The whole controversy, then,
between the Church and the Anomœans turns on this: Are we to
regard the Son and the Holy Spirit as belonging to created or uncreated
existence? Our opponent declares that to be the case which all deny: he
boldly lays it down, without looking about for any proof, that each
being is the work of the preceding being. What method of education,
what school of thought can warrant him in this, it is difficult to see.
Some axiom that cannot be denied or assailed must be the beginning of
every process of proof; so as for the unknown quantity to be
demonstrated from what has been assumed, being legitimately deduced by
intervening syllogisms. The reasoner, therefore, who makes what ought
to be the object of inquiry itself a premiss of his demonstration is
only proving the obscure by the obscure, and illusion by illusion. He
is making ‘the blind lead the blind,’ for it is a truly
blind and unsupported statement to say that the Creator and Maker of
all things is a creature made: and to this they link on a conclusion
that is also blind: namely, that the Son is alien in nature,
unlike in being to the Father, and quite devoid of His essential
character. But of this enough. Where his thought is nakedly
blasphemous, there we too can defer its refutation. We must now return
to consider his words which come next in order.