Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / tekstblob

Tekstblob

sha256: fcd854f1099aadde1a6c13186da647bfeddb7f0457bb55f2f4ad6ffc55b5b0f5 · 6,125 tekens

JEROME. my way like a prudent traveller over every inch of the road, stating repeatedly that, while I receive marriage as a thing in itself admissible, I yet prefer continence, widow- hood, and virginity, the wise and generous reader ought to have judged what seemed hard sayings by my general drift, and not to have charged me with putting forward inconsistent opinions in one and the same book. For who is so dull or so inexperi- enced in writing as to praise and to condemn one and the same object, as to destroy what he has built up, and to build up what he has destroyed ; and when he has vanquished his opponent, to turn his sword, last of all, against himself? Were my detractors coun- try bred or unacquainted with the arts of rhetoric or of logic, I should pardon their want of insight; nor should I censure them for accusing me if I saw that their ignorance was in fault and not their will. As it is, men of intellect who have enjoyed a liberal education make it their object less to under- stand me than to wound me, and for such I have this short answer, that they should cor- rect my faults and not merely censure me for them. The lists are open, I cry; your enemy has marshalled his forces, his posi- tion is plain, and (if I may quote Virgil1) — The foeman calls you: meet him face to face. Such men should answer their opponent. They ought to keep within the limits of de- bate, and not to wield the schoolmaster's rod. Their books should aim at showing in what my statements have fallen short of the truth, and in what they have exceeded it. For, although I will not listen to fault- finders, I will follow the advice of teachers. To direct the fighter how to fight when you yourself occupy a post of vantage on the wall is a kind of teaching that does not commend itself; and when you are yourself bathed in perfumes, it is unworthy to charge a bleeding soldier with cowardice. Nor in saying this do I lay myself open to a charge of boasting that while others have slept I only have entered the lists. My meaning simply is that men who have seen me wounded in this warfare may possibly be a little too cautious in their methods of fight- ing. I would not have you engage in an en- counter in which you will have nothing to do but to protect yourself, your right hand re- maining motionless while your left manages your shield. You must either strike or fall. I cannot account you a victor unless I see your opponent put to the sword. 1 Virg. A. xi. 374, 5. 13. You are, no doubt, men of vast ac- quirements; but we too have studied in the schools, and, like you, we have learned from the precepts of Aristotle — or, rather, from those which he has derived from Gorgias — that there are different ways of speaking ; and we know, among other things, that he who writes for display uses one style, and he who writes to convince, another.1 In the former case the debate is desultory; to confute the opposer, now this argument is adduced and now that. One argues as one pleases, saying one thing while one means another. To quote the proverb, " With one hand one offers bread, in the other one holds a stone."2 In the latter case a certain frankness and openness of countenance are necessary. For it is one thing to start a problem and another to ex- pound what is already proved. The first cal Is for a disputant, the second for a teacher. I stand in the thick of the fray, my life in constant danger: you who profess to teach me are a man of books. " Do not," you say, " attack unexpectedly or wound by a side- thrust. Strike straight at your opponent. You should be ashamed to resort to feints instead of force." As if it were not the per- fection of fighting to menace one part and to strike another. Read, I beg of you, Demosthenes or Cicero, or (if you do not care for pleaders whose aim is to speak plausibly rather than truly) read Plato, Theophrastus, Xenophon, Aristotle, and the rest of those who draw their respective rills of wisdom from the Socratic fountain-head. Do they show any openness? Are they de- void of artifice ? Is not every word they say filled with meaning? And does not this meaning always make for victory? Origen, Methodius, Eusebius, and Apollinaris3 write at great length against Celsus and Porphyry.4 Consider how subtle are the arguments, how insidious the engines with which they overthrow what the spirit of the devil has wrought. Sometimes, it is true, they are compelled to say not what they think but what is needful ; and for this rea- son they employ against their opponents the assertions of the Gentiles themselves. I say nothing of the Latin authors, of Tertullian, Cyprian, Minutius, Victorinus, Lactantius, Hilary, lest I should appear not so much to be defending myself as to be assailing 1 Aliud esse yv/ii/acrriKws scrihere, aliud ioy/u.aTiicu>s. The words do not appear to be used in this sense in the extant works of Aristotle. a Plaut. Aul. ii. 2, 18. 3 The reply of Origen to Celsus is still extant ; those of Me- thodius, Eusebius and Apollinaris to Porphyry have perished. Cf. Letter LXX. § 3. 4 Two philosophic opponents of Christianity who flourished, the first in the second, the second in the third, century of our era.

Alle records · Zoek op deze hash