About the period when personal attacks on the
Nicene leaders began to be exchanged for overt objections to the Nicene
Definitions, the claim was freely made that ‘the fathers’
had been condemned by the latter: in other words, that they had held
with the Arians (see below §1, ἀεὶ μὲν
προφάσεις…νῦν δὲ καὶ
διαβάλλειν
τοὺς πατέρας
τετολμήκασι).
Accordingly we find Athanasius at about the same date, viz. early in
the sole reign of Constantius, vindicating on the one hand the work of
the Council, on the other the orthodox reputation of Dionysius. The
Arians found material for their appeal to the latter in a letter
addressed by him to certain bishops in Pentapolis, called Ammon and
Euphranor. Whether or no Sabellius had been a native of that province,
at any rate his doctrine was at that time so popular there ‘that
the Son of God was scarcely any longer preached in the Churches.’
Exercising the right of supervision over those districts which had
already become vested by prescription in the Alexandrian See, Dionysius
wrote to Ammon, Bishop of Berenice, (Euseb. H. E. vii. 26, who
enumerates three several letters to Ammon, Telesphorus, and Euphranor,
and a fourth to Ammon and Euporus: he also refers to his letters to
Dionysius of Rome: Montfaucon is therefore scarcely fair in charging
Eusebius with suppressing the episode ‘ne verbum quidem de hac
historia fecerit!’) insisting on the distinctness of the Son from
the Father. In doing so he used strong expressions akin to the language
of Origen on the subordination of the Son. These expressions were at
once objected to by certain orthodox churchmen (§13, it is not
clear whether they belonged to Pentapolis or Alexandria), who without
consulting Dionysius went to Rome (about 260), and spoke against him in
the presence of his namesake, the Roman Bishop. The latter, true to the
traditions of his See since the time of Callistus (see Hipp.
Philos IX. vii. δίθεοι
ἔστε), while steering clear of
Sabellianism, was especially jealous of error in the opposite
direction. Accordingly he assembled a synod (de Synod. 44), and
drew up a letter to Alexandria, in which he rebuked firstly the
Sabellians, but secondly and more fully those who separate the Godhead
or speak of the Son as a work, including under this category certain
unnamed catechists and teachers of Alexandria (De Decr.
26). At the same time he wrote personally to Dionysius, informing him
that he was accused of maintaining
the opinions in question. In answer to this letter, Dionysius of
Alexandria drew up a treatise in four books, entitled ‘Refutation
and Defence,’ and addressed to his namesake of Rome, in which he
explained his language, and stated his belief in a manner which put an
end to the controversy. He had been charged with maintaining that the
Son was made, that He was not eternal (οὐκ ἀεὶ ἦν ὁ
θεὸς πατήρ,
οὐκ ἀεὶ ἦν ὁ
ὑιός,…οὐκ ἦν πρὶν
γεννήθῃ,
ἀλλ᾽ ἦν ποτὲ
ὅτε οὐκ ἦν
κ.τ.λ. §14), that he denied the
co-essentiality (ὁμοούσιον) of the
Son, and separated Him from the Father (§16, 18, cf. § 4,
ξένον
κατ᾽ οὐσίαν
κ.τ.λ). In his Refutation and Defence, Dionysius
admits the use of these expressions, withdraws the first (§15,
line 1) and admits the propriety of the ὁμοούσιον, although
he himself prefers Scriptural language (§ 18. The section shews
the unfixed use of the word. Dionysius had formerly used οὐσία in the sense of πρώτη
οὐσία, nearly as equivalent to ὑπόστασις: but now
he clearly takes it as δευτέρα
οὐσία, indicative not of Person but
of Nature). That the Son was made, he explains as an inadequate
formula, the word being applicable (in one of its many senses) to the
relation of son to father (§20. The defence of Athanasius, that
Dionysius referred to the Human Nature of Christ, is scarcely tenable.
It is not supported by what Dionysius himself says, rather the
contrary: and if his language did not refer to the Trinity, where would
be its relevancy against Sabellianism?). The words ἦν ὅτε
οὐκ ἦν, and οὐκ ἦν πρὶν
γεννήθῃ, he does not
explain, but professes his belief in the eternal union of the Word with
the Father (§§24, 25). Lastly, he repudiates the charge of
dividing the Holy Trinity, or of mentioning Father and Son as though
separate Beings: When I mention the Father, I have already mentioned
the Son, before I pronounce His Name (§17, the closing words of
the section are a complete formula of agreement with all that his Roman
namesake could possibly require of him).