47. This is sufficient to confute them; but to
shew still further that they are hostile to the truth and
Christ’s enemies, I could wish to ask them a question. The
Apostle in the Second Epistle to the Corinthians writes, ‘I knew
a man in Christ, above fourteen years ago, whether in the body I do not
know, or whether out of the body I do not know; God knoweth 2 Cor. xii. 2. S. Augustine
understands the passage differently, i.e. that S. Paul really did not
know whether or not he was in the body. Gen. ad lit. xii.
14..’ What now say ye? Knew the Apostle
what had happened to him in the vision, though he says ‘I know
not,’ or knew he not? If he knew not, see to it, lest, being
familiar with error, ye err in the trespass παρανομίαν, §2, n. 5. of
the Phrygians Cf.
Jerome, ‘He speaks not in ecstasy, as Montanus, Prisca, and
Maximilla rave;’ Præf. in Naum. In like manner
Tertullian speaks of ‘amentia, as the spiritalis vis qua constat
prophetia;’ de Anim. 21. Cf. Eusebius, Hist. v. 16.
Epiphanius too, noticing the failure of Maximilla’s prophecies,
says, ‘Whatever the prophets have said, they spoke with
understanding, following the sense.’ Hær. 48. p. 403.
In the de Syn. 4. Athan. speaks of the Montanists as making a
fresh beginning of Christianity; i.e. they were the first heretics who
professed to prophesy and to introduce a new or additional
revelation., who say that the
Prophets and the other ministers of the Word know neither what they do
nor concerning what they announce. But if he knew when he said ‘I
know not,’ for he had Christ within him revealing to him all
things, is not the heart of God’s enemies indeed perverted and
‘self-condemned?’ for when the Apostle says, ‘I know
not,’ they say that he knows; but when the Lord says, ‘I
know not,’ they say that He does not know. For if since Christ
was within him, Paul knew that of which he says, ‘I know
not,’ does not much more Christ Himself know, though He say,
‘I know not?’ The Apostle then, the Lord revealing it to
him, knew what happened to him; for on this account he says, ‘I
knew a man in Christ;’ and knowing the man, he knew also how the
man was caught away. Thus Elisha, who beheld Elijah, knew also how he was taken up; but though knowing,
yet when the sons of the Prophets thought that Elijah was cast upon one
of the mountains by the Spirit, he knowing from the first what he had
seen, tried to persuade them; but when they urged it, he was silent,
and suffered them to go after him. Did he then not know, because he was
silent? he knew indeed, but as if not knowing, he suffered them, that
they being convinced, might no more doubt about the taking up of
Elijah. Therefore much more Paul, himself being the person caught away,
knew also how he was caught; for Elijah knew; and had any one asked, he
would have said how. And yet Paul says ‘I know not,’ for
these two reasons, as I think at least; one, as he has said himself,
lest because of the abundance of the revelations any one should think
of him beyond what he saw; the other, because, our Saviour having said
‘I know not,’ it became him also to say ‘I know
not,’ lest the servant should appear above his Lord, and the
disciple above his Master.