Chapter XI.
It cannot be proved from Scripture that the Father existed before the Son, nor yet can
arguments taken from human reproduction avail to this end, since they bring in absurdities
without end. To dare to affirm that Christ began to exist in the course of time is the height
of blasphemy.
68. You ask me whether it is possible that He Who is the Father should not be prior in
existence. I ask you to tell me when the Father existed, the Son as yet being not; prove this,
gather it from argument or evidence of Scripture. If you lean upon arguments, you have
doubtless been taught that God’s power is eternal. Again, you have read the Scripture that
saith: “O Israel, if thou wilt hearken unto Me, there shall be no new God in thee, neither
shalt thou worship a strange God.”1029 The first of these commands betokens [the Son’s]
eternity, the second His possession of an identical nature, so that we can neither believe
Him to have come into existence after the Father, nor suppose Him the Son of another Di-
vinity. For if He existed not always with the Father, He is a “new” [God]; if He is not of one
213
Divinity with the Father, He is a “strange” [God]. But He is not after the Father, for He is
not “a new God;” nor is He “a strange God,” for He is begotten of the Father, and because,
as it is written, He is “God above all, blessed for ever.”1030
69. But if the Arians believe Him to be a strange God, why do they worship Him, when
it is written: “Thou shalt worship no strange God”? Else, if they do not worship the Son, let
them confess thereto, and the case is at an end,—that they deceive no one by their professions
of religion. This, then, we see, is the witness of the Scriptures. If you have any others to
produce, it will be your business to do so.
70. Let us now go further, and gather the truth in conclusion from arguments. For al-
though arguments usually give place, even to human evidence,1031 still, heretic, argue as
thou wilt. “Experience teaches us,” you say, “that the being which generates is prior to that
which is generated.” I answer: Follow our customary experience through all its departments,
and if the rest agree herewith, I oppose not your claim that your point be granted; but if
there be no such agreement, how can you claim assent on this one point, when in all the
rest you lack support? Seeing, then, that you call for what is customary, it comes about that
the Son, when He was begotten of the Father, was a little child. You have seen Him an infant,
crying in the cradle. As the years passed, He has gone forward from strength to strength—for
if He was weak with the weakness of things begotten, He must also have fallen under the
weakness, not only of birth, but of life also.
1029 Ps. lxxxi. 9, 10.
1030 Rom. ix. 5.
1031 i.e. à priori determinations respecting any matter cannot be maintained if they are traversed by the
statements of eye-witnesses and participators in the affair.
Chapter XI. It cannot be proved from Scripture that the Father existed before the Son, nor yet can arguments taken from human reproduction avail to this end, since they bring in absurdities without end. To dare to affirm that Christ began to exist in the course of time is the height of blasphemy.
471
Chapter XI. It cannot be proved from Scripture that the Father existed before…