Chapter 17.—32. Marcellus of Zama1809 said: "Since sins are remitted only in the
baptism of the Church, he who does not baptize a heretic holds communion with a sin-
ner."1810
505
33. What, does he who holds communion with one who does this not hold communion
with a sinner? But what else did all of them do, "in judging no one, or removing from the
right of communion any one who entertained a different opinion"? Where, then, is the
Church? Are those things not an obstacle to those who are patient, and tolerate the tares
lest the wheat should be rooted out together with them? I would have them therefore say,
who have committed the sacrilege of schism by separating themselves from the whole world,
how it comes that they have in their mouths the judgment of Cyprian, while they do not
have in their hearts the patience of Cyprian. But to this Marcellus we have an answer in
what has been said above concerning baptism and the remission of sins, explaining how
there can be baptism in a man although there be in him no remission of his sins.
1809 Zama was in ecclesiastical province of Numidia. For Marcellus, see Cypr. Ep. lxvii.
1810 Conc. Carth. sec. 53.
Chapter 17
937
Chapter 17