SECT. I.
Remarks on Dr. T.’s way of explaining this text.
The following things are worthy of notice, concerning our author’s exposition of this remarkable passage.
I. He greatly insists, that by
death
in this place no more is meant, than that death which we all die, when this present life is extinguished, and the body returns to the dust. That no more is meant in
Rom. v.12, 14, 15, 17,
(p. 27.) he declares as
evidently, clearly, and infallibly so
, because the apostle is till discoursing on the same subject; plainly implying, that
infallibly
the apostle means no more by death, throughout
this paragraph on the subject. But as infallible as this is, if we believe what Dr. T. says elsewhere, it must needs be otherwise: for (p. 120. S) speaking of those words in
Rom. vi. 23.
“The wages of sin is
death
, but the gift of God is
eternal life
, through Jesus Christ our Lord,” he says, “Death in this place is widely different from the death we
now die
; as it stands there
opposed to eternal life
, which is the gift of God through Jesus
Christ, it manifestly signifies
eternal death,
the
second death
, or that death which they shall
hereafter die
, who live after the flesh.” But the death (in the conclusion of the paragraph we are upon) that comes by Adam, and the life that comes by Christ (in the last verse of the chapter), is
opposed to eternal life
just in the same manner as in the last verse of the next chapter: “That as sin has reigned unto
death
, even so might grace reign through
righteousness, unto
eternal life
, by Jesus Christ our Lord.” So that by our author’s own argument, death in
this
place also, is
manifestly widely different from the death we now die, as it stands here opposed to eternal life, through Jesus Christ
;
and signifies eternal death, the second death
. And yet this is a part of the
same discourse
, begun in
Rom. v. 12
; as reckoned by Dr. T. himself in his division of paragraphs, in his paraphrase
and notes on the epistle. So that if we will follow him, and admit his reasonings in the various parts of his book, here is
manifest
proof, against
infallible
evidence! So that it is true, the apostle throughout this whole passage on the same subject, by death,
evidently, clearly,
and
infallibly means no more than that death we now die, when this life is extinguished
; and yet by death, in some part of this passage, is meant something
widely different from
the death we now die
—manifestly
eternal death, the second death
.
But had our author been more consistent with
himself
, in laying it down as certain and
infallible
, that because the apostle has a special respect to temporal death, in ”
Death reigned from
Adam
to
Moses,”
304
therefore he means no more in the several consequent parts of this passage, yet he is doubtless too confident and positive in this matter. This is no more
evident, clear,
and
infallible
, than that Christ meant by
perishing
—in
Luke xiii. 5.
when he says,
I tell you, Nay, but except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish—
no more than such a temporal death, as came on those who died by the fall of the tower of
Siloam
, spoken of
in the preceding words of the same speech; and no more infallible, than that by
life
, Christ means no more than this temporal life, in each part of that one sentence—
Matt. x. 39.
“He that findeth his
life
shall lose
it
; and he that loseth his
life
for my sake, shall find
it
“—because in the first part of each clause he has respect especially to temporal life.
305
The truth of the case, with respect to what the apostle here intends by the word
death
, is this,
viz.
The whole of that death which he, and the Scripture everywhere, speaks of as the proper wages and punishment of sin, including death
temporal, spiritual,
and
eternal
; though in some parts of this discourse he has a more special respect to one part of this whole, in others to another, as his argument leads him; without any more variation
than is quite common in the same discourse. That life, which the Scripture speaks of as the reward of righteousness, is a whole containing several parts,
viz
. The life of the body, union of soul and body, and the most perfect sensibility, activity, and felicity of both, which is the chief thing. In like manner the death, which the Scripture speaks of as the punishment of sin, is a whole including the death of the body and the death of the soul, and the eternal, sensible, perfect
destruction and misery of both. It is this latter whole, that the apostle speaks of by the name of death in this discourse, in
Rom. v.
though in some sentences he has a more special respect to one part, in others to another: and this, without changing the signification of the word. For having respect to several things included in the extensive signification of the word, is not the same thing as using the word in several distinct significations. As for instance, the
appellative,
man,
or the proper name of any particular man, is the name of a whole, including the different parts of soul and body. And if any one in speaking of
James
or
John
, should say, he was a wise
man
, and a beautiful
man
; in the former part of the sentence, respect would be had more especially to his soul, in the latter to his body, in the word
man
: but yet without any proper change of the signification of the name to distinct senses. In
John xxi. 7.
it is said,
Peter was naked
, and in the following part of the same story it is said,
Peter was grieved
. In the former proposition, respect is had especially to his body, in the latter to his soul: but yet here is no proper change of the meaning of the name,
Peter
. And as to the apostle’s use of the word
death
in the passage now under consideration, on the supposition that he in general means the whole of that death which is the wages
of sin, there is nothing but what is perfectly natural in supposing that—in order to evince that death, the proper punishment of sin, comes on all mankind in consequence of
Adam’s
sin—he should take notice of that part of this punishment which is visible in this world, and which every body therefore sees does in fact come on all mankind (
as in ver. 14
). And is it not equally natural from thence to infer, that all mankind are exposed to the
whole of that death which is the proper punishment of sin, whereof temporal death is a part, and a visible image of the whole, and (unless changed by divine grace) an introduction to the principal, and infinitely the most dreadful, part?
II. Dr. T.’s explanation of this passage makes wholly insignificant those first words,
By one man sin entered into the world
, and leaves this proposition without any sense at all. The apostle had been largely and elabourately representing, how the whole world was full of sin, both among
Jews
and
Gentiles
, and all exposed to death and condemnation. It is plain, that in these words he would tell us how this came to pass, namely, that the sorrowful
event came
by one man
, even the first man. That the world was full of sin, and full of death, were two great and notorious facts, deeply affecting the interests of mankind; and they seemed very wonderful facts, drawing the attention of the more thinking part of mankind every where, who often asked this question.
Whence comes evil
, moral and natural evil? It is manifest, the apostle here means to tell us, how these came into the world, and came to prevail in it as they do. But all
that is meant, according to Dr. T.’s interpretation, is, ”
He began transgression
“.
306
As if all that the apostle meant, was, to tell us who happened to sin first; not how such a malady came upon the world, or how anyone in the world, besides
Adam
himself, came by such a distemper. The words of the apostle, “By one man sin entered
into the world
, and death by sin,” show the design to be, to tell us how these evils came, as affecting the state of
the world
; and not only as reaching one man in the world. If this were not plain enough in
itself, the words immediately following demonstrate it; “And so death passed upon
all men
, for that all have sinned.” By
sin being in the world
, the apostle does not mean being in the world only in that
one instance
of
Adam’s
first transgression, but being
abroad in the world,
among the inhabitants of the earth, in a wide extent, and continued series of wickedness; as is plain in the first words of the next verse, “For until the law, sin was
in the
world
.” And therefore when he gives us an account how it came to be
in the world
, or, which is the same thing, how it
entered into the world
, he does not mean only coming in one instance.
If the case were as Dr. T. represents, that the sin of
Adam,
either in its pollution or punishment, reached none but himself, any more than the sin of any other man, it would be no more proper to say, that
by one man sin entered into the world
, than if—were it inquired, how mankind came into
America,
and there had anciently been a ship of the
Phoenicians
wrecked at sea, and a single man of the crew was driven on this continent, and here
died as soon as he reached the shore—it should be said,
By that one man mankind came into America
.
