Excursus on the Number of the Nicene Canons.
There has come down to us a Latin letter purporting to
have been written by St. Athanasius to Pope Marcus. This letter
is found in the Benedictine edition of St. Athanasius’s works
(ed. Patav. ii. 599) but rejected as spurious by Montfaucon the learned
editor. In this letter is contained the marvellous assertion that
the Council of Nice at first adopted forty canons, which were in Greek,
that it subsequently added twenty Latin canons, and that afterwards the
council reassembled and set forth seventy altogether. A tradition
that something of the kind had taken place was prevalent in parts of
the East, and some collections did contain seventy canons.
In the Vatican Library is a
ms.
which was bought for it by the famous Asseman, from the Coptic
Patriarch, John, and which contains not only seventy, but eighty canons
attributed to the council of Nice. The
ms.
is in Arabic, and was discovered by J. B. Romanus, S.
J., who first made its contents known, and translated into Latin a copy
he had made of it. Another Jesuit, Pisanus, was writing a history
of the Nicene Council at the time and he received the eighty newly
found canons into his book; but, out of respect to the
pseudo-Athanasian letter, he at first cut down the number to seventy;
but in later editions he followed the
ms.
All this was in the latter half of the sixteenth century; and in 1578
Turrianus, who had had Father Romanus’s translation revised
before it was first published, now issued an entirely new translation
with a
Proëmium
104
containing a vast amount
of information upon the whole subject, and setting up an attempted
proof that the number of the Nicene Canons exceeded twenty. His
argument for the time being carried the day.
Hefele says, “it is certain that the
Orientals
105
believed the Council
of Nice to have promulgated more than twenty canons: the learned
Anglican, Beveridge,
106
has proved this,
reproducing an ancient Arabic paraphrase of the canons of the first
four Ecumenical Councils. According to this Arabic paraphrase,
found in a
ms.
in the Bodleian Library, the
Council of Nice must have put forth three books of canons.…The
Arabic paraphrase of which we are speaking gives a paraphrase of all
these canons, but Beveridge took only the part referring to the second
book—that is to say, the paraphrase of the twenty genuine canons;
for, according to his view, which was perfectly correct, it was only
these twenty canons which were really the work of the Council of Nice,
and all the others were falsely attributed to it.”
107
Hefele goes on to prove that the canons he rejects must
be of much later origin, some being laws of the times of Theodosius and
Justinian according to the opinion of Renaudot.
108
Before leaving this point I should notice the profound
research on these Arabic canons of the Maronite, Abraham
Echellensis. He gives eighty-four canons in his Latin translation
of 1645, and was of opinion that they had been collected from different
Oriental sources, and sects; but that originally they had all been
translated from the Greek, and were collected by James, the celebrated
bishop of Nisibis, who was present at Nice. But this last
supposition is utterly untenable.
Among the learned there have not been wanting some who
have held that the Council of Nice passed more canons than the twenty
we possess, and have arrived at the conclusion independently of the
Arabic discovery, such are Baronius and Card. d’Aguirre, but
their arguments have been sufficiently answered, and they cannot
present anything able to weaken the conclusion that flows from the
consideration of the following facts.
(Hefele:
History of the Councils
, Vol. I. pp. 355
et seqq
. [2d
ed.])
Let us see first what is the testimony of those Greek
and Latin authors who lived about the time of the Council, concerning
the number.
a. The first to be consulted among the Greek
authors is the learned Theodoret, who lived about a century after the
Council of Nicæa. He says, in his History of the
Church: “After the condemnation of the Arians, the bishops
assembled once more, and decreed twenty canons on ecclesiastical
discipline.”
b. Twenty years later, Gelasius, Bishop of
Cyzicus, after much research into the most ancient documents, wrote a
history of the Nicene Council. Gelasius also says expressly that
the Council decreed twenty canons; and, what is more important, he
gives the original text of these canons exactly in the same order, and
according to the tenor which we find elsewhere.
c. Rufinus is more ancient than these two
historians. He was born near the period when the Council of
Nicæa was held, and about half a century after he wrote his
celebrated history of the Church, in which he inserted a Latin
translation of the Nicene canons. Rufinus also knew only of these
twenty canons; but as he has divided the sixth and the eighth into two
parts, he has given twenty-two canons, which are exactly the same as
the twenty furnished by the other historians.
d. The famous discussion between the African
bishops and the Bishop of Rome, on the subject of appeals to Rome,
gives us a very important testimony on the true number of the Nicene
canons. The presbyter Apiarius of Sicca in Africa, having been
deposed for many crimes, appealed to Rome. Pope Zosimus
(417–418) took the appeal into consideration, sent legates to
Africa; and to prove that he had the right to act thus, he quoted a
canon of the Council of Nicæa, containing these words:
“When a bishop thinks he has been unjustly deposed by his
colleagues he may appeal to Rome, and the Roman bishop shall have the
business decided by
judices in partibus
.” The canon
quoted by the Pope does not belong to the Council of Nicæa, as he
affirmed; it was the fifth canon of the Council of Sardica (the seventh
in the Latin version). What explains the error of Zosimus is that
in the ancient copies the canons of Nicæa and Sardica are written
consecutively, with the same figures, and under the common title of
canons of the Council of Nicæa; and Zosimus might
optima
fide
fall into an error—which he shared with Greek authors,
his contemporaries, who also mixed the canons of Nicæa with those
of Sardica. The African bishops, not finding the canon quoted by
the Pope either in their Greek or in their Latin copies, in vain
consulted also the copy which Bishop Cecilian, who had himself been
present at the Council of Nicæa, had brought to Carthage.
