Chapter XVI.—Scripture the Criterion by Which Truth and Heresy are Distinguished.
3664
But those who are ready to toil in the most
excellent pursuits, will not desist from the search after truth, till
they get the demonstration from the Scriptures themselves.
There are certain criteria common to men, as the
senses; and others that belong to those who have employed their wills
and energies in what is true,—the methods which are pursued by the
mind and reason, to distinguish between true and false propositions.
Now, it is a very great thing to abandon opinion, by
taking one’s stand between accurate knowledge and the rash wisdom
of opinion, and to know that he who hopes for everlasting rest knows
also that the entrance to it is toilsome “and strait.” And
let him who has once received the Gospel, even in the very hour in
which he has come to the knowledge of salvation, “not turn back,
like Lot’s wife,” as is said; and let him not go back
either to his former life, which adheres to the things of sense, or to
heresies. For they form the character, not knowing the true God.
“For he that loveth father or mother more than Me,” the
Father and Teacher of the truth, who regenerates and creates anew, and
nourishes the elect soul,
“is not worthy of Me”—He means, to be a son of God and a
disciple of God, and at the same time also to be a friend, and of kindred
nature. “For no man who looks back, and puts his hand to the plough,
is fit for the kingdom of God.”
3665
But, as appears, many even down to our own time regard
Mary, on account of the birth of her child, as having been in the
puerperal state, although she was not. For some say that, after she
brought forth, she was found, when examined, to be a virgin.
3666
Now such to us are the Scriptures of the Lord,
which gave birth to the truth and continue virgin, in the concealment of
the mysteries of the truth. “And she brought forth, and yet brought
not forth,”
3667
says the Scripture; as having conceived of herself, and not from
conjunction. Wherefore the Scriptures have conceived to Gnostics; but
the heresies, not having learned them, dismissed them as not having
conceived.
Now all men, having the same judgment, some,
following the Word speaking, frame for themselves proofs; while others,
giving themselves up to pleasures, wrest Scripture, in accordance
with their lusts.
3668
And the lover of truth, as I think, needs force
of soul. For those who make the greatest attempts must fail in things of
the highest importance; unless, receiving from the truth itself the rule
of the truth, they cleave to the truth. But such people, in consequence
of falling away from the right path, err in most individual points;
as you might expect from not having the faculty for judging of what is
true and false, strictly trained to select what is essential. For if they
had, they would have obeyed the Scriptures.
3669
As, then, if a man should, similarly to those drugged by
Circe, become a beast; so he, who has spurned the ecclesiastical
tradition, and darted off to the opinions of heretical men, has ceased
to be a man of God and to remain faithful to the Lord. But he who has
returned from this deception, on hearing the Scriptures, and turned his
life to the truth, is, as it were, from being a man made a god.
For we have, as the source of teaching, the Lord, both
by the prophets, the Gospel, and the blessed apostles, “in divers
manners and at sundry times,”
3670
leading from the
beginning of knowledge to the end. But if one should suppose that
another origin
3671
was required, then no longer truly could an
origin be preserved.
He, then, who of himself believes the Scripture and
voice of the Lord, which by the Lord acts to the benefiting of men, is
rightly [regarded] faithful. Certainly we use it as a criterion in the
discovery of things.
3672
What is subjected to criticism is not believed
till it is so subjected; so that what needs criticism cannot be a first
principle. Therefore, as is reasonable, grasping by faith the
indemonstrable first principle, and receiving in abundance, from the
first principle itself, demonstrations in reference to the first
principle, we are by the voice of the Lord trained up to the knowledge
of the truth.
For we may not give our adhesion to men on a bare
statement by them, who might equally state the opposite. But if it is
not enough merely to state the opinion, but if what is stated must be
confirmed, we do not wait for the testimony of men, but we establish
the matter that is in question by the voice of the Lord, which is the
surest of all demonstrations, or rather is the only demonstration; in
which knowledge those who have merely tasted the Scriptures are
believers; while those who, having advanced further, and become correct
expounders of the truth, are Gnostics. Since also, in what pertains to
life, craftsmen are superior to ordinary people, and model what is
beyond common notions; so, consequently, we also, giving a complete
exhibition of the Scriptures from the Scriptures themselves, from faith
persuade by demonstration.
3673
And if those also who follow heresies venture to avail
themselves of the prophetic Scriptures; in the first place they will
not make use of all the Scriptures, and then they will not quote them
entire, nor as the body and texture of prophecy prescribe. But,
selecting ambiguous expressions, they wrest them to their own opinions,
gathering a few expressions here and there; not looking to the sense,
but making use of the mere words. For in almost all the quotations they
make, you will find that they attend to the names alone, while they
alter the meanings; neither knowing, as they affirm, nor using the
quotations they adduce, according to their true nature.