Besides, it is not true, that by
one man,
or by
Adam,
sin entered into the world, in Dr. T.’s sense: for it was not he but
Eve
that
began transgression
. By one man Dr. T. understands
Adam,
as the figure of Christ. And it is plain, that it was for
his
transgression, and not
Eve’s
, that the sentence of death was pronounced on mankind after the fall,
Gen. iii. 19.
It appears unreasonable to suppose
the apostle means to include
Eve,
when he speaks of
Adam
; for he lays great stress on it, that it was BY ONE, repeating it several times.
III. In like manner this author brings to nothing the sense of the causal particles, in such phrases as these, so often repeated,
Rom. v. 12
“Death
by
sin,”
Rom. v. 15
“If
through
the offence of one, many be dead,”
Rom. v. 16
”
by
one that sinned,—judgment was
by
one to condemnation,”
Rom. v. 17
”
By
one man’s offence, death reigned by one,”
Rom. v. 18
”
By
the offence of one, judgment came upon all,” &c.,
Rom. v. 19
”
By
one man’s disobedience.” These
causal
particles, so variously repeated, unless we make mere nonsense of the discourse, signify some connexion and dependence, by some sort of influence of that sin of one man, or some tendency to that effect, which is so often said to come by it. But according to Dr. T. there can be no
real
dependence or
influence in the case, of any sort whatsoever. There is no connexion by any
natural
influence of that one act to make all mankind mortal. Our author does not pretend to account for this effect in any such manner, but in another most diverse,
viz.
A gracious act of God, laying mankind under affliction, toil, and death, from special favour and kindness. Nor can there be any dependence of this effect on that transgression of
Adam
, by any
moral
influence, as deserving
such a consequence, or exposing to it on any
moral account
: for he supposes, that mankind are not in this way exposed to the least degree of evil. Nor has this effect any
legal
dependence on that sin, or any connexion by virtue of any antecedent constitution, which God had established with
Adam
: for he insists, that in that threatening, “In the day thou eatest thou shalt die,” there is not a word said of his posterity (p. 8). And death on mankind, according to him,
cannot come by virtue of that legal constitution with
Adam
; because the sentence by which it came was after the annulling and abolishing that constitution (p. 113. S.) And it is manifest, that this consequence cannot be through any kind of
tendency
of that sin to such an effect; because the effect comes only as a benefit, and is the fruit of mere favour: but sin has no tendency, either
natural or moral,
to
benefits
, and divine favours. And thus that sin of
Adam
could neither be
the efficient
cause, nor the
procuring
cause; neither the
natural, moral, nor legal
cause; nor an
exciting and moving
cause, any more than Adam’s eating of
any other tree of the garden. And the only real relation that the effect can have to that sin, is a relation as to time,
viz.
that it is
after
it. And when the matter is closely examined, the whole amounts to no more than this, that God is pleased, of his mere good
will and pleasure, to bestow a greater favour upon us, than he did upon Adam in innocency,
after that sin
of his eating the forbidden fruit; which sin we are no more concerned in, than in the sin of the king of
Pegu,
or the emperor of
China
.
IV. It is altogether inconsistent with the apostle’s scope, and the import of what he says, to suppose that the death of which he here speaks, as coming on mankind by Adam’s sin, comes not as a
punishment,
but only as a
favour.
It quite makes void the
opposition,
in which the apostle sets the consequences of
Adam’s sin,
and the consequences of the
grace and righteousness of Christ.
They are set in opposition to each other, as
opposite effects, arising from opposite causes, throughout the paragraph: one,
as the just consequence of an offence
; the other,
a free gift,
Rom. v. 15-18.
Whereas, according to this scheme, there is no such opposition in the case; both are benefits, and both are free gifts. A very wholesome medicine to save from perishing, ordered by a kind father, or a shield to preserve from an enemy, bestowed by a friend, is as much a free gift as pleasant food.
The death that comes by Adam, is set in opposition to the life and happiness that comes by Christ, as being the fruit of
sin, and judgment for sin
: when the latter is the fruit of
divine grace,
Rom. v. 15, 17, 20, 21.
Whereas, according to our author, both came by grace. Death comes on mankind by the free kindness and love of God, much more truly and properly than by
Adam’s sin.
Dr. T. speaks of it as coming
by
occasion o
f Adam’s
sin
: but, as I have observed, it is an occasion without any influence. Yet the proper cause
is God’s grace.
So that the true cause is wholly good. Which, by the way, is directly repugnant to the apostle’s doctrine in
Rom. vii. 13.
“Was then that which is good made death unto me? God forbid. But sin, that it might appear sin, working death in me by that which is good.” Where the apostle utterly rejects any such suggestion, as though that which is good were
the proper cause of death
; and signifies that
sin
is the proper
cause,
and that which is
good,
only the
occasion
. But according to this author, the reverse is true: that which is good in the highest sense, even the love of God, and a divine gracious constitution, is the proper
cause
of death, and sin only the
occasion.
But to return, it is plain, that death by Adam, and life and happiness b
y
Christ,
are here set in opposition: the latter being spoken of as
good,
the other as
evil
; one as the effect
of righteousness,
the other of an
offence
; one of the fruit
of obedience,
the other
of disobedience
; one as the fruit of
God’s favour,
in consequence of what
was pleasing and acceptable to him
, but the
other the fruit of
his displeasure,
in consequence of what was
displeasing and hateful
to him; the latter coming by
justification,
the former by the
condemnation
of the subject. But according to the scheme of our author, there can be no opposition in any of these respects: the death here spoken of, neither comes as an
evil,
nor from an
evil
cause
; either an evil
efficient
cause,
or procuring
cause, nor at all as any testimony
of God’s
displeasure
to the subject, but as properly the effect of
his favour,
no less than that which is spoken of as coming by Christ; yea, as much as an act of justification of the subject; as he understands and explains the word
justification
; for both are made
by a grant of favour
, and are instances of mercy and goodness. And he abundantly insists upon it, that “any grant of favour, any instance of mercy and goodness, whereby God delivers and exempts from
any kind of danger, suffering, or calamity, or confers any favour, blessing, or privilege, is called
justification
in the scripture-sense and use of the word.
307
Moreover, our author makes void the grand and fundamental opposition—to illustrate which is the chief scope of this whole passage—between
the first and second Adam
; in the
death
that comes by
one,
and the
life
and happiness by the
other.
For, according to his doctrine,
both come by Christ the second Adam
; both by his grace, righteousness, and obedience: the death to which God sentenced mankind (
Gen.
iii. 19.
) being a great deal more properly and truly by Christ, than by
Adam
. For, according to him, that sentence was not pronounced on the basis of the covenant with
Adam
; because that was abrogated, and entirely set aside, as he largely insists for many pages together, (p. 113-120. S.) “This covenant with
Adam
was disannulled immediately after
Adam sinned.
