most eminent diving in New England who has appeared to maintain the Lord’s supper to
be properly a converting ordinance, was very full in it. In his Appeal to the Learned, in the
title-page, and through the Treatise, he supposes that all who come to the Lord’s supper,
must be visible saints, and sometimes speaks of them as professing saints, page 85, 86: and
437
supposes that it is requisite in order to their being admitted to the communion of the Lord’s
table, that they make a personal public profession of their faith and repentance to the just
satisfaction of the church, page 93, 94. In these things the whole of the position that I would
prove is in effect granted. If it be allowed (as it is allowed on all sides) that none ought to be
admitted to the communion of the christian visible church, but visible and professing saints
of Christians, if these words are used in any propriety of speech, or in any agreement with
scripture representations, the whole of that which I have laid down is either implied or will
certainly follow.
As real saints are the same with real converts, or really gracious persons, so visible saints
are the same with visible converts, or those that are visibly converted and gracious persons.
Visibility is the same with manifestation or appearance to our view and apprehension. And
therefore to be visibly a gracious person, is the same thing as to be a truly gracious person
to our view, apprehension, or esteem. The distinction of real and visible does not only take
place with regard to saintship or holiness, but with regard to innumerable other things.
There is visible and real truth, visible and real honesty, visible and real money, visible and
real gold, visible and real diamonds, &c. &c. Visible and real are words that stand related
one to another, as the words real and seeming, or true and apparent. Some seem to speak of
visibility with regard to saintship or holiness, as though it had no reference to the reality,
or as though it were a distinct reality by itself; as though by visible saints were not meant
those who to appearance are real saints or disciples indeed, but properly a distinct sort of
saints, which is an absurdity. There is a distinction between real money and visible money,
because all that is esteemed money and passes for money is not real money, but some is
false and counterfeit. By visible money, is not meant that which is taken and passes for a
different sort from true money, but that which is esteemed and taken as real money, or
which has that appearance that recommends it to men’s judgment and acceptance as true
money; though men may be deceived, and some of it may finally prove not to be so.
There are not properly two sorts of saints spoken of in Scripture. Though the word
saints may be said indeed to be used two ways in Scripture, or used so as to reach two sorts
of persons; yet the word has not properly two significations in the New Testament, any more
than the word gold has two significations among us: the word gold among us is so used as
to extend to several sorts of substances; it is true, it extends to true gold, and also to that
which only appears to be gold, and is reputed such, and by that appearance or visibility some
things that are not real obtain the name of gold; but this is not properly through a diversity
in the signification of the word, but by a diversity of the application of it, through the imper-
1755
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.