Chapter XVI.
Exceedingly weak is his assertion, that “the disciples of Jesus wrote such accounts regard-
ing him, by way of extenuating the charges that told against him: as if,” he says, “any one
were to say that a certain person was a just man, and yet were to show that he was guilty of
injustice; or that he was pious, and yet had committed murder; or that he was immortal,
and yet was dead; subjoining to all these statements the remark that he had foretold all these
things.” Now his illustrations are at once seen to be inappropriate; for there is no absurdity
in Him who had resolved that He would become a living pattern to men, as to the manner
in which they were to regulate their lives, showing also how they ought to die for the sake
of their religion, apart altogether from the fact that His death on behalf of men was a benefit
to the whole world, as we proved in the preceding book. He imagines, moreover, that the
whole of the confession of the Saviour’s sufferings confirms his objection instead of weak-
ening it. For he is not acquainted either with the philosophical remarks of Paul, 3264 or the
statements of the prophets, on this subject. And it escaped him that certain heretics have
declared that Jesus underwent His sufferings in appearance, not in reality. For had he
known, he would not have said: “For ye do not even allege this, that he seemed to wicked
men to suffer this punishment, though not undergoing it in reality; but, on the contrary, ye
acknowledge that he openly suffered.” But we do not view His sufferings as having been
merely in appearance, in order that His resurrection also may not be a false, but a real event.
For he who really died, actually arose, if he did arise; whereas he who appeared only to have
died, did not in reality arise. But since the resurrection of Jesus Christ is a subject of
mockery to unbelievers, we shall quote the words of Plato, 3265 that Erus the son of Armenius
rose from the funeral pile twelve days after he had been laid upon it, and gave an account
of what he had seen in Hades; and as we are replying to unbelievers, it will not be altogether
useless to refer in this place to what Heraclides 3266 relates respecting the woman who was
deprived of life. And many persons are recorded to have risen from their tombs, not only
on the day of their burial, but also on the day following. What wonder is it, then, if in the
case of One who performed many marvellous things, both beyond the power of man and
with such fulness of evidence, that he who could not deny their performance, endeavoured
to calumniate them by comparing them to acts of sorcery, should have manifested also in
His death some greater display of divine power, so that His soul, if it pleased, might leave
its body, and having performed certain offices out of it, might return again at pleasure?
And such a declaration is Jesus said to have made in the Gospel of John, when He said: “No
man taketh My life from Me, but I lay it down of Myself. I have power to lay it down, and
3264 ὅσα περὶ τούτου καὶ παρὰ τῷ Παύλῳ πεφιλοσόφηται.
3265 Cf. Plato, de Rep., x. p. 614.
3266 Cf. Plin., Nat. Hist., vii. c. 52.
Chapter XVI
955
Chapter XVI