Excursus on the Authority of the Second Ecumenical Council.
(Hefele, History of the Councils, Vol. II., pp. 370, et seqq.)
Lastly, to turn to the question of the authority of this Council, it appears, first of all, that
immediately after its close, in the same year, 381, several of its acts were censured by a
Council of Latins, namely, the prolongation of the Meletian schism (by the elevation of
Flavian), and the choice of Nectarius as Bishop of Constantinople, while, as is known, the
Westerns held (the Cynic) Maximus to be the rightful bishop of that city.
In consequence of this, the new Synod assembled in the following year, 382, at Con-
stantinople, sent the Latins a copy of the decrees of faith composed the year before, expressly
calling this Synod οἰκουμενική and at the same time seeking to justify it in those points
which had been censured. Photius234 maintains that soon afterwards Pope Damasus con-
firmed this synod; but, as the following will show, this confirmation could only have referred
to the creed and not to the canons. As late as about the middle of the fifth century, Pope
Leo I. spoke in a very depreciatory manner of these canons, especially of the third, which
concerned the ecclesiastical rank of Constantinople, remarking that it was never sent to the
See of Rome. Still later, Gregory the Great wrote in the same sense: Romana autem Ecclesia
eosdam canones vel gesta Synodi illius hactenus non habet, nec accepit; in hoc autem eam
accepit, quod est per eam contra Macedonium definitum.235
Thus, as late as the year 600, only the creed, but not the canons of the Synod of Con-
stantinople were accepted at Rome; but on account of its creed, Gregory the Great reckons
it as one of the four Ecumenical Councils, which he compares to the four Gospels. So also
before him the popes Vigilius and Pelagius II, reckoned this Synod among the Ecumenical
Councils.
The question is, from what date the Council of Constantinople was considered ecumen-
ical by the Latins as well as by the Greeks. We will begin with the latter. Although as we
have seen, the Synod of 382 had already designated this council as ecumenical, yet it could
not for a long time obtain an equal rank with the Council of Nicæa, for which reason the
General Council of Ephesus mentions that of Nicæa and its creed with the greatest respect,
but is totally silent as to this Synod. Soon afterwards, the so-called Robber-Synod in 449,
spoke of two (General) Councils, at Nicæa and Ephesus, and designated the latter as ἡ
187
δευτέρα σύνοδος, as a plain token that it did not ascribe such a high rank to the assembly
at Constantinople. It might perhaps be objected that only the Monophysites, who notoriously
ruled the Robber-Synod, used this language; but the most determined opponent of the
Monophysites, their accuser, Bishop Eusebius of Dorylæum, in like manner also brought
forward only the two Synods of Nicæa and Ephesus, and declared that “he held to the faith
234 Photius, De Synodis, p. 1143, ed. Justelli.
235 Greg., Epist., Lib. I., 25.
Excursus on the Authority of the Second Ecumenical Council.
365
Excursus on the Authority of the Second Ecumenical Council.