But the truth is not found by changing the meanings (for
so people subvert all true teaching), but in the consideration of what
perfectly belongs to and becomes the Sovereign God, and in establishing
each one of the points demonstrated in the Scriptures again from
similar Scriptures. Neither, then, do they want to turn to the
truth, being ashamed to abandon
the claims of self-love; nor are they able to manage their opinions,
by doing violence to the Scriptures. But having first promulgated false
dogmas to men; plainly fighting against almost the whole Scriptures,
and constantly confuted by us who contradict them; for the rest, even
now partly they hold out against admitting the prophetic Scriptures,
and partly disparage us as of a different nature, and incapable of
understanding what is peculiar to them. And sometimes even they deny
their own dogmas, when these are confuted, being ashamed openly to own
what in private they glory in teaching. For this may be seen in all
the heresies, when you examine the iniquities of their dogmas. For when
they are overturned by our clearly showing that they are opposed to the
Scriptures,
3674
one of two things may be seen to have been done by those who defend the
dogma. For they either despise the consistency of their own dogmas,
or despise the prophecy itself, or rather their own hope. And they
invariably prefer what seems to them to be more evident to what has been
spoken by the Lord through the prophets and by the Gospel, and, besides,
attested and confirmed by the apostles.
Seeing, therefore, the danger that they are in (not in
respect of one dogma, but in reference to the maintenance of the
heresies) of not discovering the truth; for while reading the books we
have ready at hand, they despise them as useless, but in their
eagerness to surpass common faith, they have diverged from the truth.
For, in consequence of not learning the mysteries of ecclesiastical
knowledge, and not having capacity for the grandeur of the truth, too
indolent to descend to the bottom of things, reading superficially,
they have dismissed the Scriptures.
3675
Elated, then, by
vain opinion, they are incessantly wrangling, and plainly care more to
seem
than to
be
philosophers. Not laying as foundations
the necessary first principles of things; and influenced by human
opinions, then making the end to suit them, by compulsion; on account
of being confuted, they spar with those who are engaged in the
prosecution of the true philosophy, and undergo everything, and, as
they say, ply every oar, even going the length of impiety, by
disbelieving the Scriptures,
3676
rather than be removed
from the honours of the heresy and the boasted first seat in their
churches; on account of which also they eagerly embrace that convivial
couch of honour in the Agape, falsely so called.
The knowledge of the truth among us from what
is already believed, produces faith in what is not yet believed; which
[faith] is, so to speak, the essence of demonstration. But, as appears,
no heresy has at all ears to hear what is useful, but opened only to what
leads to pleasure. Since also, if one of them would only obey the truth,
he would be healed.
Now the cure of self-conceit (as of every ailment) is
threefold: the ascertaining of the cause, and the mode of its removal;
and thirdly, the training of the soul, and the accustoming it to assume
a right attitude to the judgments come to. For, just like a disordered
eye, so also the soul that has been darkened by unnatural dogmas cannot
perceive distinctly the light of truth, but even overlooks what is
before it.
They say, then, that in muddy water eels are caught by
being blinded. And just as knavish boys bar out the teacher, so do
these shut out the prophecies from their Church, regarding them with
suspicion by reason of rebuke and admonition. In fact, they stitch
together a multitude of lies and figments, that they may appear acting
in accordance with reason in not admitting the Scriptures. So, then,
they are not pious, inasmuch as they are not pleased with the divine
commands, that is, with the Holy Spirit. And as those almonds are
called empty in which the contents are worthless, not those in which
there is nothing; so also we call those heretics empty, who are
destitute of the counsels of God and the traditions of Christ; bitter,
in truth, like the wild almond, their dogmas originating with
themselves, with the exception of such truths as they could not, by
reason of their evidence, discard and conceal.
As, then, in war the soldier must not leave the post
which the commander has assigned him, so neither must we desert the
post assigned by the Word, whom we have received as the guide of
knowledge and of life. But the most have not even inquired, if there is
one that we ought to follow, and who this is, and how he is to be
followed. For as is the Word, such also must the believer’s life
be, so as to be able to follow God, who brings all things to end from
the beginning by the right course.
But when one has transgressed against the Word, and
thereby against God; if it is through becoming powerless in consequence
of some impression being suddenly made, he ought to see to have the
impressions of reasons at hand. And if it is that he has become
“common,” as the Scripture
3677
says, in consequence of
being overcome the habits which formerly had sway by over him, the
habits must be entirely put a stop to, and the soul trained to oppose
them. And if it appears that conflicting dogmas draw some away, these
must be taken out of the way,
and recourse is to be had to those who reconcile dogmas,
and subdue by the charm of the Scriptures such of the untutored as are
timid, by explaining the truth by the connection of the Testaments.
