This Marcianus is an otherwise unknown personage, unless we are to
identify him, as Salmon suggests is possible, with Marcion. The
suggestion is attractive, and the reference to Docetæ gives
it a show of probability. But there are serious objections to be urged
against it. In the first place, the form of the name, Μαρκιανός
instead of Μαρκίων. The two names are by no means identical. Still, according to
Harnack, we have more than once Μαρκιανοί
and Μαρκιανισταί
for Μαρκιωνισταί
(see his Quellenkritik d. Gesch. d.
Gnosticismus, p. 31 sqq.). But again, how can Marcion have used, or
his name been in any way connected with, a Gospel of Peter?
Finally, the impression left by this passage is that
“Marcianus” was a man still living, or at any rate alive
shortly before Serapion wrote, for the latter seems only recently to
have learned what his doctrines were. He certainly cannot have been so
ignorant of the teachings of the great “heresiarch”
Marcion. We must, in fact, regard the identification as
improbable.