Chapter VI.—The Two Principles of the Manichæans; Themselves Controverted; The
Pythagorean Opinion Respecting First Principles; Good and Evil Contrary; The Victory on
the Side of Good.
They lay down two principles, God and Matter. If he (Manes) separates that which
comes into being from that which really exists, the supposition is not so faulty in this, that
neither does matter create itself, nor does it admit two contrary qualities, in being both
active and passive; nor, again, are other such theories proposed concerning the creative
cause as it is not lawful to speak of. And yet God does not stand in need of matter in order
to make things, since in His mind all things substantially exist, so far as the possibility of
their coming into being is concerned. But if, as he seems rather to mean, the unordered
motion of things really existent under Him is matter, first, then, he unconsciously sets up
another creative cause (and yet an evil one), nor does he perceive what follows from this,
namely, that if it is necessary that God and matter should be supposed, some other matter
must be supposed to God; so that to each of the creative causes there should be the subject
matter. Therefore, instead of two, he will be shown to give us four first principles. Wonderful,
too, is the distinction. For if he thinks this to be God, which is good, and wishes to conceive
of something opposite to Him, why does he not, as some of the Pythagoreans, set evil over
against Him? It is more tolerable, indeed, that two principles should be spoken of by them,
the good and the evil, and that these are continually striving, but the good prevails. For if
the evil were to prevail, all things would perish. Wherefore matter, by itself, is neither body,
nor is it exactly incorporeal, nor simply any particular thing; but it is something indefinite,
which, by the addition of form, comes to be defined; as, for instance, fire is a pyramid, air
an octahedron, water an eikosahedron, and earth a cube; how, then, is matter the unordered
motion of the elements? By itself, indeed, it does not subsist, for if it is motion, it is in that
which is moved; but matter does not seem to be of such a nature, but rather the first subject,
and unorganized, from which other things proceed. Since, therefore, matter is unordered
motion, was it always conjoined with that which is moved, or was it ever separate from it?
For, if it were ever by itself, it would not be in existence; for there is no motion without
something moved. But if it was always in that which is moved, then, again, there will be two
principles—that which moves, and that which is moved. To which of these two, then, will
it be granted that it subsists as a primary cause along with God?
The Two Principles of the Manichæans; Themselves Controverted; The Pythagorean Opinion Respecting First Principles; Good and Evil Contrary; The Victory on the Side of Good.
568
The Two Principles of the Manichæans; Themselves Controverted; The Pythagorean…