closest union with Them. For if the heaven, and the earth, and all created things were really
made through the Son and from the Father, but apart from the Spirit, what was the Holy
Spirit doing at the time when the Father was at work with the Son upon the Creation? Was
He employed upon some other works, and was this the reason that He had no hand in the
building of the Universe? But, then, what special work of the Spirit have they to point to, at
the time when the world was being made? Surely, it is senseless folly to conceive of a creation
other than that which came into existence from the Father through the Son. Well, suppose
that He was not employed at all, but dissociated Himself from the busy work of creating by
reason of an inclination to ease and rest, which shrank from toil?
May the gracious Spirit Himself pardon this baseless supposition of ours! The blasphemy
of these theorists, which we have had to follow out in every step it takes, has caused us un-
wittingly to soil our discussion with the mud of their own imaginings. The view which is
consistent with all reverence is as follows. We are not to think of the Father as ever parted
from the Son, nor to look for the Son as separate from the Holy Spirit. As it is impossible
to mount to the Father, unless our thoughts are exalted thither through the Son, so it is
impossible also to say that Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit. Therefore, Father, Son,
and Holy Spirit are to be known only in a perfect Trinity, in closest consequence and union
with each other, before all creation, before all the ages, before anything whatever of which
we can form an idea1244. The Father is always Father, and in Him the Son, and with the Son
the Holy Spirit. If these Persons, then, are inseparate from each other, how great is the folly
of these men who undertake to sunder this indivisibility by certain distinctions of time, and
so far to divide the Inseparable as to assert confidently, “the Father alone, through the Son
alone, made all things”; the Holy Spirit, that is, being not present at all on the occasion of
this making, or else not working. Well, if He was not present, they must tell us where He
was; and whether, while God embraces all things, they can imagine any separate standing-
place for the Spirit, so that He could have remained in isolation during the time occupied
320
by the process of creating. If, on the other hand, He was present, how was it that He was
inactive? Because He could not, or because He would not, work? Did He abstain willingly,
or because some strong necessity drove Him away? Now, if He deliberately embraced this
inactivity, He must reject working in any other possible way either; and He Who affirmed
that “He worketh all things in all, as He wills1245,” is according to them a liar. If, on the
contrary, this Spirit has the impulse to work, but some overwhelming control hinders His
design, they must tell us the wherefore of this hindrance. Was it owing to his being grudged
a share in the glory of those operations, and in order to secure that the admiration at their
success should not extend to a third person as its object; or to a distrust of His help, as if
1244 πρὸ πάσης καταληπτῆς ἐπινοίας.
1245 1 Cor. xiii. 6.
595
On the Holy Spirit.