Some one accordingly asked them whether the Word of God
could be changed, as the devil has been? and they feared not to say,
‘Yes, he could; for being begotten, he is susceptible of
change.’ We then, with the bishops of Egypt and Libya, being
assembled together to the number of nearly a hundred, have
anathematized Arius for his shameless avowal of these heresies,
together with all such as have countenanced them. Yet the partisans of
Eusebius have received them; endeavoring to blend falsehood with truth,
and that which is impious with what is sacred. But they shall not
prevail, for the truth must triumph; and ‘light has no fellowship
with darkness, nor has Christ any concord with Belial.’
2 Cor. vi.
14.
Who ever heard such blasphemies? or what man of any piety is there now
hearing them that is not horror-struck, and stops his ears, lest the
filth of these expressions should pollute his sense of hearing? Who
that hears John saying, ‘In the beginning was the Word,’
John i.
1–3, 18.
does not condemn those that say, ‘There was a period when the
Word was not’? or who, hearing in the Gospel of ‘the
only-begotten Son,’ and that ‘all things were made by
him,’ will not abhor those that pronounce the Son to be one of
the things made? How can he be one of the things which were made by
himself? Or how can he be the only-begotten, if he is reckoned among
created things? And how could he have had his existence from
nonentities, since the Father has said, ‘My heart has indited a
good matter’;
Ps. xliv. 1,
according to the LXX.
and ‘I begat thee out of my bosom before the dawn’?
῾Εωσφόρον, the
morning-star; taken from Ps. cix. 3.
Cf. the LXX, quoted from Ps.
lxxii.
Or how is he unlike the Father’s essence, who is ‘his
perfect image,’
Col. i.
15.
and ‘the brightness of his glory’
Heb. i.
3.
and says: ‘He that hath seen me, hath seen the Father’?
Again how if the Son is the Word and Wisdom of God, was there a period
when he did not exist? for that is equivalent to their saying that God
was once destitute both of Word and Wisdom. How can he be mutable and
susceptible of change, who says of himself, ‘I am in the Father,
and the Father in me’;
John xiv.
10.
and ‘I and the Father are one’;
John x.
30.
and again by the Prophet,
Mal. iii.
6.
‘Behold me because I am, and have not changed’? But if any
one may also apply the expression to the Father himself, yet would it
now be even more fitly said of the Word; because he was not changed by
having become man, but as the Apostle says,
Heb. xiii.
8.
‘Jesus Christ, the same yesterday, to-day, and forever.’
But what could persuade them to say that he was made on our account,
when Paul has expressly declared
Heb. ii.
10.
that ‘all things are for him, and by him’? One need not
wonder indeed at their blasphemous assertion that the Son does not
perfectly know the Father; for having once determined to fight against
Christ, they reject even the words of the Lord himself, when he says,
John x.
15.
‘As the Father knows me, even so know I the Father.’ If
therefore the Father but partially knows the Son, it is manifest that
the Son also knows the Father but in part. But if it would be improper
to affirm this, and it be admitted that the Father perfectly knows the
Son, it is evident that as the
Father knows his own Word, so also does the Word know his own Father,
whose Word he is. And we, by stating these things, and unfolding the
divine Scriptures, have often confuted them: but again as chameleons
they were changed, striving to apply to themselves that which is
written, ‘When the ungodly has reached the depths of iniquity, he
becomes contemptuous.’
Prov.
xviii. 3, according to the
LXX.
Many heresies have arisen before these, which exceeding all bounds in
daring, have lapsed into complete infatuation: but these persons, by
attempting in all their discourses to subvert the Divinity of The Word, as having made a nearer approach to
Antichrist, have comparatively lessened the odium of former ones.
Wherefore they have been publicly repudiated by the Church, and
anathematized. We are indeed grieved on account of the perdition of
these persons, and especially so because, after having been previously
instructed in the doctrines of the Church, they have now apostatized
from them. Nevertheless we are not greatly surprised at this, for
Hymenæus and Philetus
2 Tim. ii.
17, 18.
fell in like manner; and before them Judas, who had been a follower of
the Saviour, but afterwards deserted him and became his betrayer. Nor
were we without forewarning respecting these very persons: for the Lord
himself said: ‘Take heed that no man deceive you: for many shall
come in my name, saying, I am Christ: and shall many deceive
many’;
Matt. xxiv.
4.
and ‘the time is at hand; Go ye not therefore after them.’
Luke xxi.
8.
And Paul, having learned these things from the Saviour, wrote,
‘That in the latter times some should apostatize from the faith,
giving heed to deceiving spirits, and doctrines of devils,’
1 Tim. iv.
1; Tit. i. 14.
who pervert the truth. Seeing then that our Lord and Saviour Jesus
Christ has himself enjoined this, and has also by the apostle given us
intimation respecting such men, we having ourselves heard their impiety
have in consequence anathematized them, as we before said, and declared
them to be alienated from the Catholic Church and faith. Moreover we
have intimated this to your piety, beloved and most honored
fellow-ministers, in order that ye might neither receive any of them,
if they should presume to come to you, nor be induced to put confidence
in Eusebius, or any other who may write to you about them. For it is
incumbent on us who are Christians, to turn away from all those who
speak or entertain a thought against Christ, as from those who are
resisting God, and are destroyers of the souls of men: neither does it
become us even ‘to salute such men,’
2 John 10,
11.
as the blessed John has prohibited, ‘lest we should at any time
be made partakers of their sins.’ Greet the brethren which are
with you; those who are with me salute you.