Now that we have so far
discussed these matters, let us resume consideration of our
adversaries’ argument. It says, “As all generation is not
protracted to infinity, but ceases on arriving at some end.” Now,
since the sense of “generation” has been considered with
respect to either meaning,—whether he intends by this word to
signify the birth of corporeal beings, or the formation of things
created (neither of which has anything in common with the unsullied
Nature), the premise is shown to have no connection with the subject i.
e.with the subject of discussion, the
generation of the Only-begotten.. For it is not a matter of absolute
necessity, as he maintains, that, because all making and generation
ceases at some limit, therefore those who accept the generation of the
Son should circumscribe it by a double limit, by supposing, as regards
it, a beginning and an end. For it is only as being circumscribed in
some quantitative way that things can be said either to begin or to
cease on arriving at a limit, and the measure expressed by time (having
its extension concomitant with the quantity of that which is produced)
differentiates the beginning from the end by the interval between them.
But how can any one measure or treat as extended that which is without
quantity and without extension? What measure can he find for that which
has no quantity, or what interval for that which has no extension? or
how can any one define the infinite by “end” and
“beginning?” for “beginning” and
“end” are names of limits of extension, and, where there is
no extension, neither is there any limit. Now the Divine Nature is
without extension, and, being without extension, it has no limit; and
that which is limitless is infinite, and is spoken of accordingly. Thus
it is idle to try to circumscribe the infinite by
“beginning” and “ending”—for what is
circumscribed cannot be infinite. How comes it, then, that this
Platonic Phædrus disconnectedly tacks on to his own doctrine those
speculations on the soul which Plato makes in that dialogue? For as
Plato there spoke of “cessation of motion,” so this writer
too was eager to speak of “cessation of generation,” in
order to impose upon those who have no knowledge of these matters, with
fine Platonic phrases. “And these facts,” he tells us,
“cannot be disbelieved, on the ground at once of nature itself
and of the Divine laws.” But nature, from our previous remarks,
appears not to be trustworthy for instruction as to the Divine
generation,—not even if one were to take the universe itself as
an illustration of the argument: since through its creation also, as we
learn in the cosmogony of Moses, there ran the measure of time, meted
out in a certain order and arrangement by stated days and nights, for
each of the things that came into being: and this even our
adversaries’ statement does not admit with regard to the being of
the Only-begotten, since it acknowledges that the Lord was before the
times of the ages.