�60
Cbe 1iving <tburcb Chicago
Rev, 0 W, Leftlnir;well, Editor and Proprietor
CONSIDERABLE anxiety,and even alarm, has been aroused ia Ea gland, especially
amon1< ·medical men, by the modification of
the Vaccination Act by eliminating tbe
compul6ory clauses. This, it seems, is in
deference to what are understood to be the
conscientious scruples of many parents
among the poor against the idea of having
their child ren vaccinated. These scruples
are partly, no doubt, superstitious or fanati
cal, but partly, also, practical. It is
charged that other diseases have been
transmitted with the lymph and permanent
ly settled upon the constitutions of unfortu
nate children. There is, it may be, just
enough truth in this charge to furnish some
justification for opposition. Among- the
hundreds of humane men who adorn the
most humane of secular professions, there
are doctors who, in attendance upon the
poor, are ·worse than perfunctory. Any
treatment, thev seem to think, will serve
in such cases. Some sad tales have lately
come to light at English inquests, of the
neglect and harshness of the parish sur
geon. From the. impressions thus created
comes wides pread loss of confidence, and
ugly · suspicion when it comes to such a
matter as ,vaccination. Much fear is ex
pressed in the En�lish papers that the re
peal of the 1compulsory clauses of the Jaw
will lead to such neglect that the result
may be a severe epidemic. There is, it is
true, a small minority of the medical frater
nity who have always disputed the efficacy
of vaccination. To most people, however,
the broad�facts of the case seem to be over
whelmingly in favor of this mode of ward
ing off one 'of the worst plagues that human
fle�h is heir to, as among the greatest bene
fits medical science has conferred upon
mankind.
-.x-
Proposed Canonical Legislation
on Mar riage and Divorce
IN the Church Eclectic for September will be found an article by th<3° Rev. Walker
Gwynne, entitled , "Divorce Legislation and
its Results." The writer confines his view
to the historical and political, rather than
the theological, aspects of the case. His
purpose is to show that in proportion as di
vorce is made easy, unhappy marriages in
crease ,and multiply. Itis not the existence
of intolerable unhappiness which has caused
the enactment of loose divorce laws, but
the converse of this is true. When divorce
is made easy, there is a constant tendency
to treat the obligations of marriage with
levity. Many difficulties between a mar
ried pair which would be smothered and
suppres�ed if the bond was known to be in
dissoiuble, are exaggerated to the utmost
when it id lrnown that there is an easy
method of obtaining a separation and form
ing new and more satisfactory relations.
Thus it has come to pass that while the
"simult aneous polygamy" of Mormonism is
forbidden by law, "consecutive polygamy"
is encouraged and is • growing here in the
United States to enormous proportions.
As evideDee that the chief cause of the
marital misery which leads to multiplied di
vorces is our vicious divorce legislation, the
writer adduces the contrast which the ex-
ttbe 1iving <tburcb
perience of Canada affords: "While in the
twenty years ending 1886, 328,716 divorces
were granted in the United States, during
the same period in Canada there were ju st
116! In other words, while in the United
States there was one divorce to every 150
of the population, in Canada, there was only
one to every 34,000." These figures are
taken from the U. S. Report 011 Marriage
and Divorce, issued in 1889. Every one
knows that matters have not impr0ved dur
ing the last twelve years, but have gone on
from bad to worse. · The writer forcibly
urges that human nature is not radically
better north of the lakes and the St. Law
rence, than within our own boundaries; yet
there has been no loud outcry from the mul
titude of wretched homes, which, according
to the advocates of divorce, ought to exist
there. There can be but one answer to the
qu estion, What is the cause of the vast
amount of misery and cruelty in family life
to which the records of our courts testify,
and of the still more indubitable misery
which follows the breaking- up of thousands
of homes? That answer is that our laws
have fostered discontent and encouraged
vicious passion, and thus have themselve.s
created the evils which they profess to cure.
Public sentiment is becoming debauched in
this matter, and people may do, without se
rious detriment to their social position,
what would have been viewfld with abhor
rence a generation ago.
'.rhis is the condition which confronts us,
and with which the Church has to deal.
The difficulty of effective action is enhanced
by the fact that some of the leading religious
sects have given up any attempt to stem the
tide. Some of the principal organs of denom
inational and of unsectarian religion even
scout the idea of any attempt to preserve
the ancient stringency of the marriage tie.
