43. Now why it was that, though He knew, He did
not tell His disciples plainly at that time, no one may be curious Cf.
§18, n. 3. where He has been silent; for ‘Who
hath known the mind of the Lord, or who hath been His counsellor Rom. xi. 34.?’ but why, though He knew, He said,
‘no, not the Son knows,’ this I think none of the faithful
is ignorant, viz. that He made this as those other declarations as man
by reason of the flesh. For this as before is not the Word’s
deficiency Or. i. 45., but of that human nature Cf.
ii. 45, n. 2. whose property it is to be ignorant. And
this again will be well seen by honestly examining into the occasion,
when and to whom the Saviour spoke thus. Not then when the heaven was
made by Him, nor when He was with the Father Himself, the Word
‘disposing all things Prov. viii.
27,
LXX.,’ nor before
He became man did He say it, but when ‘the Word became flesh John i. 14..’ On this account it is reasonable to
ascribe to His manhood everything which, after He became man, He speaks
humanly. For it is proper to the Word to know what was made, nor be
ignorant either of the beginning or of the end of these (for the works
are His), and He knows how many things He wrought, and the limit of
their consistence. And knowing of each the beginning and the end, He
knows surely the general and common end of all. Certainly when He says
in the Gospel concerning Himself in His human character, ‘Father,
the hour is come, glorify Thy Son Ib. xvii. 1.,’ it is
plain that He knows also the hour of the end of all things, as the
Word, though as man He is ignorant of it, for ignorance is proper to
man Though our Lord, as having two natures, had a human as well as a
divine knowledge, and though that human knowledge was not only limited
because human, but liable to ignorance in matters in which greater
knowledge was possible; yet it is the doctrine of the [later] Church,
that in fact He was not ignorant even in His human nature,
according to its capacity, since it was from the first taken out of its
original and natural condition, and ‘deified’ by its union
with the Word. As then (supr. ii. 45, note 1) His manhood was
created, yet He may not be called a creature even in His manhood, and
as (supr. ii. 14, note 5) His flesh was in its abstract nature a
servant, yet He is not a servant in fact, even as regards the flesh;
so, though He took on Him a soul which left to itself had been
partially ignorant, as other human souls, yet as ever enjoying the
beatific vision from its oneness with the Word, it never was ignorant
really, but knew all things which human soul can know. vid. Eulog.
ap. Phot. 230. p. 884. As Pope Gregory expresses it,
‘Novit in natura, non ex natura humanitatis.’ Epp.
x. 39. However, this view of the sacred subject was received by the
Church only after S. Athanasius’s day, and it cannot be denied
that others of the most eminent Fathers seem to impute ignorance to our
Lord as man, as Athan. in this passage. Of course it is not meant that
our Lord’s soul has the same perfect knowledge as He has as God.
This was the assertion of a General of the Hermits of S. Austin at the
time of the Council of Basel, when the proposition was formally
condemned, animam Christi Deum videre tam clare et intense quam clare
et intense Deus videt seipsum. vid. Berti Opp. t. 3. p. 42. Yet
Fulgentius had said, ‘I think that in no respect was full
knowledge of the Godhead wanting to that Soul, whose Person is one with
the Word: whom Wisdom so assumed that it is itself that same
Wisdom.’ ad Ferrand. iii. p. 223. ed. 1639. Yet, ad
Trasmund. i. 7. he speaks of ignorance attaching to our
Lord’s human nature., and especially ignorance of these things.
Moreover this is proper to the Saviour’s love of man; for since
He was made man, He is not ashamed, because of the flesh which is
ignorant Cf.
§48., to say ‘I know not,’ that
He may shew that knowing as God, He is but ignorant according to the
flesh And
so Athan. ad Serap. ii. 9. S. Basil on the question being asked
him by S. Amphilochius, says that he shall give him the answer he had
‘heard from a boy from the fathers,’ but which was more
fitted for pious Christians than for cavillers, and that is, that
‘our Lord says many things to men in His human aspect; as
“Give me to drink,”…yet He who asked was not flesh
without a soul, but Godhead using flesh which had one.’
Ep. 236, 1. He goes on to suggest another explanation which has
been mentioned §42, note 1. Cf. Cyril Trin. pp. 623, 4.
vid. also Thes. p. 220. ‘As he submitted as man to hunger
and thirst, so.…to be ignorant.” p. 221. vid. also Greg.
Naz. Orat. 30, 15. Theodoret expresses the same opinion very
strongly, speaking of a gradual revelation to the manhood from the
Godhead, but in an argument where it was to his point to do so; in
Anath. 4. t. v. p. 23. ed. Schulze. Theodore of Mopsuestia also
speaks of a revelation made by the Word. ap. Leont. c. Nest
(Canis. i. p. 579.). And therefore He said not, ‘no, not
the Son of God knows,’ lest the Godhead should seem ignorant, but
simply, ‘no, not the Son,’ that the ignorance might be the
Son’s as born from among men.