It
was usual to say against the Apollinarians, that, unless our Lord took
on Him our nature, as it is, He had not purified and changed it,
as it is, but another nature; ‘The Lord came not to save Adam as
free from sin, that He should become like unto him; but as, in the net
of sin and now fallen, that God’s mercy might raise him up with
Christ.’ Leont. contr. Nestor. &c. ii. p. 996.
Accordingly, Athan. says elsewhere, ‘Had not sinlessness appeared
[cf. Rom. viii. 3, πέμψας]
“in the nature which had sinned,” how was sin condemned in
the flesh?’ in Apoll. ii. 6. ‘It was necessary for
our salvation,’ says S. Cyril, ‘that the Word of God should
become man, that human flesh “subject to corruption” and
“sick with the lust of pleasures,” He might make His own;
and, “whereas He is life and lifegiving,” He might
“destroy the corruption,” &c.…For by this means,
might sin in our flesh become dead.’ Ep. ad Success. i. p.
138. And S. Leo, ‘Non alterius naturæ erat ejus caro quam
nostra, nec alio illi quam cæteris hominibus anima est inspirata
principio, quæ excelleret, non diversitate generis, sed
sublimitate virtutis.’ Ep. 35 fin. vid. also Ep.
28. 3. Ep. 31. 2. Ep. 165. 9. Serm. 22. 2. and 25.
5. It may be asked whether this doctrine does not interfere with that
of the immaculate conception [i.e. that Christ was conceived
sinless]; but that miracle was wrought in order that our Lord might not
be born in original sin, and does not affect, or rather includes, His
taking flesh of the substance of the Virgin, i.e. of a fallen nature.
If indeed sin were ‘of the substance’ of our fallen nature,
as some heretics have said, then He could not have taken our nature
without partaking our sinfulness; but if sin be, as it is, a fault of
the will, then the Divine Power of the Word could sanctify the
human will, and keep it from swerving in the direction of evil. Hence
‘We say not that Christ by the felicity of a flesh separated from
sense could not feel the desire of sin, but that by perfection
of virtue, and by a flesh not begotten through concupiscence of the
flesh, He had not the desire of sin;’ Aug. Op.
Imperf. iv. 48. On the other hand, S. Athanasius expressly calls it
Manichean doctrine to consider τὴν φύσιν of the flesh ἁμαρτίαν, καὶ
οὐ τὴν
πρᾶξιν.
contr. Apoll. i. 12 fin. or φυσικὴν
εἶναι τὴν
ἁμαρτίαν. ibid. i. 14 fin. His argument in the next ch. is on the ground
that all natures are from God, but God made man upright nor is
the author of evil (vid. also Vit. Anton. 20); ‘not as
if,’ he says, ‘the devil wrought in man a nature (God
forbid!) for of a nature the evil cannot be maker (δημιουργὸς) as is the impiety of the Manichees, but he wrought a bias
of nature by transgression, and ‘so death reigned over all
men.’ Wherefore, saith he, ‘the Son of God came to destroy
the works of the devil;’ what works? that nature, which God made
sinless, and the devil biassed to the transgression of God’s
command and the finding out of sin which is death, did God the Word
raise again, so as to be secure from the devil’s bias and the
finding out of sin. And therefore the Lord said, “The prince of
this world cometh and findeth nothing in Me.”’ vid. also
§19. Ibid. ii. 6. he speaks of the devil having ‘introduced
the law of sin.’ vid. also §9.