Basil, he says, asserts that
after we have obtained our first idea of a thing, the more minute and
accurate investigation of the thing under consideration is called
conception. And Eunomius disproves this, as he thinks, by the following
argument, that where this first, and this second notion, i.e.
one more minute and accurate than the other, are not found, the
operation which we call thought and conception does not find place.
Here, however, he will be convicted of dishonesty by all who have ears
to hear. For it was not of all thought and conception that our master
(Basil) laid down this definition, but, after making a special
subdivision of the objects of thought and conception (not to encumber
the question with too many words), and having made this part clear, he
left men of sense to reason out the whole from the part for themselves.
And as, if any one should say that we get our definition of an animal
from considering a number of animals of different species, he could not
be convicted of missing the truth in making man an instance in point,
nor would there be any need to correct him as deviating from the fact,
unless he should give the same definition of a winged, or four-footed,
or aquatic animal as of a man, so, when the points of view from which
we may consider this conception are so many and various, it is no
refutation of Basil’s statement to say that it is improperly so
called in one case because there is another species. Accordingly, even
if another species come under consideration, it by no means follows
that the one previously given is erroneously so called. Now if, says
he, one of the Apostles or Prophets could be shown to have used these
names of Christ, the falsehood would have something for its
encouragement. To what industrious study of the word of God on the part
of our opponent do not these words bear testimony! None of the Prophets
or Apostles has spoken of our Lord as Bread, or a Stone, or a Fountain,
or an Axe, or Light, or a Shepherd! What, then, saith David, and of
whom? “The Lord shepherds me.” “Thou Who shepherdest
Israel, give ear Ps. xxiii. 1; lxxx. 1. Cf.
S. John xxi. 16, 17..” What
difference does it make whether He is spoken of as shepherding, or as a
Shepherd? And again, “With Thee is the Well of life Ps. xxxvi. 9..” Does he deny that our Lord is called
a “Well”? And again, “The Stone which the builders
rejected S. Matt. xxi. 42..” And John, too,—where,
representing our Lord’s power to uproot evil under the name of an
axe, he says, “And now also the Axe is laid to the root of the
trees S. Matt. iii. 10.”—is he not a weighty and
credible witness to the truth of our words?