you also therefore deign to reply to the one question that I ask: Could God suffer injury,
or not? But I ask you to reply: He could not.
Fortunatus said: He could not suffer injury.
24. Augustin said: Wherefore then did He send us hither, according to your faith?
Fortunatus said: My profession is this, that God could not be injured, and that He dir-
ected us hither. But since this is contrary to your view, do you tell how you account for the
soul being here, which our God desires to liberate both by His commandments and by His
own Son whom He has sent.
25. Augustin said: Since I see that you cannot answer my inquiries, and wish to ask
me something, behold I satisfy you, provided only that you bear in mind that you have not
replied to my question. Why the soul is here in this world involved in miseries has been
explained by me not just now, but again and again a little while ago. The soul sinned, and
therefore is miserable. It accepted free choice, used free choice, as it willed; it fell, was cast
out from blessedness, was implicated in miseries. As bearing upon this I recited to you the
testimony of the apostle who says: "As through one man death, so also through one man
came the resurrection of the dead." What more do you ask? Hence do you reply, wherefore
did He, who could not suffer injury, send us hither?
Fortunatus said: The cause must be sought, why the soul came hither, or wherefore
God desires hence to liberate the soul that lives in the midst of evils?
26. Augustin said: This cause I ask of you, that is, if God could not suffer injury,
wherefore He sent us hither?
Fortunatus said: It is inquired of us, if evil cannot injure God, wherefore the soul was
123
sent hither, or for what reason was it mingled with the world? Which is manifest in what
the apostle says: "Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, why hast thou formed
me thus?"260 If therefore this cause must be pleaded, He must be asked, why He sent the
soul, no necessity compelling Him. But if there was necessity for sending the soul, of right
is there also the will of liberating it.
27. Augustin said: Then God is pressed by necessity, is He?
Fortunatus said: Now this is it. Do not seek to bring odium upon what has been said
because we do not make God subject to necessity, but to have voluntarily sent the soul.
28. Augustin said: Recall what was said above. And it runs: "But if there was necessity
for sending the soul, of right is there also the will of liberating it. Augustin said: We have
heard: But if there was necessity for sending the soul, of right is there also the will of liber-
ating it." You, therefore, said that there was necessity for sending the soul. But if you only
wish to say "a will to send," I add this also: He who could suffer no injury, had the cruel will
to send the soul to so great miseries. Because I speak for the sake of refuting this statement,
260 Rom. ix. 20.
204
Disputation of the Second Day.