This was until the division
of the East and West the definition accepted by all the whole Christian
world. But since the Church has been divided, while the East has
kept to the old definition and has not pretended to have held any
Ecumenical Councils, the Roman Church has made a new definition of the
old term and has then proceeded to hold a very considerable number of
synods which she recognizes as Ecumenical. I say “a very
considerable number,” for even among Roman Catholic theologians
there is much dispute as to the number of these “Ecumenical
Synods,” the decrees of which, like those of Trent and the
Vatican, have never been received by about half of the Christian world,
including four of the five patriarchates and of the fifth patriarchate
all the Anglican communion. According to modern Roman writers the
definition of these non-ecumenically received Ecumenical Synods is
“Ecumenical councils are those to which the bishops and others
entitled to vote are convoked from the whole world under the Presidency
of the Pope or his legates, and the decrees of which, having received
Papal confirmation, bind all Christians.” Addis and Arnold,
A Catholic Dictionary, s. v. Councils. The reader will
notice that by this definition one at least (I. Constantinople),
probably three, of the seven undisputed Ecumenical Synods cease to be
such.