Although other synods are mentioned by the Libellus
synodicus (of the ninth century), the only ones which we have good
reason for accepting are those mentioned by Eusebius in this chapter
and the next; viz. one in Palestine (the Libellus synodicus
gives two: one at Jerusalem, presided over by Narcissus, and another at
Cæsarea, presided over by Theophilus, but the report is too late
to be of authority); one in Pontus, under the presidency of Palmas; one
in Gaul, under Irenæus; one in Osrhoëne in Mesopotamia; and
one in Asia Minor, under Polycrates. Hefele (Conciliengesch. I.
p. 101) adds one in Rome under Victor; and although Eusebius does not
distinctly mention such a synod, we are undoubtedly to conclude that
the epistle written by Victor was a synodical epistle and hence Hefele
is, in all probability, correct in assuming that some kind of a synod,
whether municipal or provincial, took place there at this time (see
note 4). From the words of Eusebius at the close of the chapter, we may
gather that still other synods than those mentioned by him were held on
this subject. The date of all of these councils is commonly given as
198 a.d., but there is no particular authority
for that year. Jerome’s version of the Chron. assigns the
composition of the various epistles to the fourth year of Septimius
Severus (196–197); but it is clear that he is giving only an
approximate date. We can say only that the synods took place sometime
during Victor’s episcopate. All the councils, as we learn from
this chapter, except the one under Polycrates in Asia Minor, decided
against the Quartodeciman practice. Athanasius, however (de Syn.
c. 5), speaks of Christians of Syria, Cilicia, and Mesopotamia as
celebrating the paschal feast on the fourteenth day; and Jerome (de
vir. ill. c. 35) says that many bishops of Asia and of the
Orient kept up this observance. It is possible that the practice
was from the beginning more widely spread than Eusebius supposed, or,
what is more probable, that the words of Athanasius and Jerome refer to
individual churches and bishops, whose observance of the fourteenth day
was not general enough to invalidate what Eusebius says of the common
consent of the whole Church, outside of Asia Minor, against the
Quartodeciman practice, and that this individual observance, not being
officially recognized by any synod, did not seem to him to require
mention.