Nestorius, therefore, must be anathematized for
believing the Blessed Virgin Mary to be mother of His manhood only,
whereby he made the person of His flesh one thing, and that of His
Godhead another, and did not recognize the one Christ in the Word of
God and in the flesh, but spoke of the Son of
God as separate and distinct from the son of
man: although, without losing that unchangeable essence which
belongs to Him together with the Father and the Holy Spirit from all
eternity and without respect of time, the “Word became
flesh” within the Virgin’s womb in such wise that by that
one conception and one parturition she was at the same time, in virtue
of the union of the two substances, both handmaid and mother of the
Lord. This Elizabeth also knew, as Luke
the evangelist declares, when she said: “Whence is this to
me that the mother of my Lord should come to
me Luke i. 43.?” But Eutyches also must be
stricken with the same anathema, who, becoming entangled in the
treacherous errors of the old heretics, has chosen the third dogma of
Apollinaris Cf. Ep. xxii. chap. 3
“conatus-antiqua impii Valentini” (the adherent of
Apollinaris and head of one of the sections of the Apollinarians after
his death) “et Apollinaris mala dogmata
renovare.” The third dogma of Apollinaris was that
“Christ’s manhood was formed out of a divine
substance.” Bright, 147.: so that he
denies the reality of his human flesh and soul, and maintains the whole
of our Lord Jesus Christ to be of one nature,
as if the Godhead of the Word had turned itself into flesh and
soul: and as if to be conceived and born, to be nursed and grow,
to be crucified and die, to be buried and rise again, and to ascend
into heaven and to sit on the Father’s right hand, from whence He
shall come to judge the living and the dead—as if all those
things belonged to that essence only which admits of none of
them
without the
reality of the flesh: seeing that the nature of the Only-begotten
is the nature of the Father, the nature of the Holy Spirit, and that
the undivided unity and consubstantial equality of the eternal Trinity
is at once impassible and unchangeable. But if Eutyches had expressly
tried to guard himself against this imputation: Ep. xxi. chap. 3,
“anathematizans Apollinarium Valentinum, Manem et Nestorium,
&c.” See Bright’s valuable notes 32, 33, 34,
and esp. 35, where he shows that “it was polemical rhetoric to
say that he was reviving Apollinarian or Valentinian
theories.”
this heretic withdraws from the perverse views of Apollinaris, lest he
be proved to hold that the Godhead is passible It must be clearly
understood that this ugly word is here and elsewhere employed to
translate passibilis (παθητός) for no
reason, except the necessity of the case: pati and
πάσχειν are both of
far wider and broader signification than “suffer” or its
synonyms: they are simply the passive of facere and
ποιεῖν (πράσσειν),
and there is no proper equivalent in ordinary English parlance.
This tendency of terms to become more and more narrow and of particular
application is constantly meeting and baffling one in translating the
Latin and Greek languages. and
mortal: and yet dares to pronounce the nature of the Incarnate
Word that is of the Word made Flesh one, he undoubtedly crosses over
into the mad view of Manichæus Leo elsewhere also
makes this hardly justifiable inference that Eutychianism is a new form
of Docetism as this view was called; chap. vi. below, and Serm. lxv. c.
4 “isti phantasmatici Christiani,” also xxviii. 4,
and lxiv. 1, 2. That the Manichæans naturally held Docetic
views on the Incarnation is obvious when we remember that their
fundamental misconception was that matter is identical with evil. and
Marcion Marcion was the
founder of one of the most formidable Gnostic sects towards the close
of the second century: Tertullian wrote a famous treatise (still
extant) against him. Like other Gnostics, his views involved him
in Docetism., and believes that the man Jesus Christ,
the mediator between God and men, did all
things in an unreal way, and had not a human body, but that a
phantom-like apparition presented itself to the beholders’
eyes.