives, and are declined without
regard to tense. But mortuus, though in form an adjective, is used as perfect participle, as
if that were to be declined which cannot be declined; and thus it has suitably come to pass
that, as the thing itself cannot in point of fact be declined, so neither can the word significant
of the act be declined. Yet, by the aid of our Redeemer’s grace, we may manage at least to
decline the second. For that is more grievous still, and, indeed, of all evils the worst, since
it consists not in the separation of soul and body, but in the uniting of both in death eternal.
And there, in striking contrast to our present conditions, men will not be before or after
death, but always in death; and thus never living, never dead, but endlessly dying. And
never can a man be more disastrously in death than when death itself shall be deathless.
571
Whether One Can Both Be Living and Dead at the Same Time.