The other heresies also, when the very Truth has
refuted them on the clearest evidence, are wont to be silent, being
simply confounded by their conviction. But this modern and accursed
heresy, when it is overthrown by argument, when it is cast down and
covered with shame by the very Truth, forthwith endeavours to coerce by
violence and stripes and imprisonment those whom it has been unable to
persuade by argument, thereby acknowledging itself to be anything
rather than godly. For it is the part of true godliness not to compel The
early theory about persecution seems to have been this,—that that
was a bad cause which ‘depended’ upon it, but that, when a
‘cause’ was good, there was nothing wrong in using force in
due ‘subordination’ to argument [so Pius IX. in
Encycl. ‘Quanta cura,’ speaks of the ’officium
coercendi sancitis pœnis violatores catholicæ religionis];
that there was as little impropriety in the civil magistrate’s
inducing ‘individuals’ by force, when they were incapable
of higher motives, as by those secular blessings which follow on
Christianity. Our Lord’s kingdom was not of this world, that is,
it did not depend on this world; but, as subduing, engrossing, and
swaying this world, it at times condescended to make use of this
world’s weapons against itself. The simple question was
‘whether a cause depended on force for its existence.’ S.
Athanasius declared and the event proved, that Arianism was so
dependent. When Emperors ceased to persecute, Arianism ceased to be; it
had no life in itself. Again, all cruel persecution, or long continued,
or on a large scale, was wrong, as arguing ‘an absence’ of
moral and rational grounds in the ‘cause’ so maintained.
Again, there was an evident ‘impropriety’ in ecclesiastical
functionaries using secular weapons, as there would be in their
engaging in a secular pursuit, or forming secular connections; whereas
the soldier might as suitably, and should as dutifully, defend religion
with the sword, as the scholar with his pen. And further there was an
abhorrence of cruelty natural to us, which it was a duty to cherish and
maintain. All this being considered, there is no inconsistency in S.
Athanasius denouncing persecution, and in Theodosius decreeing that
‘the heretical teachers, who usurped the sacred titles of Bishops
or Presbyters,’ should be ‘exposed to the heavy penalties
of exile and confiscation.’ Gibbon, Hist. ch. 27. For a
list of passages from the Fathers on the subject, vid. Limborch on the
Inquisition, vol. 1. Bellarmin. de Laicis, c. 21, 22, and of
authors in favour of persecution, vid. Gerhard de Magistr.
Polit. p. 741, &c. [But vide supr., Apol. Fug. 23:
‘persecution is a device of the devil;’ see also
Socr. vii. 3.], but to persuade, as I said before. Thus our
Lord Himself, not as employing force, but as offering to their free
choice, has said to all, ‘If any man will follow after Me Matt. xvi. 24.;’ and to His disciples, ‘Will ye
also go away John vi. 67.?’ This heresy, however, is
altogether alien from godliness; and therefore how otherwise should it
act, than contrary to our Saviour, seeing also that it has enlisted
that enemy of Christ, Constantius, as it were Antichrist himself Cf.
De Syn. 5, note 10., to be its leader in impiety? He for its
sake has earnestly endeavoured to emulate Saul in savage cruelty. For
when the priests gave victuals to David, Saul commanded, and they were
all destroyed, in number three hundred and five 1 Sam. xxii.
18,
LXX.;
and this man, now that all avoid the heresy, and confess a sound faith
in the Lord, annuls a Council of full three hundred Bishops, banishes
the Bishops themselves, and hinders the people from the practice of
piety, and from their prayers to God, preventing their public
assemblies. And as Saul overthrew Nob, the city of the priests, so this
man, advancing even further in wickedness, has given up the Churches to
the impious. And as he honoured Doeg the accuser before the true
priests, and persecuted David, giving ear to the Ziphites; so this man
prefers heretics to the godly, and still persecutes them that flee from
him, giving ear to his own eunuchs, who falsely accuse the orthodox. He
does not perceive that whatever he does or writes in behalf of the
heresy of the Arians, involves an attack Apol. Ar. 23.
upon the Saviour.