89
Historical Introduction.
With regard to the Synod of Gangra we know little beside what we learn from its own
synodal letter. Three great questions naturally arise with regard to it.
1. What was its date?
2. Who was the Eustathius it condemned?
3. Who was its presiding officer?
I shall briefly give the reader the salient points with regard to each of these matters.
1. With regard to the date, there can be no doubt that it was after Nice and before the
First Council of Constantinople, that is between 325 and 381. Socrates131 seems to place it
about 365; but Sozomen132 some twenty years earlier. On the other hand, Remi Ceillier133
inconsistently with his other statements, seems to argue from St. Basil’s letters that the true
date is later than 376. Still another theory has been urged by the Ballerini, resting on the
supposition that the Eusebius who presided was Eusebius of Cæsarea, and they therefore
fix the date between 362 and 370. With this Mr. Ffoulkes agrees, and fixes the date,134 with
Pagi, at 358, and is bold enough to add, “and this was unquestionably the year of the
Council.” But in the old collections of canons almost without exception, the canons of
Gangra precede those of Antioch, and Blondel and Tillemont135 have sustained this, which
perhaps I may call the traditional date.
2. There does not seem to be any reasonable ground to doubt that the person con-
demned, Eustathius by name, was the famous bishop of Sebaste. This may be gathered from
both Sozomen136 and Socrates,137 and is confirmed incidentally by one of St. Basil’s
epistles.138 Moreover, Eustathius’s See of Sebaste is in Armenia, and it is to the bishops of
Armenia that the Synod addresses its letter. It would seem in view of all this that Bp. Hefele’s
words are not too severe when he writes, “Under such circumstances the statement of Bar-
onius, Du Pin, and others (supported by no single ancient testimony) that another Eustath-
ius, or possibly the monk Eutactus, is here meant, deserves no serious consideration, though
Tillemont did not express himself as opposed to it.”139
131 Socrat. H. E., Lib. II., cap. xliij.
132 Sozomen. H. E., Lib. IV., cap. xxiv.
133 Remi Ceillier. Hist. Générale des Auteurs Sacrés, Tom. IV., p. 735.
134 E. S. Ffoulkes, in Smith and Cheetham, Dict. Christ. Antiq., s. v. Gangra.
135 I am indebted to Hefele for this reference, and he gives Mémoires, note xxvij., sur St. Basile.
136 Sozom. H. E., III., xiv.
137 Socrat. H. E., II., xliij.
138 S. Basil. M.,Ep. ccxxiij.
139 Hefele. Hist. Councils, Vol. II., p. 337.
Historical Introduction.
182
Historical Introduction.