Our faith from our forefathers, which also we
have learned from thee, Blessed Pope, is this:—We acknowledge One
God, alone Ingenerate, alone Everlasting, alone Unbegun, alone True,
alone having Immortality, alone Wise, alone Good, alone Sovereign;
Judge, Governor, and Providence of all, unalterable and unchangeable,
just and good, God of Law and Prophets and New Testament; who begat an
Only-begotten Son before eternal times, through whom He has made both
the ages and the universe; and begat Him, not in semblance, but in
truth; and that He made Him subsist at His own will, unalterable and
unchangeable; perfect creature of God, but not as one of the creatures;
offspring, but not as one of things begotten; nor as Valentinus
pronounced that the offspring of the Father was an issue What
the Valentinian προβολὴ was is described in Epiph. Hær. 31, 13 [but see D.C.B.
iv. 1086 sqq.] Origen protests against the notion of
προβολή, Periarch. iv. p. 190, and Athanasius Expos.
§1. The Arian Asterius too considers προβολὴ to introduce the notion of τεκνογονία, Euseb. contr. Marc. i. 4. p. 20. vid. also Epiph.
Hær. 72. 7. Yet Eusebius uses the word προβάλλεσθαι. Eccl. Theol. i. 8. On the other hand Tertullian
uses it with a protest against the Valentinian sense. Justin has
προβληθὲν
γέννημα,
Tryph. 62. And Nazianzen calls the Almighty Father προβολεὺς
of the Holy Spirit. Orat. 29. 2. Arius
introduces the word here as an argumentum ad invidiam. Hil.
de Trin. vi. 9.; nor as Manichæus taught that the
offspring was a portion of the Father, one in essence The
Manichees adopting a material notion of the divine substance,
considered that it was divisible, and that a portion of it was absorbed
by the power of darkness.; or as Sabellius, dividing the Monad, speaks
of a Son-and-Father υἱοπατόρα. The term is ascribed to Sabellius, Ammon. in Caten.
Joan. i. 1. p. 14: to Sabellius and [invidiously to] Marcellus,
Euseb. Eccl. Theol. ii. 5: Cf., as to Marcellus, Cyr. Hier.
Catech. xv. 9. also iv. 8. xi. 16; Epiph. Hær. 73.
11 fin.: to Sabellians, Athan. Expos. Fid. 2. and 7, and Greg.
Nyssen. contr. Eun. xii. p. 733: to certain heretics, Cyril.
Alex. in Joann. p. 243: to Praxeas and Montanus, Mar.
Merc. p. 128: to Sabellius, Cæsar. Dial. i. p. 550: to
Noetus, Damasc. Hær. 57.; nor as Hieracas,
of one torch from another, or as a lamp divided into two [On
Hieracas, see D.C.B. iii. 24; also Epiph. Hær. 67; Hil.
Trin. vi. 12.]; nor that He who was before, was afterwards
generated or new-created into a Son Bull
considers that the doctrine of such Fathers is here spoken of as held
that our Lord’s συγκατάβασις
to create the world was a γέννησις, and certainly such language as that of Hippol. contr.
Noet. §15. favours the supposition. But one class of
[Monarchians] may more probably be intended, who held that the Word
became the Son upon His incarnation, such as Marcellus, vid. Euseb.
Eccles. Theol. i. 1. contr. Marc. ii. 3. vid. also
Eccles. Theol. ii. 9. p. 114 b. μηδ᾽ ἄλλοτε
ἄλλην κ.τ.λ. Also the Macrostich says, ‘We anathematize those who call
Him the mere Word of God, not allowing Him to be Christ and Son of God
before all ages, but from the time He took on Him our flesh: such are
the followers of Marcellus and Photinus, &c.’ infr.
§26. Again, Athanasius, Orat. iv. 15, says that, of those
who divide the Word from the Son, some called our Lord’s manhood
the Son, some the two Natures together, and some said ‘that the
Word Himself became the Son when He was made man.’ It makes it
more likely that Marcellus is meant, that Asterius seems to have
written against him before the Nicene Council, and that Arius in other
of his writings borrowed from Asterius. vid. de Decret.
§8., as thou too
thyself, Blessed Pope, in the midst of the Church and in session hast
often condemned; but, as we say, at the will of God, created before
times and before ages, and gaining life and being from the Father, who
gave subsistence to His glories together with Him. For the Father did
not, in giving to Him the inheritance of all things, deprive Himself of
what He has ingenerately in Himself; for He is the Fountain of all
things. Thus there are Three Subsistences. And God, being the cause of
all things, is Unbegun and altogether Sole, but the Son being begotten
apart from time by the Father, and being created and founded before
ages, was not before His generation, but being begotten apart from time
before all things, alone was made to subsist by the Father. For He is
not eternal or co-eternal or co-unoriginate with the Father, nor has He
His being together with the Father, as some speak of relations Eusebius’s letter to Euphration, which is mentioned just
after, expresses this more distinctly—‘If they coexist, how
shall the Father be Father and the Son Son? or how the One first, the
Other second? and the One ingenerate and the other generate?’
Acta Conc. 7. p. 301. The phrase τὰ πρός τι Bull well explains to refer to the Catholic truth that the
Father or Son being named; the Other is therein implied without naming.
Defens. F. N. iii. 9. §4. Hence Arius, in his Letter to
Eusebius, complains that Alexander says, ἀεὶ ὁ
θεός, ἀεὶ ὁ
υἱ& 231·ς ἅμα
πατήρ, ἅμα υἱ&
231·ς. Theod. H. E. i.
4., introducing two ingenerate beginnings, but
God is before all things as being Monad and Beginning of all. Wherefore
also He is before the Son; as we have learned also from thy preaching
in the midst of the Church. So far then as from God He has being, and
glories, and life, and all things are delivered unto Him, in such sense
is God His origin. For He is above Him, as being His God and before
Him. But if the terms ‘from Him,’ and ‘from the
womb,’ and ‘I came forth from the Father, and I am come ἥκω, and so Chrys. Hom. 3. Hebr. init. Epiph.
Hær. 73. 31, and 36.’ (Rom. xi. 36; Ps. cx. 3; John xvi. 28), be understood by some to mean as
if a part of Him, one in essence or as an issue, then the Father is
according to them compounded and divisible and alterable and material,
and, as far as their belief goes, has the circumstances of a body, Who
is the Incorporeal God.