Let us now see the remaining
results of his expertness in dealing with words; results, which he
himself truly says, are at once ridiculous and lamentable. Truly one
must laugh outright at what he says, if a deep lament for the error
that steeps his soul were not more fitting. Whereas Father, as we
teach, includes, according to one of its meanings, the idea of the
Ungenerate, he transfers the full signification of the word Father to
that of the Ungenerate, and declares “If Father is the same as
Ungenerate, it is allowable for us to drop it, and use Ungenerate
instead; thus, the Ungenerate of the Son is Ungenerate; for as the
Ungenerate is Father of the Son, so reversely the Father is Ungenerate
of the Son.” After this a feeling of admiration for our
friend’s adroitness steals over me, with the conviction that the
many-sided subtlety of his theological training is quite beyond the
capacity of most. What our Teacher said was embraced in one short
sentence, to the effect that it was possible that by the title
‘Father’ the Ungeneracy could be signified; but
Eunomius’ words depend for their number not on the variety of the
thoughts, but on the way that anything within the circuit of similar
names can be turned about ἐν τῇ
περιόδῳ καὶ
ἀναστροφῇ
τῶν ὁμοίων
ῥημάτων.. As the cattle that
run blindfold round to turn the mill remain with all their travel in
the same spot, so does he go round and round the same topic, and never
leaves it. Once he said, ridiculing us, that ‘Father’ does
not signify the having begotten, but the being from nothing. Again he
wove a similar dilemma, “If Father signifies Ungeneracy, before
He begat He was not ungenerate.” Then a third time he resorts to
the same trick. “It is allowable for us to drop Father, and to
use Ungenerate instead;” and then directly he repeats the logic
so often vomited. “For as the Ungenerate is Father of the Son, so
reversely the Father is Ungenerate of the Son.” How often he
returns to his vomit; how often he blurts it out again! Shall we not,
then, annoy most people, if we drag about our argument in company with
this foolish display of words? It would be perhaps more decent to be
silent in a case like this; still, lest any one should think that we
decline discussion because we are weak in pleas, we will answer thus to
what he has said. ‘You have no authority, Eunomius, for calling
the Father the Ungenerate of the Son, even though the title Father
does signify that the Begetter was from no cause Himself. For
as, to take the example already cited, when we hear the word
‘Emperor’ we understand two things, both that the one who
is pre-eminent in authority is subject to none, and also that he
controls his inferiors, so the title Father supplies us with two ideas
about the Deity, one relating to His Son, the other to His being
dependent on no preconceivable cause. As, then, in the case of
‘Emperor’ we cannot say that because the two things are
signified by that term, viz., the ruling over subjects and the not
having any to take precedence of him, there is any justification for
speaking of the ‘Unruled of subjects,’ instead of the
‘Ruler of the nation,’ or allowing so much, that we may use
such a juxtaposition of words, in imitation of king of a nation, as
kingless of a nation, in the same way when ‘Father’
indicates a Son, and also represents the idea of the Ungenerate, we may
not unduly transfer this latter meaning, so as to attach this idea of
the Ungenerate fast to a paternal relationship, and absurdly say
‘the Ungenerate is Ungenerate of the Son.’