Chapter 27.—32. But this is not what we are now inquiring. Let him rather answer
(what he wanders off into the most irrelevant matters in order to avoid answering) by what
means the conscience of the recipient is cleansed who is unacquainted with the stain on the
conscience of the giver, if the conscience of one that gives in holiness is what we look for to
cleanse the conscience of the recipient? and from what source he receive faith who is unwit-
tingly baptized by one that is faithless, if he that has wittingly received his faith from one
that is faithless receives not faith but guilt? Omitting, therefore, his revilings, which he has
cast at me without any sound consideration, let us still notice that he does not say what we
demand in what follows. But I should like to look at the garrulous mode in which he has
set this forth, as though he were sure to overwhelm us with confusion. "But let us return,"
he says, "to that argument of your fancy, whereby you seem to have represented to yourself
in a form of words the persons you baptize. For since you do not see the truth, it would
have been more seemly to have imagined what was probable." These words of his own,
Petilianus put forth by way of preface, being about to state the words that I had used. Then
he went on to quote: "Behold, you say, the faithless man stands ready to baptize, but he who
is to be baptized knows nothing of his faithlessness." 2381 He has not quoted the whole of
my proposition and question; and presently he begins to ask me in his turn, saying, "Who
is the man, and from what corner has he started up, that you propose to us? Why do you
seem to see a man who is the produce of your imagination, in order to avoid seeing one
whom you are bound to see, and to examine and test most carefully? But since I see that
you are unacquainted with the order of the sacrament, I tell you this as shortly as I can: you
were bound both to examine your baptizer, and to be examined by him." What is it, then,
that we were waiting for? That he should tell us by what means the conscience of the recip-
ient is to be cleansed, who is unacquainted with the stain on the conscience of him that gives
but not in holiness, and whence the man is to receive not guilt but faith, who has received
baptism unwittingly from one that is faithless. All that we have heard is that the baptizer
ought most diligently to be examined by him who wishes to receive not guilt but faith, that
the latter may make himself acquainted with the conscience of him that gives in holiness,
which is to cleanse the conscience of the recipient. For the man that has failed to make this
examination, and has unwittingly received baptism from one that is faithless, from the very
fact that he did not make the examination, and therefore did not know of the stain on the
conscience of the giver, was incapacitated from receiving faith instead of guilt. Why therefore
did he add what he made so much of adding,—the word wittingly, which he calumniously
accused me of having suppressed? For in his unwillingness that the sentence should run,
"He who has received his faith from one that is faithless, receives not faith but guilt," he
seems to have left some hope to the man that acts unwittingly. But now, when he is asked
2381 See Book I. c. 2, 3.
Chapter 27
1212
Chapter 27