Himself is predicted, and the Paraclete’s doing the same to you as regards the New Testament,
where there is a similar prediction of Him. There might have been some plausibility in this,
had there been anything in the Old Testament which we denounced as a mistake, or as not
of divine authority, or as untrue. We do nothing of the kind; we receive everything, both
what we observe as rules of conduct, and what we no longer observe, but still recognize as
having been prophetical observances, once enjoined and now fulfilled. And besides, the
promise of the Paraclete is found in those books, all the contents of which you do not accept;
and His mission is recorded in the book which you shrink from even naming. For, as is
stated above, and has been said repeatedly, there is a distinct narrative in the Acts of the
Apostles of the mission of the Spirit on the day of Pentecost, and the effect produced showed
who it was. For all who first received Him spoke with tongues;1059 and in this sign there
was a promise that in all tongues, or in all nations, the Church of after times would faithfully
proclaim the doctrine of the Spirit as well as of the Father and of the Son.
16. Why, then, do you not accept everything in the New Testament? Is it because the
books have not the authority of Christ’s apostles, or because the apostles taught what was
wrong? You reply that the books have not the authority of the apostles. That the apostles
were wrong in their teaching is what Pagans say. But what can you say to prove that the
publication of these books cannot be traced to the apostles? You reply that in many things
they contradict themselves and one another. Nothing could be more untrue; the fact is, you
do not understand. In every case where Faustus has brought forward what you think a
discrepancy, we have shown that there was none; and we will do the same in every other
case. It is intolerable that the reader or learner should dare to lay the blame on Scriptures
of such high authority, instead of confessing his own stupidity. Did the Paraclete teach you
that these writings are not of the apostles’ authorship, but written by others under their
names? But where is the proof that it was the Paraclete from whom you learned this? If
you say that the Paraclete was promised and sent by Christ, we reply that your Paraclete
was neither promised nor sent by Christ; and we also show you when He sent the Paraclete
whom He promised. What proof have you that Christ sent your Paraclete? Where do you
get the evidence in support of your informant, or rather misinformant? You reply that you
find the proof in the Gospel. In what Gospel? You do not accept all the Gospel, and you
say that it has been tampered with. Will you first accuse your witness of corruption, and
then call for his evidence? To believe him when you wish it, and then disbelieve him when
you wish it, is to believe nobody but yourself. If we were prepared to believe you, there
1059 Acts ii.
576
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or…