fit: and that this is the ground of the judgment to condemnation, coming upon all men.” 43
But this is trifling, to a great degree: for,
1. Suffering death, and failing of possible existence, are entirely different things. If there
had never been any such thing as sin committed, there would have been infinite numbers
of possible beings, which would have failed of existence, by God’s appointment. God has
appointed (if the phrase be allowable) not to bring into existence numberless possible worlds,
each replenished with innumerable possible inhabitants. But is this equivalent to God’s ap-
pointing them all to suffer death?
2. Our author represents, that by Adam’s sin, the possible existence of his posterity fell
into the hands of the Judge, to be disposed of as he should think fit. But there was no need of
any sin of Adam, or of any body else, in order to their being brought into God’s hands, in
this respect. The future possible existence of all created beings is in God’s hands, antecedently
to the existence of any sin. And therefore, infinite numbers of possible beings, without any
relation to Adam, or any other sinning being, fail of their possible existence. And if Adam
had never sinned, yet it would be unreasonable to suppose, but that innumerable multitudes
of his possible posterity would have failed of existence by God’s disposal. For will any be so
unreasonable as to imagine, that God would and must have brought into existence as many
of his posterity as it was possible should be, if he had not sinned? Or, that then it would not
have been possible, that any other persons of his posterity should ever have existed, than
those individual persons who now actually suffer death, and return to the dust?
3. We have many accounts in Scripture, which imply the actual failing of the possible
existence of innumerable multitudes of Adam’s posterity, yea, of many more than ever come
into existence. As, of the possible posterity of Abel, the possible posterity of all them that
were destroyed by the flood, and the possible posterity of the innumerable multitudes, which
we read of in Scripture, destroyed by sword, pestilence, &c. And if the threatening to Adam
reached his posterity, in no other respect than this, that they were liable to be deprived by
it of their possible existence, then these instances are much more property a fulfilment of
that threatening, than the suffering of death by such as actually come into existence; and so
is that which is most properly the judgment to condemnation, executed by the sentence of
the Judge, proceeding on ground of that threatening. But where do we ever find this so
represented in Scripture? We read of multitudes cut off for their personal sins, who thereby
failed of their possible posterity. And these are mentioned as God’s judgments on them,
and effects of God’s condemnation of them: but when are they ever spoken of as God judi-
cially proceeding against, and condemning their possible posterity?
4. Dr. T. in what he says concerning this matter, speaks of the threatening of the law
delivered to Adam, which the possible existence of his posterity fell under, as the ground of
43 Page 95, 90, 91. S
1040
SECTION III. Adam a federal head, &c.