From Hegesippus (see above, Bk. III. chap. 32) we learn that
Symeon, the successor of James, was martyred during Trajan’s
reign. As was seen in note 6 of the chapter referred to, the martyrdom
probably occurred early in that reign. Eusebius, in his Chron.,
refers the martyrdom and the accession of Justus to the tenth year of
Trajan (107 a.d.). This leaves thirteen
bishops to be inserted between 107 (or, if this date is not reliable,
98+) and 135 a.d., which is, to say the least,
very suspicious. The true explanation appears to be that, after the
death of Symeon, the last prominent relative of Christ, the presbyters
took the lead, and that they were afterward made by tradition into
successive monarchical bishops. Closs and Gieseler suppose that there
were bishops of a number of churches in Palestine at the same time,
whom tradition made successive bishops of Jerusalem. But the fact is,
that the episcopate is of Greek, not of Jewish, origin, and in the
strictly Jewish Christian churches of Palestine no such person as a
bishop can have existed. Only after the church there came under the
influence of the Gentile church, and lost its prevailingly Jewish
character, was it possible for a bishop, in the general sense of the
term, to exist there. The Jewish Christians assumed for their church
government the form of the Jewish Sanhedrim, though while James and
Symeon were alive, they were naturally leaders (according to the common
Oriental custom, which exalted the relatives of the founder of a
religion). The Jewish character of the Jerusalem congregation was very
marked until the destruction of the city under Hadrian (note that all
but two of the fifteen bishops have Jewish names), after which all
circumcised Jews—Christians as well as unbelievers—were
excluded, and a heathen Christian congregation took its place (see the
next chapter). According to Stroth, followed by Closs, Stigloher, and
Heinichen, the church of Jerusalem remained in Pella after 70 a.d., and was called the church of Jerusalem because
it was made up of Christians from Jerusalem. This is possible; but
Eusebius evidently did not understand it so (compare, too, his Dem.
Evang. III. 5), and Epiphanius (de Mensa et Pond. chap 15)
says expressly that, after the destruction of the city by Titus, the
church returned again to Jerusalem, and there is no good reason to
doubt the report.