which is a vice, we may learn from kings and rulers, and commanders, and women, and
children, and citizens, and masters, and servants, and pedagogues, and teachers; for each
of these is useful to himself and to the public when he is temperate; but when he is licentious
he is injurious to himself and to the public. And if there be any difference between a filthy
man and a noble man, a licentious and a temperate; and if the character of the noble and
the temperate be the better, and that of the opposite the worse; and if those of the better
character be near to God and His friends, and those of the worse be far from Him and His
enemies, those who believe in fate make no distinction between righteousness and unright-
eousness, between filthiness and nobility, between licentiousness and temperance, which is
a contradiction. For if good be opposed to evil, and unrighteousness be evil, and this be
opposed to righteousness and righteousness be good, and good be hostile to evil, and evil
be unlike to good, then righteousness is different from unrighteousness. And therefore God
is not the cause of evils, nor does He rejoice in evils. Nor does reason commend them, being
good. If, then, any are evil, they are evil in accordance with the wants and desires of their
minds, and not by necessity.
“They perish self-destroyed,
By their own fault.”2753
If destiny2754 leads one on to kill a man, and to stain his hands with murder, and the
law forbids this, punishing criminals, and by threats restrains the decrees of destiny, such
as committing injustice, adultery, theft, poisoning, then the law is in opposition to destiny;
for those things which destiny appointed the law prohibits, and those things which the law
prohibits destiny compels men to do. Hence law is hostile to destiny. But if it be hostile,
343
then lawgivers do not act in accordance with destiny; for by passing decrees in opposition
to destiny they destroy destiny. Either, then, there is destiny and there was no need of laws;
or there are laws and they are not in accordance with destiny. But it is impossible that anyone
should be born or anything done apart from destiny; for they say it is not lawful for anyone
even to move a finger apart from fate. And therefore it was in accordance with destiny that
Minos and Dracon, and Lycurgus, and Solon, and Zaleukos were law-givers and appointed
laws, prohibiting adulteries, murders, violence, rape, thefts, as things which neither existed
nor took place in accordance with destiny. But if these things were in accordance with destiny,
then the laws were not in accordance with destiny. For destiny itself would not be destroyed
by itself, cancelling itself, and contending against itself; here appointing laws forbidding
adultery and murders, and taking vengeance upon and punishing the wicked, and there
producing murders and adulteries. But this is impossible: for nothing is alien and abhorrent
to itself, and self-destructive, and at variance with itself. And, therefore, there is no destiny.
2753 Hom., Od., i. 7.
2754 γένεσις = birth, h. the star of man’s nativity, h. destiny.
777
Several Other Things Turned Against the Same Mathematicians.