169
motives inexpressibly manifold and great, and in the utmost conceivable variety—be from
a permanent internal great cause.
If the voice of common sense were heard, there would be no occasion for labour in
multiplying arguments to show, that one act does not prove a fixed inclination; but that
constant pursuit does. We see that, in fact, it is agreeable to the reason of all mankind, to
argue fixed principles tempers, and prevailing inclinations, from repeated and continued
actions—though the actions are voluntary, and performed of choice—and thus to judge of
the tempers and inclinations of persons, ages, sexes, tribes, and nations. But is it the manner
of men to conclude, that whatever they see others once do, they have a fixed abiding inclin-
ation to do? Yea, there may be several acts seen, and yet not be taken as good evidence of
an established propensity; even though that one act, or those several acts, are followed by
such constant practice, as afterwards evidences fixed disposition. As for example; there may
be several instances of a man drinking some spirituous liquor, and those instances be no
sign of a fixed inclination to that liquor: but these acts may be introductory to a settled habit
or propensity, which may be made very manifest afterwards by constant practice.
From these things it is plain, that what is alleged concerning the first sin of Adam, and
of the angels, without a previous fixed disposition to sin, cannot in the least weaken the ar-
guments brought to prove fixed propensity to sin in mankind, in their present state. From
the permanence of the cause has been argued, the permanence of the effect. And that the
permanent cause consists in an internal fixed propensity, and not in any particular external
circumstances, has been argued from the effects being the same, through a vast variety and
change of circumstances. But the first acts of sin in Adam or the angels, considered in
themselves, were no permanent, continued effects. And though a great number of the angels
sinned, and the effect on that account was the greater, and more extensive; yet this extent
of the effect is a very different thing from that permanence, or settled continuance of effect,
which is supposed to show a permanent cause, or fixed propensity. Neither was there any
trial of a vast variety of circumstances attending a permanent effect, to show the fixed cause
to be internal, consisting in a settled disposition of nature, in the instances objected. And
however great the sin of Adam, or of the angels, was, and however great the means, motives,
and obligations were against which they sinned—and whatever may be thence argued con-
cerning the transient cause, occasion, or temptation, as being very subtle, remarkably
tending to deceive and seduce, &c.—yet it argues nothing of any settled disposition, or fixed
cause, either great or small; the effect both in the angels and our first parents, being in itself
transient, and, for ought appears, happening in each of them under one system or coincidence
of influential circumstances. 18
18 See p. 81, note.
997
SECTION IX. Several evasions considered.