is tantamount, as we have said, to not at all? For as humanity is not possible to that which
53
does not possess the complete connotation of the term ‘man,’ and the whole conception of
it is cancelled in the case of one who lacks any of the properties, so in every thing whose
complete and proper existence is denied, the partial affirmation of its existence is no proof
of its subsisting at all; the demonstration, in fact, of its incomplete being is a demonstration
of its effacement in all points. So that if he is well-advised, he will come over to the orthodox
belief, and remove from his teaching the idea of less and of incompleteness in the nature of
the Son and the Spirit: but if he is determined to blaspheme, and wishes for some inscrutable
reason thus to requite his Maker and God and Benefactor, let him at all events part with his
conceit of possessing some amount of showy learning, unphilosophically piling, as he does,
being over being, one above the other, one proper, one not such, for no discoverable reason.
We have never heard that any of the infidel philosophers have committed this folly, any
more than we have met with it in the inspired writings, or in the common apprehension of
mankind.
I think that from what has been said it will be clear what is the aim of these newly-devised
names. He drops them as the base of operations or foundation-stone of all this work of
mischief to the Faith: once he can get the idea into currency that the one Being alone is su-
preme and proper in the highest degree, he can then assail the other two, as belonging to
the inferior and not regarded as properly Being. He shows this especially in what follows,
where he is discussing the belief in the Son and the Holy Spirit, and does not proceed with
these names, so as to avoid bringing before us the proper characteristic of their nature by
means of those appellations: they are passed over unnoticed by this man who is always
telling us that minds of the hearers are to be directed by the use of appropriate names and
phrases. Yet what name could be more appropriate than that which has been given by the
Very Truth? He sets his views against the Gospel, and names not the Son, but ‘a Being existing
through the First, but after It though before all others.’ That this is said to destroy the right
faith in the Only-begotten will be made plainer still by his subsequent arguments. Still there
is only a moderate amount of mischief in these words: one intending no impiety at all towards
Christ might sometimes use them: we will therefore omit at present all discussion about our
Lord, and reserve our reply to the more open blasphemies against Him. But on the subject
of the Holy Spirit the blasphemy is plain and unconcealed: he says that He is not to be ranked
with the Father or the Son, but is subject to both. I will therefore examine as closely as possible
this statement.
100
He does wrong in making the being of the Father alone proper and supreme,…