ungenerate too. Well, if he means by this that the Father’s essence is ungenerate, I agree
with what is said, and do not oppose his doctrine: for not one of the orthodox maintains
that the Father of the Only-begotten is Himself begotten. But if, while the form of his expres-
sion indicates only this, he maintains that the ungeneracy itself is the essence, I say that we
ought not to leave such a position unexamined, but expose his attempt to gain the assent of
the unwary to his blasphemy.
Now that the idea1165 of ungeneracy and the belief in the Divine essence are quite dif-
ferent things may be seen by what he himself has put forward. God, he says, is indestructible
and ungenerate by His very essence, as being unmixed and pure from all diversity and dif-
ference. This he says of God, Whose essence he declares to be indestructibility and ungen-
eracy. There are three names, then, that he applies to God, being, indestructibility, ungener-
acy. If the idea of these three words in respect of God is one, it follows that the Godhead
and these three are identical. Just as if any one, wanting to describe a man, should say that
he was a rational, risible, and broad-nailed creature; whereupon, because there is no essential
variation from these in the individuals, we say that the terms are equivalent to each other,
and that the three things seen in the subject are one thing, viz. the humanity described by
these names. If, then, Godhead means this, ungeneracy, indestructibility, being, by doing
away with one of these he necessarily does away with the Godhead. For just as we should
say that a creature which was neither rational nor risible was not man either, so in the case
of these three terms (ungeneracy, indestructibility, being), if the Godhead is described by
these, should one of the three be absent, its absence destroys the definition of Godhead. Let
him tell us, then, in reply, what opinion he holds of God the Only-begotten. Does he think
Him generate or ungenerate? Of course he must say generate, unless he is to contradict
himself. If, then, being and indestructibility are equivalent to ungeneracy, and by all of these
Godhead is denoted, to Whom ungeneracy is wanting, to Him being and indestructibility
must needs be wanting also, and in that case the Godhead also must necessarily be taken
away. And thus his blasphemous logic brings him to a twofold conclusion. For if being, and
indestructibility, and ungeneracy are applied to God in the same sense, our new God-maker
289
is clearly convicted of regarding the Son created by Him as destructible, by his not regarding
Him as ungenerate, and not only so, but altogether without being, through his inability to
see Him in the Godhead, as one in whom ungeneracy and indestructibility are not found,
since he takes the ungeneracy and indestructibility to be identical with the being. But since
in this there is manifest perdition, let some one counsel these unhappy folk to turn to the
only course which is left them, and, instead of setting themselves in open opposition to the
truth, to allow that each of these terms has its own proper signification, such as may be seen
1165 τὸ νόημα. There is a lacuna in the Paris Editt., beginning here, and extending to “ungenerate,” just below.
Oehler’s Codices have supplied it.
543
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.