The Letter of Anastasius,
Bishop of the Church of Rome to
John Bishop of Jerusalem Concerning the Character of
Rufinus.
————————————
The letter of Anastasius to John
of Jerusalem was written in the year 401; it is spoken of in
Jerome’s Apol. iii., c. 21, which was written in the first half
of 402, as “the letter of last year.” Jerome intimates in
the same passage that it was only one of several letters of the same
character which Anastasius wrote to the East. Rufinus had not seen it,
and refused to believe its genuineness. But there seems to be no reason
for doubting this. Anastasius had, at the earnest request of Theophilus
of Alexandria, formally condemned Origenism. And Rufinus’
translations of Origen’s
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
and of
Pamphilus’ Vindication of Origen, and his own book on the
Falsification of Origen’s works were taken at Rome as a defence
of Origenism generally. Rufinus, however, appealed continually, and
especially in his Apology to Anastasius, to the church of Jerusalem,
where he had been ordained. “My faith,” he says, “is
that which is preached at Jerusalem.” Anastasius, therefore, in
condemning Origen would be understood as condemning Rufinus, and might
also seem to condemn his Bishop John of Jerusalem. This will account
for the fulsome praises with which the letter opens. John, moreover,
had written “to consult” Anastasius about Rufinus, which
probably implies some action in Rufinus’ interest; but the fact
that Jerome knew the contents of the letter and Rufinus did not seems
to show that Bishop John had become more friendly with Jerome and less
so with Rufinus.
1. The kind words of approval
that you have addressed, my dear Bishop, to your brother Bishop, is a
fresh mark of your long tried affection. It is a high commendation
which you confer upon me, a most lavish recognition of my services. I
thank you for this proof of your love; and, following you at a distance
in my littleness, I bring the tribute of my words to honour the
splendour of your holiness and those virtues which the Lord has
conferred upon you. You excel all others so far, the splendour of your
praise shines forth so conspicuously, that no words which I can use can
equal your deserts. Yet your glory excites in me such admiration that I
cannot turn away from the attempt to describe it, even though I can
never do so adequately. And, first, the praise which you have bestowed
on me out of the serene heaven of your great spirit forms part of your
own glory: for it is the majesty of your episcopate, shining forth like
the sun upon the opposite quarter of the world, which has reflected its
own brightness upon us. And you give me your friendship unreservedly;
you do not weigh me in the balance of criticism. If it is right for you
to praise me, must not your praise be echoed back to you? I beg you
therefore, for your own sake no less than mine, that you will not
praise me any more to my face. I ask this for two reasons: if the
praise is undeserved it must excite in your brother-bishop a sense of
pain; if it is true, it must make him blush.
2. Let me come to the subject of
your letter. Rufinus, about whom you have done me the honour to ask my
advice, must bring his conscience to the bar of the divine
majesty.
It
is for him to see how he can approve himself to God as maintaining his
true allegiance to him.
3. As for Origen, whose writings
he has translated into our language, I have neither formerly known, nor
do I now seek to know either who he was or what expression he may have
given to his thought. But as to the feeling left by this matter on my
own mind I should be glad to speak with your holiness for a moment. The
impression which I have received is this,—and it has been brought
out clearly by the reading of parts of Origen’s works by the
people of our City, and by the sort of mist of blindness which it threw
over them,—that his object was to disintegrate our faith, which
is that of the Apostles, and has been confirmed by the traditions of
the fathers, by leading us into tortuous paths.
4. I want to know what is the
meaning of the translation of this work into the Roman tongue. If the
translator intends by it to put the author in the wrong, and to
denounce to the world his execrable deeds, well and good. In that case
he will expose to well-merited hatred one who has long laboured under
the adverse weight of public opinion. But if by translating all these
evil things he means to give his assent to them, and in that sense
gives them to the world to read, then the edifice which he has reared
at the expense of so much labour serves for nothing else than to make
the guilt the act of his own will, and to give the sanction of his
unlooked for support to the overthrow of all that is of prime
importance in the true faith as held by Catholic Christians from the
time of the Apostles till now.
5. Far be such teaching from the
catholic system of the Church of Rome. It can never by any possibility
come to pass that we should accept as reasonable things which we
condemn as matters of law and right. We have, therefore, the assurance
that Christ our God, whose providence reaches over the whole world,
bestows his approval on us when we say that it is wholly impossible for
us to admit doctrines which defile the church, which subvert its well
tried moral system, which offend the ears of all who are witnesses of
our doings and lay the ground for strife and anger and dissensions.
This was the motive which led me to write my letter to Venerius
2811
our brother in the Episcopate, the
character of which, written as it was in my weakness but with great
care and diligence, you will realize by what I now subjoin:
“Whence, then, he who translated the work has gained and
preserves this assurance of innocence I am not greatly troubled to
know: it fills me with no vain alarm. I certainly shall omit nothing
which may enable me to guard the faith of the Gospel amongst my own
people, and to warn, as far as in me lies, those who form part of my
body, in whatever part of the world they live, not to allow any
translation of profane authors to creep in and spring up amongst them,
which will seek to unsettle the mind of devout men by spreading its own
darkness among them. Moreover, I cannot pass over in silence an event
which has given me great pleasure, the decree issued by our Emperors,
2812
by which every one who serves God is
warned against the reading of Origen, and all who are convicted of
reading his impious works are condemned by the imperial
judgment.” In these words my formal sentence was
pronounced.
6. You are troubled by the
complaint which people make as to our treatment of Rufinus, so that you
pursue certain persons
2813
with vague
suspicions. But I will meet this feeling of yours with an instance
taken from holy writ, namely, where it is said: “Man seeth not as
God seeth; for God looketh upon the heart, but man upon the
countenance.” Therefore, my dearly beloved brother, put away all
your prejudice. Weigh the conduct of Rufinus in your own unbiassed
judgment; ask yourself whether he has not translated Origen’s
words into Latin and approved them, and whether a man who gives his
encouragement to vicious acts committed by another differs at all from
the guilty party. In any case I beg you to be assured of this, that he
is so completely separate from all part or lot with us, that I neither
know nor wish to know either what he is doing or where he is living. I
have only to add that it is for him to consider where he may obtain
absolution.
2811
Appointed bishop of Milan in 400, in succession to
Simplicianus.
2812
Arcadius and Honorius.
2813
Probably the friends of Jerome at Rome, Pammachius and
Marcella.