4. This is the hissing of the old serpent; by counsel
such as this the dragon drove man from Paradise. For he promised that
if they would prefer fulness to fasting they should be immortal, as
though it were an impossibility for them to fall; and while he promises
they shall be as Gods, he drives them from Paradise, with the result
that they who, while naked and unhampered, and as virgins unspotted
enjoyed the fellowship of the Lord were cast down into the vale of
tears, and sewed skins together to clothe themselves withal. But, not
to detain the reader any longer, I will keep to the division given
above and taking his propositions one by one will rely chiefly on the
evidence of Scripture to refute them, for fear he may chatter and
complain that he was overcome by rhetorical skill rather than by force
of truth. If I succeed in this and with the aid of a cloud of witnesses
from both Testaments prove too strong for him, I will then accept his
challenge, and adduce illustrations from secular literature. I will
show that even among philosophers and distinguished statesmen, the
virtuous are wont to be preferred by all to the voluptuous, that is to
say men like The philosopher
of Crotona, in Italy, b.c. 580–510. See
some of his sayings in Jerome’s Apology, iii. 39–40.Pythagoras, The great
teacher of the Academy at Athens; lived b.c.
428–389.Plato and Surnamed the
“Just.” He was the opponent of Themistocles. He fought at
Marathon (490), and although in exile did good service at Salamis
(480). He was now recalled, and after commanding the Athenians at
Platæa (479) died, probably in 468, so poor that he did not leave
enough to pay for his funeral.Aristides, to Flourished about
b.c. 370. A disciple of Socrates, and founder
of the Cyrenaic School of Philosophy; he was luxurious in his life, and
held pleasure to be the highest good.Aristippus, Epicurus (b.c. 342–270), though a disciple of
Aristippus, does not appear to have deserved the odium attached to his
name by Jerome and many others. “Pleasure with him was not a mere
momentary and transitory sensation, but something lasting and
imperishable, consisting in pure and noble enjoyments, that is, in
ἀταραξία and ἀπονία, or the freedom from pain
and from all influences which disturb the peace of our mind, and
thereby our happiness which is the result of it.” See
Zeller’s Socrates and the Socratic Schools (Reichel’s
translation), second ed., p. 337 sq.Epicurus and The famous
Athenian, talented, reckless and unscrupulous; born about b.c. 450, assassinated 404.Alcibiades. I entreat virgins of both
sexes and all such as are continent, the married also and the twice
married, to assist my efforts with their prayers. Jovinian is the
common enemy. For he who maintains all to be of equal merit, does no
less injury to virginity in comparing it with marriage than he does to
marriage, when he allows it to be lawful, but to the same extent as
second and third marriages. But to digamists and trigamists also he
does wrong, for he places on a level with them whoremongers and the
most licentious persons as soon as they have repented; but perhaps
those who have been married twice or thrice ought not to complain, for
the same whoremonger if penitent is made equal in the kingdom of heaven
even to virgins. I will therefore explain more clearly and in proper
sequence the arguments he employs and the illustrations he adduces
respecting marriage, and will treat them in the order in which he
states them. And I beg the reader not to be disturbed if he is
compelled to read Jovinian’s nauseating trash. He will all the
more gladly drink Christ’s antidote after the devil’s
poisonous concoction. Listen with patience, ye virgins; listen, I pray
you, to the voice of the most voluptuous of preachers; nay rather close
your ears, as you would to the Syren’s fabled songs, and pass on.
For a little while endure the wrongs you suffer: think you are
crucified with Christ, and are listening to the blasphemies of the
Pharisees.