It is natural enough that they should do so,
since in Protestant circles the sacramental
character of marriage is explicitly repudi
ated. Where this is the case, the tradition
al sanctity of wedded life, while its effects
may linger for a long time, cannot stand
against a strong adverse tendency. •There
is enough of this Protestant atmosphere
among ourselves to render an attempt at
definite legislation and the enforcement of
an uncompromising rule constantly more
difficult.
The Church has a double duty in this
matter. She is set in the world to testify
to that which is right and pure. If she does
not stand for the highest morality, she fails
in her mission to the world. She may not
follow or connive at an evil course of secu
lar legislation and allow her moral teaching
and practice to be weakly conformed to a
low standard, because it has been admitted
by t1.e State. Severed, in this country,
from all embarrassing relation to the civil
goverument, she is able to pursue her ends
untrammeled by any license of civil law.
Her office in such a matter as marriage is•
to show by her own example what legisla
tion should make its end for the preserva
tion of the family and of society.
But the duty of the Church is, first of all,
to her own children. It is to prePerve them
from the false views which are producing
such widespread corruption, The engag
ing idea upon which the changes are rung
in certain quarters, that there is no long-er
any antagonii;m between the Church and
·the world , is to be sternly and emphatically
denied. The enmity with God is as pro
nounced now as at any time in history, and
SE PT, 24, 1898
the "spirit of the al?'e" is not Christian, or
entitled in any degree to give the law to
the Church of Cl::.rist.
The marriage service of the Church pre
serves that pure and perfect ideal of mar-
riage which has been handed down to us
from the first ages through the Mother
Church of England. Its leading princi ple
is the indissoluble character of the inarriage,
bond, once rightly effected. Our canonical
legislatloa, in which practical re!;ulations
are laid down for the guidance of the clergy
and laity, can never be rigb.t until it ls ex
actly conformed to this primary principle.
We may be forced to allow, in extreme
cases, a separation, but the point to be
maintained, in accordance with the mar
riage service, is that under no circum
stances will the Church admit the iilea that
the bond can be severed and a new marriag-e
relation entered upon. This principle of
the necessity of absolute harmony bet ween
the marriage service and all other legisla
tion upon the subject,has been asserted in a
declaration recently set forth by a number
of the bishopa and clergy of highest stand
ing in the Church.
Th_e canon proposed in the report of the
Joint Commission, numbered 34, whatever
its other deficiencies, has this supreme
merit,that it asserts the indissoluble charac
ter of the marriage bond. Sec. III. reads as
follows: "No minister of this Church shall
solemnize the marriag-e of either party to a
divorce juring the life time of the other
party." Whatever else is done, it becomes
this Church to assert that principle. We
regret that the commission was not able to
make its report unanimous in this particu
lar.
It is very true that to make this legisla
tion properly effective, some things will
have to be made more explicit than they
appear in this proposed canon. Particular
ly is it necess11.ry that the matter of impedi
ments ·shall be made more clear, At the
beginning of the Office for the Solemniza
tion of Matrimony, the priest is directed to
charge the parties in the most solemn man
ner, ''as they will answer at the dreadful
Day of Judgment," if they know any impedi
ment why they may not be lawfully joined
together in matrimony; that they shall now
confess it, assuring them, moreover, that if
they be "joined together otherwise than as
God's Word doth allow, their marriage is
not lawful." Plainly, therefore, there are
cases in which, on account of the presence
of such impediments, the marriage rite is
nu·n and void, the supposed marriage is no
marriage. It is in the highest degree nec
essary that a knowledge of such impedi
ments should be easily accessible to priests
and lay-people. It is in this particular that
the proposed canon is seriously defective.
Section I. orders that "no minister shall
solemnize a marriage the parties to which
are within the degrees of consanguin ity and
affinity defined in the eighteenth chapter of
the Book of Leviticus. " It is certainly nec
essary that the sense which the Church has
placed upon this chapter should be plainly
expressed, and this can be done in no more
effective way ·t han by printing in full in
this canon the Table of Prohibited Degrees.
lt may be that the General Convention,
seeing the importance of this point, will
deem it wise to remit this canon to a special
committee which may cover the necessary
particulars, and at last put our legislation
on this grave subject into a shape worthy of
the Church's claims and of her mission in