4. Then after saying some things concerning all the heresies he adds: “I received this
rule and ordinance from our blessed father,2189 Heraclas.2190 For those who came over
from heresies, although they had apostatized from the Church,—or rather had not apostat-
ized, but seemed to meet with them, yet were charged with resorting to some false teach-
er,—when he had expelled them from the Church he did not receive them back, though
they entreated for it, until they had publicly reported all things which they had heard from
their adversaries; but then he received them without requiring of them another baptism.2191
For they had formerly received the Holy Spirit from him.”
5. Again, after treating the question thoroughly, he adds: “I have learned also that this2192
is not a novel practice introduced in Africa alone, but that even long ago in the times of the
bishops before us this opinion has been adopted in the most populous churches, and in
synods of the brethren in Iconium and Synnada,2193 and by many others. To overturn their
part of the same saying) are quoted more frequently by the Fathers than any other of the Agrapha (Resch, on p.
116 sq. gives 69 instances). Their interpretation, in connection with the words of Paul in 1 Thess. v. 21, 22, has
been very satisfactorily discussed by Hänsel in the Studien und Kritiken, 1836, p. 170 sq. They undoubtedly
mean that we are to test and to distinguish between the true and the false, the good and the bad, as a skillful
money-changer distinguishes good and bad coins. For a full discussion of this utterance, and for an exhibition
of the many other patristic passages in which it occurs, see the magnificent work of Alfred Resch, Agrapha:
Aussercanonische Evangelienfragmente, in Gebhardt and Harnack’s Texte und Untersuchungen, Bd. V. Heft 4,
Leipzig, 1889; the most complete and satisfactory discussion of the whole subject of the Agrapha which we have.
2189 π€πα. According to Suicer (Thesaurus) all bishops in the Occident as late as the fifth century were called
Papæ as a mark of honor and though the term by that time had begun to be used in a distinctive sense of the
bishop of Rome, the older usage continued in parts of the West outside of Italy, until Gregory VII. (a.d. 1075)
forbade the use of the name for any other than the pope. In the East the word was used for a long time as the
especial title of the bishops of Alexandria and of Rome (see Suicer’s Thesaurus and Gieseler’s Church Hist.
Harper’s edition, I. p. 499).
2190 On Heraclas, see Bk. VI. chap. 3, note 2.
2191 Compare Cyprian’s epistle to Quintus concerning the baptism of heretics (Ep. 70, al. 71). Cyprian there
takes the position stated here, that those who have been baptized in the Church and have afterward gone over
to heresy and then returned again to the Church are not to be re-baptized, but to be received with the laying on
of hands only. This of course does not at all invalidate the position of Cyprian and the others who re-baptized
heretics, for they baptized heretics not because they had been heretics, but because they had not received true
baptism, nor indeed any baptism at all, which it was impossible, in their view, for a heretic to give. They therefore
repudiated (as Cyprian does in the epistle referred to) the term re-baptism, denying that they re-baptized anybody.
2192 Namely the re-baptism (or, as they would say, the baptism) of those who had received baptism only at
the hands of heretics standing without the communion of the Church.
2193 Iconium was the principal city of Lycaonia, and Synnada a city of Phrygia. The synod of Iconium referred
to here is mentioned also by Firmilian in his epistle to Cyprian, §§7 and 19 (Cypriani Ep. 74, al. 75). From that
753
The Abominable Error of the Heretics; the Divine Vision of Dionysius; and…