3678
But, as appears, we incline to ideas founded on opinion,
though they be contrary, rather than to the truth. For it is austere
and grave. Now, since there are three states of the
soul—ignorance, opinion, knowledge—those who are in
ignorance are the Gentiles, those in knowledge, the true Church, and
those in opinion, the Heretics. Nothing, then, can be more clearly seen
than those, who know, making affirmations about what they know, and the
others respecting what they hold on the strength of opinion, as far as
respects affirmation without proof.
They accordingly despise and laugh at one another. And
it happens that the same thought is held in the highest estimation by
some, and by others condemned for insanity. And, indeed, we have
learned that voluptuousness, which is to be attributed to the Gentiles,
is one thing; and wrangling, which is preferred among the heretical
sects, is another; and joy, which is to be appropriated to the Church,
another; and delight, which is to be assigned to the true Gnostic,
another. And as, if one devote himself to Ischomachus, he will make him
a farmer; and to Lampis, a mariner; and to Charidemus, a military
commander; and to Simon, an equestrian; and to Perdices, a trader; and
to Crobylus, a cook; and to Archelaus, a dancer; and to Homer, a poet;
and to Pyrrho, a wrangler; and to Demosthenes, an orator; and to
Chrysippus, a dialectician; and to Aristotle, a naturalist; and to
Plato, a philosopher: so he who listens to the Lord, and follows the
prophecy given by Him, will be formed perfectly in the likeness of the
teacher—made a god going about in flesh.
3679
Accordingly, those fall from this eminence who follow
not God whither He leads. And He leads us in the inspired
Scriptures.
Though men’s actions are ten thousand in number,
the sources of all sin are but two, ignorance and inability. And both
depend on ourselves; inasmuch as we will not learn, nor, on the other
hand, restrain lust. And of these, the one is that, in consequence of
which people do not judge well, and the other that, in consequence of
which they cannot comply with right judgments. For neither will one who
is deluded in his mind be able to act rightly, though perfectly able to
do what he knows; nor, though capable of judging what is requisite,
will he keep himself free of blame, if destitute of power in action.
Consequently, then, there are assigned two kinds of correction
applicable to both kinds of sin: for the one, knowledge and clear
demonstration from the testimony of the Scriptures; and for the other,
the training according to the Word, which is regulated by the
discipline of faith and fear. And both develop into perfect love. For
the end of the Gnostic here is, in my judgment, twofold,—partly
scientific contemplation, partly action.
Would, then, that these heretics would learn and be set
right by these notes, and turn to the sovereign God! But if, like the
deaf serpents, they listen not to the song called new, though very old,
may they be chastised by God, and undergo paternal admonitions previous
to the Judgment, till they become ashamed and repent, but not rush
through headlong unbelief, and precipitate themselves into
judgment.
For there are partial corrections, which are called
chastisements, which many of us who have been in transgression incur,
by falling away from the Lord’s people. But as children are
chastised by their teacher, or their father, so are we by Providence.
But God does not punish, for punishment is retaliation for evil. He
chastises, however, for good to those who are chastised, collectively
and individually.
I have adduced these things from a wish to avert those,
who are eager to learn, from the liability to fall into heresies, and
out of a desire to stop them from superficial ignorance, or stupidity,
or bad disposition, or whatever it should be called. And in the attempt
to persuade and lead to the truth those who are not entirely incurable,
I have made use of these words. For there are some who cannot bear at
all to listen to those who exhort them to turn to the truth; and they
attempt to trifle, pouring out blasphemies against the truth, claiming
for themselves the knowledge of the greatest things in the universe,
without having learned, or inquired, or laboured, or discovered the
consecutive train of ideas,—whom one should pity rather than hate
for such perversity.
But if one is curable, able to bear (like fire or steel)
the outspokenness of the truth, which cuts away and burns their false
opinions, let him lend the ears of the soul. And this will be the case,
unless, through the propensity to sloth, they push truth away, or
through the desire of fame, endeavour to invent novelties. For those
are slothful who, having it in their power to provide themselves with
proper proofs for the divine Scriptures from the Scriptures themselves,
select only what contributes to their own pleasures. And those have a
craving for glory who voluntarily evade, by arguments of a diverse
sort, the things delivered by the blessed apostles and teachers, which
are wedded to inspired words; opposing the divine tradition by human
teachings,
in order to establish the heresy.
3680
For, in truth, what remained
to be said—in ecclesiastical knowledge I mean—by such men,
Marcion, for example, or Prodicus, and such like, who did not walk in
the right way? For they could not have surpassed their predecessors in
wisdom, so as to discover anything in addition to what had been uttered
by them; for they would have been satisfied had they been able to learn
the things laid down before.