Even before God passed sentence upon
Adam,
grace was introduced.” “The death that
mankind are the subjects of now, stands under the covenant of grace.—In the counsel and appointment of God, it stood in this very light, even before the sentence of death was pronounced upon
Adam
: and consequently, death is no proper and legal punishment of sin.” And he often insists, that it comes only as a favour and benefit; and standing, as he says, under the covenant of grace, which is by Christ, therefore is truly one of the benefits of the new covenant, which comes by
Christ, the second
Adam.
For he himself is decided, to use his own words,
308
“That all the grace of the gospel is dispensed to us, in, by, or through The Son of God.” “Nothing is clearer (says he
309
) from the whole current of Scripture, than that all the mercy and love of God, and all the blessings of the gospel, from first to last, are in, by, and through Christ, and particularly by his blood, by the redemption that is in him. This can bear no dispute among Christians.” What then becomes of all this discourse of the apostle’s, about the great difference and opposition between
Adam and Christ
; as death is by one, and eternal life and happiness by the other? This grand
distinction between the two Adams, it seems, and the other instances of opposition and difference here insisted on—as between the effects of
sin and righteousness,
the consequences of
obedience
and
disobedience,
of the
offence
and the
free gift, judgment and grace, condemnation and justification—
all come to nothing. And this whole discourse of the apostle, wherein he seems to labour much, as if it were to set forth some very grand and most important
distinction and oppositions
in the state of things, as derived from the two great
heads
of mankind, proves nothing but a multitude of words without meaning, or rather a heap of inconsistencies.
V. Our author’s own doctrine entirely
makes void
what he supposes to be the apostle’s argument
,
in
Rom. v. 13, 14
, in these words; “For until the law, sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed where there is no law. Nevertheless death reigned from
Adam
to
Moses,
even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of
Adam’s
transgression.”
What he supposes the apostle would prove here, is, that the mortality of mankind comes only by
Adam’s
sin, and not by men’s
personal
sins, because there was
no law
threatening death to
Adam’s
posterity for
personal
sins, before the law of
Moses
; but death, or the mortality of
Adam’s
posterity, took place many ages before the law was given; therefore death could not be by any law threatening death for
personal
sins, and consequently could be by nothing but
Adam’s
sin.
310
On this I would observe,
1. That which he supposes the apostle to take for a truth in this argument,
viz.
That there was
no law of God
in being, by which men were exposed to death for
personal sin,
during the time from
Adam
to
Moses,
is neither true, nor agreeable to this apostle’s own doctrine.
First,
The assertion is
not true.
For the law of
nature,
written in men’s hearts, was then in being, and was a law by which men were exposed to death for
personal
sin. That there was a divine establishment, fixing the death and destruction of the sinner as the consequence of personal sin, which was well known before the giving of the law by Moses, is plain by many passages in the book of
Job
, as fully and clearly implying a
connexion between such sin and such a punishment, as any passage in the law of
Moses
: such as that in
Job xxiv. 19.
“Drought and heat consume the snow-waters; so doth the grave them that have sinned.” (Compare
Job. xxiv. 20, 24.
) Also
Job xxxvi. 6.
“He preserveth not the life of the wicked.”
Job xxi. 29-32,
“Have ye not asked them that go by the way ? and do ye not know their tokens?
That the wicked is reserved to the day of destruction; they shall be brought forth to the day of wrath.”
Job xxi. 32.
“He shall be wrought to the grave.”
311
Secondly.
To suppose that there is no law in being, by which men are exposed to death for
personal sin,
when a revealed law of God is not in being,
is contrary to our apostle’s own doctrine
in this epistle.
Rom. ii. 12, 14, 15.
” For as many as have sinned without law (
i. e.
the revealed law) shall perish without law.” But how they can be exposed to die and perish, who have not the law of
Moses,
nor any
revealed
law,
the apostle shows us in
Rom. ii. 14,15.
;
viz.
in that they have the law of nature, by which they fall under sentence to this punishment. “For when the
Gentiles,
which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these having not the law, are a law to themselves; which show the work of the law written in their hearts; their conscience also bearing witness.” —Their
conscience not only bore witness to the duty prescribed by this law, but also to the
punishment
before spoken of, at that which they who sinned without law, were liable to suffer,
viz
. that they should
perish
. In which the apostle is yet more express,
Rom. i. 32.
speaking more especially of the heathen, “Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death.” Dr. T. often calls the law the
rule of right
;
and this rule of right sentenced those sinners to death, who were not under the law of
Moses,
according to this author’s own paraphrase of this verse, in these words, “The heathen were not ignorant of the
rule of right,
which God had implanted in the human nature; and which shows that they which commit such crimes, are deserving of death.” And he himself supposes
Abraham,
who lived between
Adam
and
Moses,
to be
under law,
by which he would have,
been
exposed to punishment without hope,
were it not for the promise of grace.—(Paraph. on
Rom. iv. 15.
)
So that in our author’s way of explaining the passage before us, the grand argument which the apostle insists upon here to prove his main point,
viz.
that death does not come by men’s
personal sin,
but by
Adam’s
sin, because it came
before
the law was given, that threatened death for personal sin; I say, this argument which Dr T. supposes so clear and strong,
312
is brought to nothing more then a mere shadow without substance; the very foundation of the argument having no truth. To say, there was no such law actually expressed in any standing revelation, would be mere trifling. For it no more appears, that God would not bring
temporal
death for personal sins without a standing revealed law threatening it, than that he would not bring
eternal
death before there was a revealed law threatening that: which yet wicked men that
lived in
Noah’s
time, were exposed to, as appears by
1 Pet. iii. 19, 20.
and which Dr. T. supposes all mankind are exposed to by their personal sins; and he himself says.
313
” Sin in its own unalterable nature leads to death.” Yea, it might be argued with as much strength of reason, that God could bring on men
no punishment at all
for any sin, that was committed from
Adam
to
Moses
, because there was no standing revealed law then extant threatening any punishment. It may here be properly observed, that our author supposes, the shortening of man’s days, and hastening of death,
entered into the world by the sin of the
antediluvians,
in the same sense as death and mortality entered into the world by
Adam’s
sin.
314
But where was there any standing revealed law for that, though, the event was so universal? If God might bring this on all mankind, on occasion of
other
men’s sins, for which they deserved nothing, without a revealed law, what could there be to hinder God bringing death on men for their
personal
sins, for which their own consciences tell them they deserve death without a revealed law?
2. If from
Adam
to
Moses
there had been no law in being, of any kind, revealed or natural, by which men could be properly exposed to temporal death for personal sin, yet the mention of
Moses
law would have been wholly impertinent, and of no signification in the argument, according to our author. He supposes that what the apostle would prove, is, that
temporal
death comes by
Adam
; and not by
any law
threatening such a
punishment for personal sin; because this death prevailed before the law of
Moses
was in being, which is the only law threatening death for personal sin. And yet he himself supposes, that the law of
Moses, when it was in
being,
threatened
no such death
for personal sin. For he abundantly asserts, that the death which the law of
Moses
threatened for personal sin,
was eternal death,
as has been already noted: and he says in express terms, that
eternal death is of a nature
widely different from the death we now die
;||
315
as was also observed before.