The legates of the Pope then declared that they did not rely upon these
copies, and they agreed to send to Alexandria and to Constantinople to
ask the patriarchs of these two cities for authentic copies of the
canons of the Council of Nicæa. The African bishops desired
in their turn that Pope Boniface should take the same step (Pope
Zosimus had died meanwhile in 418)—that he should ask for copies
from the Archbishops of Constantinople, Alexandria, and Antioch.
Cyril of Alexandria and Atticus of Constantinople, indeed, sent exact
and faithful copies of the Creed and canons of Nicæa; and two
learned men of Constantinople, Theilo and Thearistus, even translated
these canons into Latin. Their translation has been preserved to
us in the acts of the sixth Council of Carthage, and it contains only
the twenty ordinary canons. It might be thought at first sight
that it contained twenty-one canons; but on closer consideration we
see, as Hardouin has proved, that this twenty-first article is nothing
but an historical notice appended to the Nicene canons by the Fathers
of Carthage. It is conceived in these terms: “After
the bishops had decreed these rules at Nicæa, and after the holy
Council had decided what was the ancient rule for the celebration of
Easter, peace and unity of faith were re-established between the East
and the West. This is what we (the African bishops) have thought
it right to add according to the history of the Church.”
The bishops of
Africa despatched to Pope Boniface the copies which had been sent to
them from Alexandria and Constantinople, in the month of November 419;
and subsequently in their letters to Celestine I. (423–432),
successor to Boniface, they appealed to the text of these
documents.
e. All the ancient collections of canons, either
in Latin or Greek, composed in the fourth, or quite certainly at least
in the fifth century, agree in giving only these twenty canons to
Nicæa. The most ancient of these collections were made in
the Greek Church, and in the course of time a very great number of
copies of them were written. Many of these copies have descended
to us; many libraries possess copies; thus Montfaucon enumerates
several in his
Bibliotheca Coisliniana
. Fabricius makes a
similar catalogue of the copies in his
Bibliotheca Græca
to
those found in the libraries of Turin, Florence, Venice, Oxford,
Moscow, etc.; and he adds that these copies also contain the so-called
apostolic canons, and those of the most ancient councils. The
French bishop John Tilius presented to Paris, in 1540, a
ms.
of one of these Greek collections as it existed in the
ninth century. It contains exactly our twenty canons of
Nicæa, besides the so-called apostolic canons, those of Ancyra,
etc. Elias Ehmger published a new edition at Wittemberg in 1614,
using a second
ms.
which was found at Augsburg;
but the Roman collection of the Councils had before given in 1608, the
Greek text of the twenty canons of Nicæa. This text of the
Roman editors, with the exception of some insignificant variations, was
exactly the same as that of the edition of Tilius. Neither the
learned Jesuit Sirmond nor his coadjutors have mentioned what
manuscripts were consulted in preparing this edition; probably they
were manuscripts drawn from several libraries, and particularly from
that of the Vatican. The text of this Roman edition passed into
all the following collections, even into those of Hardouin and Mansi;
while Justell in his
Bibliotheca juris Canonici
and Beveridge in
his
Synodicon
(both of the eighteenth century), give a somewhat
different text, also collated from
mss.
, and
very similar to the text given by Tilius. Bruns, in his recent
Bibliotheca Ecclesiastica
, compares the two texts. Now all
these Greek
mss.
, consulted at such different
times, and by all these editors, acknowledge only twenty canons of
Nicæa, and always the same twenty which we possess.
The Latin collections of the canons of the Councils also
give the same result—for example, the most ancient and the most
remarkable of all, the
Prisca
, and that of Dionysius the Less,
which was collected about the year 500. The testimony of this
latter collection is the more important for the number twenty, as
Dionysius refers to the
Græca auctoritas
.
f. Among the later Eastern witnesses we may
further mention Photius, Zonaras and Balsamon. Photius, in his
Collection of the Canons
, and in his
Nomocanon
, as well
as the two other writers in their commentaries upon the canons of the
ancient Councils, quote only and know only twenty canons of Nicæa,
and always those which we possess.
g. The Latin canonists of the Middle Ages also
acknowledge only these twenty canons of Nicæa. We have proof
of this in the celebrated Spanish collection, which is generally but
erroneously attributed to St. Isidore (it was composed at the
commencement of the seventh century), and in that of Adrian (so called
because it was offered to Charles the Great by Pope Adrian I).
The celebrated Hincmar, Archbishop of Rheims, the first canonist of the
ninth century, in his turn attributes only twenty canons to the Council
of Nicæa, and even the pseudo-Isidore assigns it no more.
I add for the convenience of the reader the captions of
the Eighty Canons as given by Turrianus, translating them from the
reprint in Labbe and Cossart,
Concilia
, Tom. II. col. 291.
The Eighty-four Canons as given by Echellensis together with numerous
Constitutions and Decrees attributed to the Nicene Council are likewise
to be found in Labbe (
ut supra
, col. 318).
104
Vide
Labbe,
Conc
. ii. 287.
105
Who exactly these
Orientals
were Hefele does not specify, but Ffoulkes well points
out (
Dict. Christ. Antiq. sub voce
Councils of Nicæa) that
it is an entire mistake to suppose that the Greek Church “ever
quoted other canons [than the xx] as Nicene ‘by mistake,’
which were not Nicene, as popes Zosimus, Innocent and Leo
did.”
106
Beveridge,
Synod.
sive Pand
. i. 686.
107
Hefele:
Hist.
Councils
, I. 362.
108
Renaudot:
Hist.
Patriarcharum Alexandrianorum
Jacobitarum
. Paris, 1713, p.
75.