In a fragment preserved by the Chron. Paschale, and
purporting to be a part of an epistle written from prison, shortly
before his death, by the presbyter Lucian of Antioch to the church of
that city, Anthimus, bishop of Nicomedia, is mentioned as having just
suffered martyrdom (see Routh’s Rel. Sac. IV. p. 5).
Lucian, however, was imprisoned and put to death during the persecution
of Maximinus (a.d. 311 or 312). See below, Bk.
IX. chap. 6, and Jerome’s de vir. ill. chap. 77. It would
seem, therefore, if the fragment given in the Chron. Paschale be
genuine, and there seems no good reason to doubt it, that Anthimus
suffered martyrdom not under Diocletian, but under Maximinus, in 311 or
312. In that case Eusebius is mistaken in putting his death at this
early date, in connection with the members of the imperial household.
Indeed, we see no reason for his execution at this time, and should
find it difficult to explain if we were to accept it. In the time of
Maximinus, however, it is perfectly natural, and of a piece with the
execution of Peter of Alexandria and other notable prelates. Eusebius,
as we have already seen, pays no attention to chronology in this Eighth
Book, and hence there is no great weight to be placed upon his mention
of the death of Anthimus at this particular place. Mason (p. 324) says
that Hunziker (p. 281) has conclusively shown Eusebius’ mistake
at this point. I have not seen Hunziker, and therefore cannot judge of
the validity of his arguments, but, on the grounds already stated, have
no hesitation in expressing my agreement with his conclusion. Of
Anthimus himself, we know nothing beyond what has been already
intimated. In chap. 13, §1, below, he is mentioned again, but
nothing additional is told us in regard to him.
Having observed
Eusebius’ mistake in regard to Anthimus, we realize that there is
no reason to consider him any more accurate in respect to the other
martyrdoms referred to in this paragraph. In fact, it is clear enough
that, in so far as his account is not merely rhetorical, it relates to
events that took place not at this early date, but during a later time
after the regular religious persecution had begun. No such
“multitude” suffered in consequence of the conflagration as
Eusebius thinks. The martyrdoms of which he has heard belong rather to
the time after the Fourth Edict (see below, Mart. Pal. chap. 3,
note 2), or possibly to the still later time when Maximinus was at
Nicomedia, and was in the midst of his bloody career of
persecution.