How impertinently therefore does Dr. T- make an inspired writer argue, when, according to him, the apostle would prove, that
this kind of death
did not come by any law threatening
this kind of death,
because it came before the existence of a law threatening
another kind of death,
of a nature
widely different
! How is it to the apostle’s purpose, to fix on that period, the time of giving
Moses’s
law, as if that had been the
period wherein men began to be threatened with
this punishment
for their personal sins, when in truth it was no such thing? And therefore it was no more to this purpose to fix on that period, from
Adam
to
Moses,
than from
Adam
to
David,
or any other period whatsoever. Dr. T. holds, that even now, since the law of
Moses
has been given, the mortality of mankind, or the death we now die, does not come by that law; but that it always comes only by
Adam
.
316
And if it
never comes
by that law, we may be sure it
never was
threatened
in that law.
3. If we should allow the argument in Dr. T.‘s sense of it, to prove that death does not come by
personal sin,
yet it will be wholly without force to prove the main point, even that it must come by
Adam’s sin
: for it might come by God’s sovereign and gracious pleasure; as innumerable other divine benefits do. If it be ordered, agreeable to our author’s supposition, not as a punishment, nor as a calamity, but only as a
favour,
what
necessity of any settled constitution, or revealed sentence, in order to bestow
such
a favour, more than
other
favours; and particularly more than that
great benefit,
which he says entered into the world by the sin of the
antediluvians,
the shortening men’s lives so much after the flood? Thus the apostle’s arguing, by Dr. T.‘s explanation of it, is turned into mere trifling, a vain and impertinent use of words, without any real force or significance.
VI. The apostle here speaks of that great benefit which we have by Christ, as the antitype of
Adam,
under the notion of the fruit of grace. I do not mean only that
superabounding
of grace wherein the benefit we have by Christ goes beyond the damage sustained by
Adam
; but that benefit, with regard to which
Adam was the figure of him that was to come
, and which is as it were the counterpart of the suffering by Adam, and which repairs
the loss we have by him. This is here spoken of as the fruit of the
free grace of God
; (as appears by
Rom. v. 15-18, 20, 21.
) which according to our author, is the restoring of mankind to that life which they lost in
Adam
: and he himself supposes this restoration of life by Christ to be what
grace
does for us
,
and calls it the
free gift of God
, and the
grace and favour of the lawgiver
.*
317
And speaking of this restoration, he breaks out in admiration of the
unspeakable riches of this grace
.†
318
But it follows from his doctrine, that there is no
grace at all
in this benefit, and it is no more than a mere act of
justice
, being only a removing of what mankind suffer, being
innocent
. Death, as it commonly comes on mankind, and even on infants, (as has been observed,) is an extreme, positive calamity; to bring which on the perfectly
innocent
, unremedied, and without any thing to countervail it, we are sufficiently taught, is not
consistent with the
righteousness of the judge of all the earth
. What
grace
therefore, worthy of being so celebrated, would there be in affording remedy and relief, after there had been brought on
innocent mankind that which is (as Dr. T. himself represents
319
) the dreadful and universal destruction of their nature; being a striking demonstration how infinitely hateful sin is to God! What
grace
in delivering from such shocking ruin, them who did not deserve the least calamity! Our author says, “We could not
justly
lose communion with God by
Adam’s
sin.”
320
If so, then we could not justly lose our lives, and be annihilated, after a course of extreme pains and agonies of body and mind, without any restoration; which would be an eternal loss of communion with God, and all other good, besides the positive suffering. The apostle, throughout this passage, represents the
death
which is the consequence of
Adam’s
transgression, as coming in a way of
judgment
and
condemnation
for sin; but deliverance and life
through Christ, as by
grace
, and the
free gift
of God. Whereas, on the contrary, by Dr. T.‘s scheme, the death that comes by
Adam,
comes by
grace, great grace
; it being a great benefit, ordered in fatherly love and kindness, and on the basis of a covenant of grace: but in the deliverance and restoration by Christ, there is
no grace at all.
So things are turned
topsy-turvy,
the apostle’s scope and scheme entirely inverted and confounded.
VII. Dr. T. explains the words,
judgment, condemnation, justification,
and
righteousness,
as used in this place in a very unreasonable manner.
I will first consider the sense he puts upon the two former,
judgment
and
condemnation.
He often calls this condemnation a
judicial act,
and a
sentence of condemnation.
But, according to his scheme, it is a judicial sentence of condemnation passed upon them who are perfectly
innocent—
and viewed by the judge, even in passing the condemnatory sentence, as having no guilt of sin, or any fault at all chargeable upon them—and a
judicial proceeding, passing sentence
arbitrarily, without any law or rule of right before established. For there was no preceding law threatening death, that he or any one else ever pretended to have been established, but only this, “In the day that thou eatest thereof, thou shall surely die.” And concerning this he insists, that there is not a word said in it of Adam’s posterity. So that the condemnation spoken of, is a sentence of condemnation to death, for, or in consequence of, the
sin of
Adam,
without any law by which that sin could be imputed to bring any such consequence; contrary to the apostle’s plain scope. And not only so, but, over and above all this, it is a
judicial sentence
of
condemnation
to that which is no calamity, nor is considered as such in the sentence; but a condemnation to a great favour!
The apostle uses the words
judgment
and
condemnation
in other places; they are no strange and unusual terms with him: but never are they used by him in this sense, or any like it; nor are they ever used thus any where else in the New Testament. This apostle, in this epistle to the
Romans,
often speaks of
condemnation,
using the same or similar terms and phrases as here, but never in the above said sense.
321
This will be plain to every one who casts his eye on those places. And if we look into the former part of this chapter, the apostle’s discourse makes it evident, that he is speaking of a condemnation, which is no testimony of
favor
to the innocent; but of God’s
displeasure
towards those to whom he is not reconciled, but looks on as offenders and enemies, and holds as the objects of his
wrath,
from which we are delivered by Christ. (See
ver. 6-11.
)
And even viewing this discourse itself, in the very paragraph we are upon, if we may judge any thing by language, there is every thing to lead us to suppose, that the apostle uses words here, as he does elsewhere,
properly,
and as implying a supposition of sin, chargeable on the subject, and exposing to punishment. He speaks of
condemnation
as what
comes by sin,
a condemnation to
death,
which seems to be a most terrible evil, and capital
punishment, even in what is temporal and visible: and this in the way of
judgment
and execution of justice, in opposition to
grace
or
favour,
and
gift,
or a benefit coming by favour. And sin, offence, transgression, and disobedience are, over and over again, spoken of as the
ground
of the condemnation, and of the capital suffering, for ten verses successively; that is, in every verse in the whole paragraph.
The words
, justification
and
righteousness,
are explained by Dr. T. in a manner no less unreasonable. He understands
justification,
in
ver. 18.
and
righteousness,
in
ver. 19.
in such a sense, as to suppose they belong to all, and are actually to be applied to all mankind, good and bad, believers and unbelievers; to the worst enemies of God, remaining
such, as well as his peculiar favourites, and many that never had any sin imputed to them; meaning thereby no more than what is fulfilled in an universal resurrection from the dead, at the last day.
322
Now this is a most arbitrary, forced sense. Though these terms are used all over the New Testament, yet nothing like such an use of them is to be found in any one instance. The words
justify, justification,
and
righteousness,
as from God to men, are never used but to signify a
privilege
belonging only to
some,
and that which is peculiar to
distinguished favourites.