Our Gnostic then alone, having grown old in the
Scriptures, and maintaining apostolic and ecclesiastic orthodoxy in
doctrines, lives most correctly in accordance with the Gospel, and
discovers the proofs, for which he may have made search (sent forth as
he is by the Lord), from the law and the prophets. For the life of the
Gnostic, in my view, is nothing but deeds and words corresponding to
the tradition of the Lord. But “all have not knowledge. For I
would not have you to be ignorant, brethren,” says the apostle,
“that all were under the cloud, and partook of spiritual meat
and drink;”
3681
clearly affirming that all who heard
the word did not take in the magnitude of knowledge in deed and
word. Wherefore also he added: “But with all of them He was
not well pleased.” Who is this? He who said, “Why do
you call Me Lord, and do not the will of My Father?”
3682
That is the Saviour’s teaching,
which to us is spiritual food, and drink that knows no thirst, the water
of gnostic life. Further it is said, knowledge is said “to puff
up.” To whom we say: Perchance seeming knowledge is said to puff
up, if one
3683
suppose the expression means “to be swollen up.” But
if, as is rather the case, the expression of the apostle means,
“to entertain great and true sentiments,” the difficulty
is solved. Following, then, the Scriptures, let us establish what has
been said: “Wisdom,” says Solomon, “has inflated her
children.” For the Lord did not work conceit by the particulars
of His teaching; but He produces trust in the truth and expansion of
mind, in the knowledge that is communicated by the Scriptures, and
contempt for the things which drag into sin, which is the meaning of
the expression “inflated.” It teaches the magnificence of
the wisdom implanted in her children by instruction. Now the apostle
says, “I will know not the speech of those that are puffed up,
but the power;”
3684
if ye understand the Scriptures magnanimously
(which means truly; for nothing is greater than truth). For in that
lies the power of the children of wisdom who are puffed up. He says, as
it were, I shall know if ye rightly entertain great thoughts respecting
knowledge. “For God,” according to David, “is known
in Judea,” that is, those that are Israelites according to
knowledge. For Judea is interpreted “Confession.” It is,
then, rightly said by the apostle, “This
Thou, shall not commit
adultery, Thou shall not steal, Thou shalt not covet;
and if there
be any other commandment, it is comprehended in this word,
Thou shalt
love thy neighbour as thyself
.”
3685
For we must never, as do those who follow the heresies,
adulterate the truth, or steal the canon of the Church, by gratifying
our own lusts and vanity, by defrauding our neighbours; whom above all
it is our duty, in the exercise of love to them, to teach to adhere to
the truth. It is accordingly expressly said, “Declare among the
heathen His statutes,” that they may not be judged, but that
those who have previously given ear may be converted. But those who
speak treacherously with their tongues have the penalties that are on
record.
3686
3664
[One of the most important testimonies of primitive antiquity.
Elucidation III.
]
3665
Luke ix. 62
.
3666
[A reference to the sickening and
profane history of an apocryphal book, hereafter to be noted. But this
language is most noteworthy as an absolute refutation of modern
Mariolatry.]
3667
Tertullian, who treats of the above-mentioned topic, attributes
these words to Ezekiel: but they are sought for in vain in Ezekiel,
or in any other part of Scripture. [The
words
are not found in
Ezekiel, but such was his understanding of
Ezek. xliv. 2
.]
3668
[2
Pet. iii. 16.]
3669
[Nothing is Catholic dogma, according to our author,
that is not proved by the Scriptures.]
3670
Heb. i. 1
.
3671
[Absolutely exclusive of any other
source of dogma, than “the faith once delivered to the
saints.”
Jude 3
;
Gal. i. 6–9
.]
3672
[
τῆ κυριακῇ γραφῆ
…
αὐτῇ χρώμεθα κριτηρίῳ
.
Can anything be more decisive, save what follows?]
3673
[An absolute demonstration of the
rule of Catholic faith against the Trent dogmas.]
3674
[Opposition
to the Scriptures is the self-refutation of false dogma.]
3675
[See, e.g.,
Epochs of the
Papacy
, p. 469. New York, 1883.]
3676
[See, e.g.,
Epochs of the
Papacy
, p. 469. New York, 1883.]
3677
An apocryphal Scripture
probably.
3678
[At every point in this chapter, the student may
recognise the primitive rule of faith clearly established.]
3679
[Strong as this language is, it is
based on 2 Pet. i. 4.]
3680
[The divine tradition is here identified with “things delivered by
the blessed apostles.”]
3681
1 Cor. x. 1, 3, 4
.
3682
Luke vi. 46
, combined
with
Matt. vii. 21
.
3683
εἔ
τις
instead of
ἥτις
.
3684
1 Cor. iv. 19
.
3685
Rom. xiii. 9
.
3686
[When we reach
The
Commonitory
of Vincent of Lerins (
a.d.
450), we shall find a strict adherence to what is taught by
Clement.]