pentance; the very nature of it is to acknowledge our own utter sinfulness and unworthiness,
and to renounce our own goodness, and all confidence in self; and so to trust in the propiti-
ation of the Mediator, and ascribe all the glory of forgiveness to him.
Object. 6. The last objection I shall mention, is that paragraph in the 3d chapter of
James, where persons are said expressly to be justified by works: Ver. 21. “Was not Abraham
our father justified by works?” Ver. 24. “Ye see then how that by works a man is justified,
and not by faith only.” Ver. 25. “Was not Rahab the harlot justified by works?”
In answer to this objection, I would,
650
1. Take notice of the great unfairness of the divines that oppose us, in the improvement
they make of this passage against us. All will allow, that in that proposition of St. James, “By
works a man is justified, and not by faith only,” one of the terms, either the word faith, or
else the word justify, is not to be understood precisely in the same sense as the same terms
when used by St. Paul; because they suppose, as well as we, that it was not the intent of the
apostle James to contradict St. Paul in that doctrine of justification by faith alone, in which
he had instructed the churches. But if we understand both the terms, as used by each apostle,
in precisely the same sense, then what one asserts is a precise, direct, and full contradiction
of the other, the one affirming and the other denying the very same thing. So that all the
controversy from this text comes to this, viz. which of these two terms shall be understood
in a diversity from St. Paul. They say that it is the word faith; for they suppose, that when
the apostle Paul uses the word, and makes faith that by which alone we are justified, that
then by it is understood a compliance with and practice of Christianity in general; so as to
include all saving christian virtue and obedience. But as the apostle James uses the word
faith in this place, they suppose thereby is to be understood only an assent of the understand-
ing to the truth of gospel doctrines, as distinguished from good works, and that may exist
separate from them, and from all saving grace. We, on the other hand, suppose that the
word justify is to be understood in a different sense from the apostle Paul. So that they are
forced to go as far in their scheme, in altering the sense of terms from Paul’s use of them,
as we. But yet at the same time that they freely vary the sense of the former of them, viz.
faith, yet when we understand the latter, viz. justify, in a different sense from St. Paul, they
exclaim against us. What necessity of framing this distinction, but only to serve an opinion?
At this rate a man may maintain any thing, though never so contrary to Scripture, and elude
the clearest text in the Bible! though they do not show us why we have not as good warrant
to understand the word justify in a diversity from St. Paul, as they the word faith. If the sense
of one of the words must be varied on either scheme, to make the apostle James’s doctrine
consistent with the apostle Paul’s; and if varying the sense of one term or the other be all
that stands in the way of their agreeing with either scheme; and if varying the sense of the
latter be in itself as fair as of the former, then the text lies as fair for one scheme as the other,
2454
DISCOURSE. II. Pressing into the Kingdom of God.