This apostle in particular, above all the other writers of the New Testament,
abounds in the use of these terms; so that we have all imaginable opportunity to understand his language, and know the sense in which he uses these words: but he never elsewhere uses them in the sense supposed here, nor is there any
pretence
that he does. Above all, this apostle abounds in the use of these terms in this epistle. justification is the subject he had been upon through all the preceding part of the epistle. It was the grand subject of all the foregoing chapters, and the
preceding part of this chapter, where these terms are continually repeated. And the word,
justification,
is constantly used to signify something peculiar to believers, who had been sinners; implying some reconciliation and forgiveness of sin, and special privilege in nearness to God, above the rest of the world. Yea, the word is constantly used thus, according to Dr. T’s own explanations, in his paraphrase and notes on this epistle. And there is not the least reason to suppose but that
he is
still
speaking of the
same justification,
which he had dwelt upon from the beginning to this place. He speaks of
justification
and
righteousness
here, just in the same manner as he had done in the preceding part of the epistle. He had all along spoken of justification as standing in relation to
sin,
disobedience to God, and offence against him, and so he does here. He had before been speaking of justification through free
grace,
and so he does
here. He before had been speaking of justification through
righteousness, as in Christ Jesus,
and so he does here.
And if we look into the former part of this very chapter, we shall find
justification
spoken of just in the same sense as in the rest of the epistle; which is also supposed by our author in his exposition. It is still
justification by faith, justification
of them who had been
sinners, justification
attended with
reconciliation, justification
peculiar to them who had
the love of God shed abroad in their hearts.
The apostle’s
foregoing discourse on justification by grace through faith—and what he had so greatly insisted on as the evidence of the truth of this doctrine, even the universal sinfulness of mankind in their original state—is plainly what introduces this discourse in the latter part of this
5th chapter;
where he shows how all mankind came to be sinful and miserable, and so to need this grace of God, and righteousness of Christ. And therefore we cannot, without the
most absurd violence, suppose any other than that he is still speaking of the same
justification.
And as to the universal expression used in the
18th verse
, “by the righteousness of one, the free gift came upon
all men
to justification of life;” it is needless here to go into the controversy between
the remonstrants and anti-remonstrants,
concerning universal redemption, and their different interpretations of this place. If we take the words even as the
Arminians
do; yet, in their sense of them, the
free gift comes on all men to justification only
conditionally, i. e. provided
they believe, repent, &c. But in our author’s sense, it
actually
comes on all, whether they believe and repent, or not; which certainly cannot be inferred from the universal expression, as here used. Dr. T. himself supposes, the main design of the apostle in this universal phrase,
all men,
is to signify that the benefits
of Christ shall come on
Gentiles
as well as
Jews.*
And he supposes
that the Many and the All,
here signify the same; but it is quite certain, that all the benefits here spoken of, which the apostle says are to
the many,
does not
actually
come upon all mankind; as particularly
the abounding of grace
,
ver. 15.
“The grace of God, and the gift by grace, hath abounded unto the many
(NOT ENGLISH)
.”
This abounding of grace our author explains thus; “a rich overplus of grace, in erecting a new dispensation, furnished with a glorious fund of light, means, and motives,” (p. 44.) But will any pretend, that all mankind have actually been partakers of this new fund of light, &c. How were the many millions of
Indians,
on the
American
side of the globe, partakers of it, before the
Europeans
came hither? Yea, Dr. T. himself supposes,
that it
is only free for all that are willing to accept of it
.
323
The agreement between
Adam
as the type or figure of him that was to come, and
Christ
as the anti-type, appears full and clear, if we suppose that all who are in christ (to use the common scripture phrase) have the benefit of his obedience, even as all who are in adam have the sorrowful fruit of his disobedience. The Scripture speaks of believers as the seed or posterity of Christ. (
Gal. iii. 29.
) They are
in Christ by grace,
as
Adam’s
posterity
are in him by nature.
See also
1 Cor. xv. 45-49.
The spiritual seed are those which this apostle often represents as
Christ’s body
: and the
NOT ENGLISH
. here spoken of as made righteous by Christ’s obedience, are doubtless the same with the
NOT ENGLISH
which he speaks of in chap.
chap. xii.5.
We, being many, are one body
; or,
we,
the many,
NOT
ENGLISH
. And again,
1 Cor. x. 17.
NOT ENGLISH.
And the same which the apostle had spoken of in the preceding chapter. (
Rom. iv. 18.
compared with
Gen. xv. 5.
)
Dr. T. insists much on
1 Cor. xv. 21, 22.
“For since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead; for as in Adam all die, so in Christ shall all be made alive;” to confirm his suppositions, that the apostle in the
5th of Romans,
speaking of the death and condemnation which come by
Adam,
has respect only to the death
we all die,
when this life ends: and that
by the justification and life which come by Christ, he has respect only to the general
resurrection
at the last day. But it is observable, that his argument is wholly built on these two suppositions,
viz. First,
that the resurrection meant by the apostle,
1 Cor. xv.
is the resurrection of
all
mankind, both just and unjust.
Secondly,
That the opposite consequences of
Adam’s sin,
and Christ’s obedience, in
Rom. v.
are
the very same, neither more nor less, than are spoken of there. But there are no grounds for supposing either of these things to be true.
1. There is no evidence, that the
resurrection
there spoken of, relates both to the
just and unjust
; but abundant evidence of the contrary. The resurrection of the wicked is seldom mentioned in the New Testament, and rarely included in the meaning of the word; it being esteemed not worthy to be called a rising to life, being only for a great increase of the misery and darkness of eternal death: and therefore by the
resurrection
is most
commonly meant a rising to life and happiness.
324
The saints are called
the children of the resurrection,
as Dr. T. observes in his note on
Rom. viii. 11.
And it is exceeding evident, that it is the resurrection to life and happiness, which the apostle is speaking of in
1 Cor. xv. 21, 22.
As appears by each of the three foregoing verses.
Ver. 18.
“Then they which are fallen asleep
in Christ
(
i.
e.
the saints) are
perished.”
Ver. 19.
“If in this life only
we
(Christians or apostles) have hope in Christ, (and have no resurrection and eternal life to hope for,) we are of all men most miserable.”
Ver. 20.
“But now is Christ risen from the dead, and is become the
first-fruits
of them that slept.” He is the forerunner and first-fruits only with respect to them that are his; who are to follow him, and
partake with him in the glory and happiness of his resurrection: but he is not the first-fruits of them that shall come forth to the resurrection of
damnation.
It also appears by the verse immediately following,
ver. 23.
