to light upon the writings of some heretic, and, not having the knowledge requisite for dis-
cerning truth from error, he might entertain some belief contrary to the Catholic faith, yet
not condemned by the words of the creed, just as, under color of the same words, innumer-
able heretical errors have sprung up. Supposing, then, that the catechumen was under the
impression that he was studying the work of some great and learned Catholic, and was
baptized with that belief in the Catholic Church, and by subsequent research should discover
what he ought to believe, so that, embracing the Catholic faith, he should reject his former
error, ought he, on confessing this, to be baptized again? Or supposing that, before learning
and confessing this for himself, he should be found to entertain such an opinion, and should
be taught what he ought to reject and what he should believe, and it were to become clear
442
that he had held this false belief when he was baptized, ought he therefore to be baptized
again? Why should we maintain the contrary? Because the sanctity of the sacrament, con-
secrated in the words of the gospel, remains upon him in its integrity, just as he received it
from the hands of the minister, although he, being firmly rooted in the vanity of his carnal
mind entertained a belief other than was right at the time when he was baptized. Wherefore
it is manifest that it is possible that, with defective faith, the sacrament of baptism may yet
remain without defect in any man; and therefore all that is said about the diversity of the
several heretics is beside the question. For in each person that is to be corrected which is
found to be amiss by the man who undertakes his correction. That is to be made whole
which is unsound; that is to be given which is wanting, and, above all, the peace of Christian
charity, without which the rest is profitless. Yet, as the rest is there, we must not administer
it as though it were wanting, only take care that its possession be to the profit, not the hurt
of him who has it, through the very bond of peace and excellence of charity.
769
Chapter 14