Chapter 11.—Whether It is Just that the Punishments of Sins Last Longer Than the Sins
Themselves Lasted.
Some, however, of those against whom we are defending the city of God, think it unjust
that any man be doomed to an eternal punishment for sins which, no matter how great they
were, were perpetrated in a brief space of time; as if any law ever regulated the duration of
the punishment by the duration of the offence punished! Cicero tells us that the laws recog-
nize eight kinds of penalty,—damages, imprisonment, scourging, reparation,1515 disgrace,
exile, death, slavery. Is there any one of these which may be compressed into a brevity
proportioned to the rapid commission of the offence, so that no longer time may be spent
in its punishment than in its perpetration, unless, perhaps, reparation? For this requires
that the offender suffer what he did, as that clause of the law says, “Eye for eye, tooth for
tooth.”1516 For certainly it is possible for an offender to lose his eye by the severity of legal
retaliation in as brief a time as he deprived another of his eye by the cruelty of his own law-
lessness. But if scourging be a reasonable penalty for kissing another man’s wife, is not the
fault of an instant visited with long hours of atonement, and the momentary delight punished
with lasting pain? What shall we say of imprisonment? Must the criminal be confined only
for so long a time as he spent on the offence for which he is committed? or is not a penalty
of many years’ confinement imposed on the slave who has provoked his master with a word,
or has struck him a blow that is quickly over? And as to damages, disgrace, exile, slavery,
which are commonly inflicted so as to admit of no relaxation or pardon, do not these resemble
eternal punishments in so far as this short life allows a resemblance? For they are not
eternal only because the life in which they are endured is not eternal; and yet the crimes
which are punished with these most protracted sufferings are perpetrated in a very brief
space of time. Nor is there any one who would suppose that the pains of punishment should
occupy as short a time as the offense; or that murder, adultery, sacrilege, or any other crime,
463
should be measured, not by the enor mity of the injury or wickedness, but by the length of
time spent in its perpetration. Then as to the award of death for any great crime, do the
laws reckon the punishment to consist in the brief moment in which death is inflicted, or
in this, that the offender is eternally banished from the society of the living? And just as the
punishment of the first death cuts men off from this present mortal city, so does the punish-
ment of the second death cut men off from that future immortal city. For as the laws of this
present city do not provide for the executed criminal’s return to it, so neither is he who is
condemned to the second death recalled again to life everlasting. But if temporal sin is visited
with eternal punishment, how, then, they say, is that true which your Christ says, “With the
same measure that ye mete withal it shall be measured to you again?”1517 and they do not
1515 “Talio,” i.e. the rendering of like for like, the punishment being exactly similar to the injury sustained.
1516 Ex. xxi. 24.
1517 Luke vi. 38.
Whether It is Just that the Punishments of Sins Last Longer Than the Sins Themselves Lasted.
1038
Whether It is Just that the Punishments of Sins Last Longer Than the Sins…