“But every man in his own order; Christ the first-fruits, and afterwards they that are Christ’s, at his coming.” The same is plain by what is said in
verse 29-32.
and by all
that is said from the
35th verse
to the end of the chapter, for twenty-three verses together: it there expressly appears, that the apostle is speaking only of a rising
to glory, with a glorious body,
as the little grain that is sown, being quickened, rises a beautiful flourishing plant. He there speaks of the different degrees of glory among them that shall rise, and compares it to the different degrees of glory among the celestial
luminaries. The resurrection he treats of, is expressly,
being raised in incorruption, in glory, in power, with a spiritual body, having the image of the second man,
the spiritual and heavenly
Adam
: a resurrection wherein this
corruptible shall put on incorruption, and this mortal put on immortality, and death be swallowed up in victory,
and the saints gloriously triumph over that last enemy. Dr. T. himself says what is in effect owning that the resurrection here
spoken of is only of the righteous; for it is expressly a resurrection
NOT ENGLISH
, and
NOT ENGLISH
, (
ver 53, and 42.
) But Dr. T. says,
These are never attributed to the wicked in Scripture.§
So that when the apostle says here, “As in Adam all die, so in Christ shall all be made alive;”
325
it is as much as if he had said,
As in Adam we all die,
and our bodies
are sown in corruption, in dishonour, and in weakness
:
so in Christ we all
(we Christians, whom I have been all along speaking of)
shall be raised in power, glory, and incorruption, spiritual and heavenly,
conformed to the second Adam.
For as we have borne the image of the earthy, we shall
also
bear the image of the heavenly
,
ver. 49.
Which clearly explains and determines his meaning in
ver. 21, 22.
2. There is no evidence, that the benefit by the second
Adam,
spoken of in
Rom. v.
is the very same (containing neither more nor less) as the resurrection spoken of in
1 Cor. xv.
It is no evidence of it, that the benefit is opposed to the death that comes by the first
Adam,
in like manner in both places. The resurrection to eternal life, though it be not the whole of that salvation and happiness which comes
by the second
Adam,
yet is it that wherein this salvation is principally obtained. The time of the saints’ glorious resurrection is often spoken of as the proper time of their salvation,
The day of their redemption,
the time of their adoption, glory, and recompence.
326
All that happiness which is given before, is only a prelibation and earnest of their great reward. Well therefore may that consummate salvation bestowed on them, be set in opposition to the death and ruin which comes by the first
Adam,
in like manner as the whole of their salvation is opposed to the same in
Rom. v.
Dr. T. himself observes,
¶
That the revival and resurrection of the body, is frequently put for our advancement to eternal
life.
It being the highest part, it is often put for the whole.
This notion, as if the justification, righteousness, and life spoken of in
Rom. v.
implied the resurrection of damnation, is not only without ground from Scripture, but contrary to
reason.
For those are there spoken of as great benefits, by the grace and free gift of God: but this is the contrary, in the highest degree possible; the most consummate calamity. To obviate this, our author supposes the resurrection of all to be a great
benefit
in itself,
though turned into a calamity by the sin and folly of obstinate sinners, who abuse God’s goodness. But the far greater part of mankind, since
Adam,
have never had opportunity to abuse this goodness, it having never been made known to them. Men cannot abuse a kindness, which they never had either in possession, promise, offer, or some intimation: but a resurrection is made known only by divine revelation which few comparatively have enjoyed. So that as to such
wicked men as die in lands of darkness, if their resurrection comes at all by Christ, it comes
from
him, and
to
them, only is a curse, and not a blessing; for it never comes to them at all by any
conveyance, grant, promise,
or
offer,
or any thing by which they can claim it, or know any thing of it, till it comes as an infinite calamity, past all remedy.
VIII. In a peculiar manner is there an unreasonable violence used in our author’s explanation of the words
sinners
and
sinned,
in the paragraph before us. He says, “These words,
By one man’s disobedience many were made sinners,
mean neither more nor less, than that by one man’s disobedience, the many were made subject to death, by the judicial act of God.”
327
And he says in the same place, “By death, most certainly, is meant no other than the death and mortality common to all mankind.” And those words,
ver. 12.
“For that all have sinned,” he thus explains, “All men became
sinners,
as all mankind are brought into a state of suffering.
328
Here I observe,
1. The main thing, by which he justifies such interpretations, is, that
sin,
in various instances, is used for
suffering,
in the Old Testament.
329
To which I reply; though it be true, that the original word (
NOT ENGLISH
) signifies both
sin,
and a
sin-offering—
and though this, and some other
Hebrew
words which signify sin, iniquity, and wickedness, are sometimes put for the effect or punishment of iniquity, by a metonymy of the cause for the effect—yet it does not appear, that these words are ever used for suffering, where that suffering is not a
punishment,
or a fruit of God’s anger
for sin. And therefore none of the instances he mentions, come up to his purpose. When
Lot
is commanded to leave
Sodom,
that he might not be consumed
in the iniquity
of the city, meaning in that fire which was the
effect
and
punishment
of the iniquity of the city; this is quite
another
thing, than if that fire came on the city in general, as no punishment at all, nor as any fruit of a charge of iniquity, but as a token of God’s
favour
to the
inhabitants. For according to Dr. T. the death of mankind is introduced only as a
benefit,
from a covenant of grace. And especially is this quite another thing, than if, in the expression used, the iniquity had been ascribed to
Lot
; and God, instead of saying, Lest thou be consumed in
the iniquity of the city,
had said, Lest thou be consumed
in thine iniquity,
or, Lest
thou sin,
or b
e made a sinner.
Whereas the expression is such, as expressly
removes the iniquity spoken of from
Lot,
and fixes it on the city. The place cited by our author in
Jer. li.
is exactly parallel. And as to what
Abimelech
says to
Abraham
, “What have I offended thee, that thou hast brought on me, and on my kingdom, a great
sin
?”
330
It is manifest,
Abimelech
was afraid that God was angry for what he had done to
Sarah
; or would have been angry with him, if he had done what he was about to do, as imputing
sin
to him for it. Which is a quite different thing from calling some calamity,
sin,
under no notion of its being any punishment of sin, nor in the least degree from God’s displeasure. And so with regard to every place our author cites in the margin, it is plain, that what is meant
in each of them, is
the punishment of sin,
and not some suffering which is no punishment at all. And as to the instances he mentions in his
Supplement,
(p. 8.) the two that look most favourable to his design are those in
Gen. xxxi. 39.
and
2 Kings vii. 9.
With respect to the former, where
Jacob
says,
that which was
torn of beasts,
(
NOT ENGLISH
) I
bare the loss of it.
Dr. T. is pleased to translate it,
I was the sinner
; but properly rendered, it is,
I
expiated it
; the verb in
Pihel
properly signifying to
expiate
; and the plain meaning is,
I
bore the blame of it, and was obliged to pay for it,
as being supposed to be lost through my
fault
or neglect: which is a quite different thing from suffering without any supposition of fault. And as to the latter place, where the lepers say,
this day is a day of good tidings,
and we hold our peace
:
if we tarry till morning some mischief will befall us
: in the
Hebrew
it is (
NOT ENGLISH
)
iniquity will find us,
that is, some punishment of our fault will come upon us. Elsewhere such phrases are used, as
your iniquity will find you out,
and the like. But certainly this is a different thing from suffering without fault, or supposition of fault. And it does not appear, that the verb in Hiphil, (
NOT ENGLISH
) rendered
to condemn,
is ever put for
condemn,
in any other sense than for sin, or guilt, or supposed guilt belonging to the subject condemned. This word is used in the participle of Hiphil, to signify condemning, in
Prov. xvii. 15.
“He that justifieth the wicked, and he that
condemneth
the just, even both are an abomination to the Lord.” This Dr. T. observes, as if it were to his purpose, when he is endeavouring to show, that in this place (
Rom.
v.
) the apostle speaks of God himself as
condemning the just,
or perfectly innocent, in a parallel signification of terms. Nor is any instance produced, wherein the verb
sin,
which is used by the apostle when he says,
all have sinned,
is any where used in our author’s sense, for being brought into a state of suffering, and that not as a punishment for sin, or as any thing arising from God’s displeasure; much less for being the subject of what comes only as the
fruit of divine love, and as a benefit of the highest nature.
331
Nor can any thing like this sense of the verb be found in the whole Bible.
2. If there had been any thing like such an use of the words
sin
and
sinner,
as our author supposes, in the
Old Testament,
it is evident that such an use of them is quite alien from the language of the
New Testament.
Where can an instance be produced of any thing like it, in any one place, besides what is pretended in this? and particularly in any of this apostle’s writings? We have enough of his writings, by which to learn his way of
speaking about
sin, condemnation, punishment, death,
and
suffering.
He wrote much more of the New Testament than any other person. He very often has occasion to speak of
condemnation
: but where does he express it by such a phrase as
being made sinners
? Especially how far is he elsewhere from using such a phrase, to signify being condemned without guilt, or any imputation or supposition of guilt? Vastly more still is it remote from his language, so to
use the verb
sin,
and to say, man
sinneth,
or
has sinned,
though hereby meaning nothing more nor less, than that he, by a
judicial act,
is
condemned,
according to a dispensation of
grace,
to receive a
great favour
! He abundantly uses the words
sin
and
sinner
; his writings are full of such terms; but where else does he use them in such a sense? He has much occasion in his epistles to speak of
death,
temporal and
eternal; to speak of
suffering
of all kinds, in this world, and the world to come: but where does he call these things
sin
? or denominate innocent men
sinners,
meaning, that they are brought into a state of
suffering
? If the apostle, because he was a
Jew
, was so addicted to the
Hebrew
idiom, as thus in
one
paragraph to repeat this particular
Hebraism,
which, at most, is comparatively rare even in the Old Testament; is it not
strange, that never any thing like it should appear any where else in his writings? and especially, that he should never fall into such a way of speaking in his epistle to the
Hebrews,
written to
Jews
only, who were most used to the
Hebrew
idiom? And why does
Christ
never use such language in any of his speeches, though he was born and brought up among the
Jews,
and delivered almost all his speeches to
Jews
only? And why do none of the other
New-Testament writers ever use it, who were all born and educated
Jews,
(excepting perhaps
Luke,)
and some of them wrote especially for the benefit of the
Jews
?
It is worthy to be observed, what liberty is taken and boldness is used with this apostle. Such words as
NOT ENGLISH. NOT ENGLISH ,
are abundantly used by him elsewhere in this and other epistles, when speaking, as here, of Christ’s redemption and atonement, the general sinfulness of mankind, the condemnation of sinners, the justification by Christ, death as the consequence of sin, and restoration to life by Christ; yet no where are any of these words
used, but in a sense very remote from what is supposed by Dr. T. however, in this place, it seems, these terms must have a
distinguished singular
sense annexed to them! A
new
language must be coined for the apostle, to which he is evidently quite unused, for the sake of evading this clear, precise, and abundant testimony of his, to the doctrine of original sin.
3. To put such a sense on the word
sin,
in this place, is not only to make the apostle greatly disagree with himself in the language he uses
every where else,
but also
in this very passage.
He often here uses the word
sin,
and other words plainly of the same import, such as
transgression, disobedience, offence.
Nothing can be more evident, than that these are used as several names of the same
thing; for they are used
interchangeably, and put one for another. And these words are used no less than
seventeen
times in this one paragraph. Perhaps we shall find no place in the whole Bible, in which the word
sin,
and other words plainly synonymous, are used so often in so little compass: and in all these instances, in the
proper
sense, as signifying
moral evil,
and even so understood by Dr. T. himself, (as appears by his own exposition,) but only in these two places, (
ver. 12, 19.
) where, in the midst of all, to evade a clear evidence of the doctrine of original sin, another meaning must be found out, and it must be supposed that the apostle uses the word in a sense entirely different, signifying something that neither
implies
nor
supposes
any moral evil at all in the subject.
Here it is very remarkable, how the gentleman who so greatly insisted upon it, that the word
death
must needs be understood in the
same
sense throughout this paragraph; yea, that it is
evidently, clearly,
and
infallibly
so, inasmuch as the apostle is still discoursing on the same subject; yet can, without the least difficulty, suppose the word
sin,
to be used so differently in the very same passage, wherein the apostle is
discoursing on the same thing. Let us take that one instance in
ver. 12.
“Wherefore as by one man
sin
entered into the world, and death by
sin,
and so death passed upon all men, for that all have
sinned.
“ Here, by
sin,
implied in the word
sinned,
in the end of the sentence, our author understands something perfectly and altogether
diverse
from what is meant by the word
sin,
twice in the former
part of the very same sentence, of which this latter part is the explication. And a sense entirely
different
from the use of the word twice in the
next
sentence, wherein the apostle is still most plainly discoursing on the same subject, as is not denied. And so our author himself understands
ver. 14.
Afterwards (
ver. 19.
) the apostle uses the word
sinners,
which our author supposes to
be in a somewhat different sense still. So that here is the utmost violence of the kind that can be conceived of, to make out a scheme against the plainest evidence, in changing the meaning of a word backward and forward in one paragraph, all about one thing, and in different parts of the same sentence, occurring in quick repetitions, with a variety of other synonymous words to fix its signification. To which we may add, the continued use of the word in all the preceding and subsequent parts of
this epistle; in none of which places is it pretended, but that the word is used in the proper sense, by our author in his paraphrase and notes on the whole epistle.
332
But indeed we need go no further than
ver. 12.
. What the apostle means by
sin,
in the latter part of the verse, is evident, by comparing it with the former part; the last clause being exegetical of the first. “Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that (or unto which) all have sinned.” Here
sin
and
death
are so spoken of in the
former and in the latter part that the same things are clearly meant by the terms in both parts. Besides, to interpret
sinning,
here, by falling under the suffering of
death,
is yet the more violent and unreasonable, because the apostle in this very place once and again
distinguishes
between
sin
and
death
; plainly speaking of one as the effect, and the other the cause. So in the
21st verse,
“that as
sin
hath reigned unto
death
;” and in the
12th verse,
”
sin
entered into the world, and
death
by sin.’’ And this plain distinction holds through all the discourse, as between
death
and the
offence
,
ver. 15.
and
ver. 17.
. and between the
offence and condemnation
,
ver. 18.
.
4. Though we should omit the consideration of the manner in which the apostle uses the words,
sin, sinned,
&c. in other places, and in other parts of this discourse, yet Dr. T.‘s interpretation of them would be very absurd.
The case stands thus: according to
his
exposition, we are said to have
sinned
by an
active
verb, as though we had actively sinned; yet this is not spoken truly and properly, but it is put figuratively for our becoming sinners
passively,
our being
made
or
constituted
sinners. Yet again, not that we do truly become sinners
passively,
or are really
made sinners,
by any thing that God does; this also is only a
figurative or tropical representation; and the meaning is only, we are
condemned,
and treated as if we were s
inners.
Not indeed that we are properly
condemned,
for God never truly condemns the innocent; but this also is only a figurative representation of the thing. It is but
as it were
condemning; because it is appointing to
death,
a terrible evil,
as if it were
a punishment. But then, in reality, here is no appointment to a terrible
evil,
or
any evil at all; but truly to a
benefit,
a
great
benefit; and so in representing death as a punishment, another figure is used, and an exceeding bold one; for, as we are appointed to it, it is so far from being an evil or punishment, that it is really
a favour,
and that of the highest nature, appointed by mere grace and love, though it
seems
to be a calamity.
Thus we have tropes and figures multiplied, one upon another; and all in that one word,
sinned
; according to the manner, as it is supposed, in which the apostle uses it. We have a
figurative representation,
not of a reality, but of a
figurative representation.
Neither is this a representation of a reality, but of another thing that still is but a
figurative representation
of something else: yea, even this
something else
is
still but a
figure,
and one that is very harsh and far-fetched. So that here we have
a figure
to represent a
figure,
even a
figure
of a
figure,
representing some very remote
figure,
which most obscurely represents the thing intended; if the
most terrible evil
can indeed be said at all to
represent
the contrary
good
of the highest kind. And now, what cannot be made of
any
place of Scripture, in such a way as this? And is there
any hope of ever deciding any controversy by the Scripture, in the way of using such a licence in order to force it to a compliance with our own schemes? If the apostle indeed uses language after so strange a manner in this place, it is perhaps such an instance, as not only there is not the like in all the Bible besides, but perhaps in no writing whatsoever. And this, not in any parabolical, visionary, or prophetic description, in which difficult and obscure representations are wont to be made;
nor in a dramatic or poetical representation, in which a great licence is often taken, and bold figures are commonly to be expected. But it is in a familiar letter, wherein the apostle is delivering gospel-instruction, as a minister of the New Testament: and wherein, as he professes, he delivers divine truth without the vail of ancient figures and similitudes, and uses great plainness of speech. And in a discourse that is wholly didactic, narrative, and argumentative; evidently setting himself
to explain the doctrine he is upon, in the reason and nature of it, with a great variety of expressions, turning it as it were on every side, to make his meaning plain, and to fix in his readers the exact notion of what he intends. Dr. T. himself observes,
333
“This apostle takes great care to guard and explain every part of his subject: and I may venture to say, he has left no part of it unexplained or unguarded. Never was an author more exact and cautious in this than he. Sometimes he writes notes on a sentence liable to exception, and wanting explanation.” Now I think, this care and exactness of the apostle no where appears more than in the place we are upon. Nay, I scarcely know another instance equal to this, of the apostle’s care
to be well understood, by being very particular, explicit, and precise, setting the matter forth in every light, going over and over again with his doctrine, clearly to exhibit, and fully to settle and determine the thing at which he aims.
304
Rom. v. 14.
305
There are many places parallel with these, as
John xi. 25,26.
” I am the resurrection and the life: he that believeth in me, though he were dead, yet shall he live: and whosoever liveth, and believeth in me, shall never die.” Here both the words, life and death, are used with this variation: “I am the resurrection and the life,” meaning spiritual and eternal life, “He that believeth in me, though he were dead,” having respect to temporal
death, “yet shall he live,” with respect to spiritual life, and the restoration of the life of the body. “And whosoever liveth and believeth in me, shall never die,” meaning a spiritual and eternal death. So in
John vi. 49,50.
“Your fathers did eat manna in the wilderness, and are dead,” having respect chiefly to temporal death. “This is the bread which cometh down from heaven, that a man may eat thereof, and not die,” i.e. by the loss of spiritual life, and by eternal
death. (See also ver. 58.) And in the next verse, “If any man eat of this bread, he shall live forever.” have eternal life. So ver. 54. See another like instance,
John v. 24-29.
306
Page 56.
307
Key,§ 374. where it is to be observed, that he himself puts the word ANY in capital letters. The same thing in substance is often asserted elsewhere. And this indeed is his main point in what he calls the true gospel-scheme.
308
Key, chap. viii. title, p. 44.
309
Key, § 145.
310
Page 40, 41, 43, 57. and often elsewhere.
311
See also
Job iv. 7, 8, 9.
Job xv. 17-35.
Job xviii. 5-21.
Job xix. 29.
and
Job xx. 4-8, 23-29.
Job xxi 16-18, 20-26.
Job xxii. 13-20
and
Job xxvii. 11-23
Job xxxi. 3,23
Job xxxiii. 18,22,23,24,28,30.
Job xxxiv. 11, 21-26.
Job xxxvii. 12, 18, 19, 20.
and
Job xxxviii. 13.
312
Page 117. S.
313
Page 77, 78.
314
Page 68.
315
| Page 120. S. He says to the like purpose in his note on
Rom. v. 17.
316
This is plain by what he says, p. 38, 40, 53, 117. S.
317
* Page 39, 70, 148, 27. S. See also contents of this paragraph in
Rom v.
in his notes on the epistle, and his notes on
Rom. v. 15, 16, 17.
318
† Page 119. S.
319
Page 69.
320
Page 148.
321
See
chap. ii. 1, 2, 3.
six times in these verses; also
ver. 12 and 27.
and
chap. iii. 7.
chap. viii. 1, and 3.
chap. xiv. 3. 4.
and
ver. 10, 13, 22, and 23.
322
So page 47, 49, 60,61, 62, and other places.
323
Notes on the epistle, page 284.
324
As may be observed in
Matt. xxii. 30.
Luke xx. 35, 36.
John vi. 39, 40, 54.
Philip. iii. 11.
and other places.
325
1 Cor. xv. 22.
326
As in
Luke xiv. 14.
and
xxi. 28.
Rom. viii. 23.
Eph. iv. 30.
Colos. iii. 4.
2 Thess. i.7.
2 Tim. iv. 8.
1 Pet. i. 13.
and
v. 4.
1 John iii. 2.
and other places.
327
Page 30.
328
Page 54, and elsewhere.
329
Page 34.
330
Gen. xx. 9.
331
Page 27. S.
332
Agreeably to his manner, our author, in explaining
the 7th chap. of Romans,
understands the pronoun I, or me, used by the apostle in that one continued discourse, in no less than six different senses. He takes it in
the 1st ver.
to signify the apostle Paul himself. In
the 8, 9, 10, and 11th verses,
for the people of
the Jews, through all ages, both before and after Moses, especially the carnal ungodly part of them. In
the 13th ver.
for an objecting Jew, entering into a dialogue with the apostle. In
the 15, 16, 17, 20,
and latter part of
the 25th ver.
it is understood in two different senses, for two I’s in the same person; one, a man’s reason; and the other,
his passions and carnal appetites. And in
the 7th
and former part of the last verse, for us Christians in general; or, for all that enjoy the word of God, the law and the gospel: and these different senses, the most of them strangely inter mixed and interchanged backwards and forwards.
333
Pref. to Paraph. on Rom. p. 146. 48.